They're definitely BreadTube adjacent (I mean, NJB is literally subbed to Contrapoints of all people). While I agree with the general sentiment of raising awareness for urban planning, I don't believe the polarization they're causing is a good thing. A lot of what he advocates for, only exists in the Randstad (The more urban, more left-leaning economic center of The Netherlands) and doesn't really exist outside of that bubble, apart from the Arnhem - Nijmegen region. Partly because of this, they're creating a false narrative, they're only showing you the good, not the bad. When I was living in a more deprived part of the country, I was still paying a very high insurance rate, fuel and tax for my car, but I had no other option: The bus only went once an hour and it took 2 hours for it to get to my destination, whereas it's only 30 minutes tops by car. This shafts development in the poorer regions of the country.
I like cars, and I want cars to stay. These Youtubers are right about a lot of things, but they're ignoring many, many key points. For example, NJB tries to spin it as if American suburbs are dangerous and a Ponzi scheme. He forgets to tell you that The Netherlands also has sprawling suburbs (i.e. "bloemkoolwijken" - Cauliflower neighborhoods), while they do have better transport connections, they're still very far from the city (e.g. Colmschate). Anyway, my point isn't so much to discuss urban planning, my point is that he's being disingenuous.
Things like, "SUV's are vanity vehicles" are stupid talking points. The alternatives he suggests, such as a Urban Arrow bakfiets, are hilariously expensive, and only reserved for the Randstad middle class. The average person in The Netherlands cannot afford one, these cargo bikes are also vanity vehicles and he fails to address many points such as the width of the bike in relation to the bike paths, it's the same problem you have with SUVs, but because they're bikes it's suddenly okay? You're a bit of a hypocrite here Jason.
There's a collective in The Netherlands that "shakes" the electric VanMoof bikes which causes the alarm to trigger, making the owner have to respond, as well as tiewrapping the wheels so the ride isn't as comfortable anymore. Yet, Jason is happily advertising these late-stage capitalism products and framing them disingenuously. It's the same problem SUVs have, but in bike form. He doesn't talk about this though, he doesn't want you to know this, because that's the bad kind of vandalism! Nooooo, not our heckin' bikes!
Also, as an expat in The Netherlands, Jason happily makes use of the "30% ruling", a tax break for if you're immigrating to The Netherlands. Yes, you read that right, not only is this guy shamelessly trying to widen the Randstad divide, he's doing it tax free like the grifter he is.
One more thing, about the "missing middle housing": This doesn't exist in the same way it does in The Netherlands, however Jason wants you to believe there's a healthy mix. In reality, The Netherlands is in a deep housing crisis where the median income is priced out, there's 0, ZERO homes available for people with median incomes. This isn't the cause of the housing crisis though, it's many things that the government mismanaged such as the temporary mortgage tax deduction, bad rent controls and more. What he wants you to think, and what the government also wants you to think, is that we should build more housing. But the truth is, we have enough homes, except a lot are empty because the government introduced tax benefits around this for landlords, and many other reasons before something like mixed use developments come up.
I'm sure many of the ideas they have are great on paper. But the reality is that someone will have to pay, and it will likely be the people of the poorer regions of The Netherlands like they've always done, they ignore this, they don't talk about this, they want you to believe it'll be a heckin' wholesome kind society. My parents live along a dirt road in a very poor area, with the closest public transport connection an hour away. The people who live in these places have been subsidizing the Randstad utopia for decades and they're sick of it. I'm sick of it too, especially when people come to the country using tax deductions and other benefits, conveniently ignoring the reality that someone is paying for their luxury. Their world-view is incompatible with what's actually happening in the country.
On the subject of whether this should be in Mass Debates or Community Watch, this is definitely a community of people that are grifting with these ideas that are only going to drive a bigger wedge between the working and middle classes. We should try to provide strong counterpoints, not debate each other. I know that people like Jason, Alan Fisher, etc will read these posts, they always do. I hope we can plant a little seed of conscious and I'll be very interested to see any response from them.