YouTube Commentary Community - You know shit's about to get real when the cartoon avatar crosses their arms!

I'm sorry but the way I see it, I don't think Idubbbz was this big game changer that Tom likes to boast about.
The Keemstar video didn't do shit to his career in the long run. He still around today, still has a following and is even getting into the boxing seen. All that video did was just made Keem the person to hate that week because Idubbbz said he sucks so he sucks now. And like you said only a logs like h3h3 give a shit
Like with Keem, Leafy just because the person to shit on that week. But unlike Keem, Leafy went into hiding for years. And that was mostly do his dumbass making the situation worse.
And even then, when Leafy left other youtuber started to emulate Leafys style of video, and a lot of them were gaining a ton of attention from it.
At the end of the day, people only change because they were leeching off the success of Idubbbz. It was all just a desperate attempt to keep themselves from going irrelevant. And you can see how well that worked out for them in the end
The whole "either all of them are okay or none of them are okay" slur discourse was good but, to bring up h3h3 again, you don't see him living by this at all. As for the whole wanting outsiders to care about my opinion, most outsiders think I'm ether a Nazi or a Tranny. So I don't really see the point of doing so
Again sorry Sprate Header but I'm gonna have to disagree with you on this
Respectfully disagree. I think idubbbz did change the commentary scene and you can still see this today in the number of people trying to recapture that "Content Cop" energy plus they were a relatively big event when they were new.

That said who fucking cares?

Idubbz fell off and the commentary community fell off. It was only ever relevant because normies followed it in 2015 but that was forever ago in internet years and now that revelation is about as relevant as Sargon redefining "skeptic" YouTube. No one who isn't in this space could tell you a single event of any real significance to happen in this arena in years.

If you are going to do a takedown video in current year and you are following the content cop formula it's like trying to make a hit movie and using early 2000's teen comedies as the blueprint. The format had it's time but it's stale. All the interesting people moved on to other things and now it's mostly lazy grifters picking at the scraps.
 
I got 7 minutes into this and he's jerking himself off to John swans editing
I will never understand the appeal to Johns editing
This guy is lazily using South Park mouth animations every 10 seconds, within the first two minutes. His transitions and editing after that look like moviemaker/slideshow tier. So I guess it makes sense that John swan’s editing is fucking astonishing to him. I’d honestly prefer a black screen or some videogame footage. If you’re barely going to use important visuals or do anything fancy to keep people engaged in the watchtime then you don’t need a lazy avatar on the screen.

Not to be an ass but I don’t care enough about John swan to watch nearly two hours of people bitching about what a liar he is, in the same way that I don’t want to watch TRO’s 4 hour documentary on Nikocado avocado. I thought the editing praise was just to get him off the rope after his ‘career was RUINED’ and that commentary bros were just trying to help him make money that way.
 
This guy is lazily using South Park mouth animations every 10 seconds, within the first two minutes. His transitions and editing after that look like moviemaker/slideshow tier. So I guess it makes sense that John swan’s editing is fucking astonishing to him. I’d honestly prefer a black screen or some videogame footage. If you’re barely going to use important visuals or do anything fancy to keep people engaged in the watchtime then you don’t need a lazy avatar on the screen.

Not to be an ass but I don’t care enough about John swan to watch nearly two hours of people bitching about what a liar he is, in the same way that I don’t want to watch TRO’s 4 hour documentary on Nikocado avocado. I thought the editing praise was just to get him off the rope after his ‘career was RUINED’ and that commentary bros were just trying to help him make money that way.
I do think that they did promote John's editing for that reason too but also he was a big commentator at the time so they kept him to suck any views they could get from him.

How they actually think is that they made it look similar to those basic bitch tv documentaries you seen on tv at some point that means now it is amazing editing because it's "tv quality."

In reality, this is just sony vegas effects that are no different from the effects in windows movie maker that most commentators used to use back in 2009.

Like cool, you can make a page scroll sideways on the screen, but even I seen this issue in john's videos.
If we need to read a screenshot, then too much of transitioning effects can be distracting, and make reading those pieces of evidence harder to do.

If you have to pause a video to read shit then you failed to communicate what the fuck is happening.
Which surprise is the issue john has that his evidence half the time is also not very well researched, and repeating others points, or inserting personal thoughts that are irrelevant to the topic at hand.
 
Honestly given what a liar is, I wouldn't necessarily believe he did all the editing on my own; There are so many places where you can buy templates and even ones where they do all the editing online for you. Inserting things into pictures and filters and all that stuff John is great at, can easily be out-sourced and a new person could do anything. But honestly his editing can be done by anyone with the right program. It still takes the work and a lot of people don't know about them. But having looked at a few of these places John's style is basically these places that put stuff together for you.

He probably did everything himself, and maybe even one of these services would be himself, but if the guy is breathing he's lying so who knows if he did it through editing or a program or not honestly.
 
Honestly given what a liar is, I wouldn't necessarily believe he did all the editing on my own; There are so many places where you can buy templates and even ones where they do all the editing online for you. Inserting things into pictures and filters and all that stuff John is great at, can easily be out-sourced and a new person could do anything. But honestly his editing can be done by anyone with the right program. It still takes the work and a lot of people don't know about them. But having looked at a few of these places John's style is basically these places that put stuff together for you.

He probably did everything himself, and maybe even one of these services would be himself, but if the guy is breathing he's lying so who knows if he did it through editing or a program or not honestly.
John swan had ghost editors
 
Turkey tom is upset that when you look up tom on google it outright says he is autistic.
Screenshot_2022-06-15-18-32-57.png


To whomever is writing this about turkey tom, this is some genuinely funny shit thank you.
FU_unz2WIAAWzNJ.jpg


Also you know the joke that turkey tom is a femboy is floating around?
Well tom is also starting to retweet stuff like HRT and stuff like that more and more

Screenshot_2022-06-15-18-34-02.png
 
I might be retarded and can't tell if you're joking or not, but I am 99% sure this tweet is a joke about leafy and I think that's shoeonhead looking the same.
It hard to explain if you haven't kept up with the twitter for a while.
For example, you looked on his twitter in the past he has retweeted similar things like he retweeted artwork of him one time that was him as a femboy shota he promoted on twitter for a while.
There other incidents he done over time too along with him painting his fingernails that just been occuring over time more and more.

I am saying he doing a behavior that getting a little noticeable.
 
Honestly given what a liar is, I wouldn't necessarily believe he did all the editing on my own; There are so many places where you can buy templates and even ones where they do all the editing online for you. Inserting things into pictures and filters and all that stuff John is great at, can easily be out-sourced and a new person could do anything. But honestly his editing can be done by anyone with the right program. It still takes the work and a lot of people don't know about them. But having looked at a few of these places John's style is basically these places that put stuff together for you.

He probably did everything himself, and maybe even one of these services would be himself, but if the guy is breathing he's lying so who knows if he did it through editing or a program or not honestly.
I'm trying to remember which stream I heard it on, it was during the latest Johnswan fuckup, and I think it was the acheeto stream Nick did though I could be very off base on that, wherever it was Nick described in some detail how John does editing, and something tells me if Nick hadn't seen it himself he wouldn't have mentioned it given their history at this point.

If we are to believe Nick, the process he saw was extremely efficient. John allegedly had "transitions and scenes set up on a streamdeck" which John had set up for editing (quotes are to indicate almost the exact words used, I'm not a Premier or After Effects expert by any means so I've only got a vague sense of how this would work), the end result being he could easily put shiny things together very quickly.

I think you're picking up on that aspect of the editing with John's videos, it's a bit formulaic when you turn down the lensflare and actually look at the mechanics of it, because it is almost like an assembly line the way he does it.

The best recent example is of course John's lackluster Bella video which went head to head with Tom's far superior video. John put that thing together in a matter of days if the story is to be believed while Tom had been working on his for rather more time, and the end product showed the difference, but John was able to get his out hours before Tom's released. Frankly, if I didn't know the Bella story before I saw it pop up on recommended, I might have thought John's video was way better than it actually was because it looked so slick, but peel back the shiny transitions and it's not all that complex nor is the script very good if you have a remote familiarity with the lore involved.

All that to say that for the videos John has currently released, I think he's done them himself, if only because I think he might have more videos coming out if he did use ghost editors since he could basically just direct the work of a hoard of children like the biggest loser conductor in the world while raking in that sweet adsense money.

That said I can absolutely believe he started using ghost editors from among the hoards of children he seems to hang out with in discord if credible evidence came out to suggest it. It makes perfect sense as TRO kind of puts together videos this way & is damn successful doing it, and being a bit of a psycho John's propensity will be towards mimicry of successful people around him, a process which he saw up close since he was a TRO editor for a good while.
 
Jesus christ dillin attracts a lot of spergs.

But you are forgetting you are replying to a guy who wants to fuck dolphins.
By default he is a sperg so him missing why people didn't like his message will more likely go over his head.
N-no you >:o

No, but really, I *get* why people think that. As soon as I saw the replies I thought "ok, yeah, I could have worded that better, or not said it at all", but what am I supposed to do? Delete the post? That's exactly the kind of thing Dildo does. I said something stupid, some people replied to it, life goes on.

Anyways. Is Dillin back on Twitter? I thought he deleted his account, but it still shows up when I search for it. No follows or followers tho, so that's weird. Of course, when I tried searching for him by name, the first two posts I saw was Ian Flynn himself calling him a troll, and Chris Chan saying he and Taylor were a "power couple", so that got a laugh out of me.
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20220615-192601_Twitter.jpg
    Screenshot_20220615-192601_Twitter.jpg
    280 KB · Views: 77
  • Screenshot_20220615-192644_Twitter.jpg
    Screenshot_20220615-192644_Twitter.jpg
    469.3 KB · Views: 74
  • Screenshot_20220615-192712_Twitter.jpg
    Screenshot_20220615-192712_Twitter.jpg
    784.4 KB · Views: 77
  • Like
Reactions: Cheerlead-in-Chief
More ActMan Stuff:

This person isn't in the commentary community. They do MMOs and Kickstarter stuff from what I can tell and just popped up on my timeline:
 
Last edited:
  • Informative
Reactions: SpergPatrol
More ActMan Stuff:
I hate this generation of commentators seriously they are too overly sensitive over the dumbest of shit.

Act Man was in the right when this started, but now he is saying youtube homophobic for the whole copyright shit, then flipping his shit over a jaystation joke is just embarrassing.
 
Back