BreadTube - The Unofficial ContraPoints Dickriders Club and the culture / drama surrounding the community.

Your post made me go look through old articles about Hasan and my god I know I don't have to tell people here but he is like the definition of astroturfed. The ball washing in some of the articles is crazy. "SO THOROUGHLY MODERN THAT I WAS ACTUALLY ABLE TO CALM DOWN". Because he sat with OBS open and read news articles?
View attachment 5773271
yeah breadtube was mandated from the top down not the bottom up. i remember the wave of institutions thinking some retarded turk would upend the natural instinct of people to want to be free online. also how the fuck do you calm down watching hasan? its hours of him being gone to eat and then occasionally a jumpscare loud annoying screech because someone pointed out hes obviously wrong on whatever dumb opinion he has that day. its like a heart attack simulator. youd be calmer if the quiet turk suddenly yelled allahu akbar on the plane ffs.
Far-Right Shenanigans Underway? According to this Breadtube video anyway.

this is the most unaware late and gay thing ever. he might as well have came on and said "guys guys guys. you wont believe what i just found out about germany and this hitler guy!" little late there pal. little late to notice the far right decrying the jewish genocidal campaigns and our occupied gov footing the bill. maybe this guy is a secret nazi and hes just trying to grow our accounts by letting people know now that the stories dying off in the west. he might as well have said "oh the news cycle is shifting focus dont forget to subscribe to my favorite nazi bros on twitter, heres a list of people i 100 percent avow"
 
Your post made me go look through old articles about Hasan and my god I know I don't have to tell people here but he is like the definition of astroturfed. The ball washing in some of the articles is crazy. "SO THOROUGHLY MODERN THAT I WAS ACTUALLY ABLE TO CALM DOWN". Because he sat with OBS open and read news articles?
View attachment 5773271
>"so thoroughly modern"

Twitch streams have been a thing for over a decade, Gita.
 
>"so thoroughly modern"

Twitch streams have been a thing for over a decade, Gita.
its "current year" bullshit. ie anything that aligns with their near religious idea of mankind evolving on a set path towards their identity is modern and all dissent is primitive and wrong.

edit also some people have asked me how breadtube experiment failed if people like hasan are successful even if less so than the right or edgy content. the reason it failed is because it was supposed to entirely tame the internet and kill off any right wing sphere and make people not want to be edgy or say slurs because they can idk pepe post to vaush and hasan and have a teletubby corpo friendly watered down version of that. many breadtubers did fail but even the successful ones never made a cultural impact and basically only appeal to gays and trannies and blacks anyway, people who you didnt need to convince to not like alt right stuff or to hate edgy content that wasnt "jokes" about being pedophlic like on the left or to dislike any valid or invalid critique or joke that mocks someone in their groups.
 
It's not just that. There was the whole alt-right pipeline paradigm that only calmed down when PewDiePie went on his hiatus. It was not just about shutting down the right wing spheres, it was quite definitively focused on also capturing the audience on it's way into the alt-right and trying to prepare agitators for debating their racist uncles and grandpas on facebook (Innuendo Studios etc.). And some of the content was not even that bad, provided some flawed insight into how discourses work, etc. But almost all of that intellectual type of videos died down with the arrival of Twitch politics and upper-class midwits like Vaush or Hasan, which spawned a whole new generation of monetization-friendly bland liberal-progressive content farms.
Noah Sampsen is kind of definitive of the style. Low energy, low information, just dumb, and a lot of deadpan-delivery of sensitivity-instilled emotional trauma. It's giving divorced art teacher on SSRIs vibes, and I'm still wondering how YouTube manage to make it all not lose money. The ad revenue must be crazy for this to be able to keep up.

The worst thing about it is, it's become all filler. If HBomberguy makes a video, I usually chuckle a few times, shake my head a few times, but I learn something, laugh at something and it's a positive experience altogether. The Wakefield documentary was great, the Tallarico documentary was funny. When I watch FD Signifier, Noah Sampsen, Big Joel or a Thought Slime slop segment, I want to lobotomize myself.
 
It's not just that. There was the whole alt-right pipeline paradigm that only calmed down when PewDiePie went on his hiatus. It was not just about shutting down the right wing spheres, it was quite definitively focused on also capturing the audience on it's way into the alt-right and trying to prepare agitators for debating their racist uncles and grandpas on facebook (Innuendo Studios etc.).
people say that because there arent as many yelling NIGGER on youtube that are allowed to get big but i see nothing but an explosion in sentiments that were verboten years ago with less explicit right wing content creators being popular along with slightly less hard right right wing figures who explode in popularity like tucker. not only that but alot of the popular culture is more influenced by right wing sentiments than left wing ones. anytime i see someone whos generally considered lesss sanitized and actually at least somewhat interesting they give more leeway to the right ideas than left ones.

just searching for a random halo vid the guy mocked some "woke" elements. from the newer games, just watching vinny from vinesauce he said he doesnt really care if some game he was playing generated slurs. i dont really see that kind of osmosis from things like hasan or hbomb or the like even if theyre objectively right on things. ive never seen someone mention or allude to harry's soy debunking video but i always hear in random places the soy meme itself to this day. the closest ive seen is someone reference "sell their houses to who ben?" all the figures people i know irl know are right wing explicitly or implicitly.

sorry for the autistic examples ig but my point is even in niche or autistic places people just mindlessly wander into i see a complete failure to cull right wing ideas from spreading to the point at least some level of acceptance of those ideas are universal in any online culture that likes to be a bit more authentic and not sanitized totally for ads. i cant even name many popular left wing or breadtube memes. the pronoun rant from heelvs and the debate guy ig are kinda close but even then they seem relegated to just a section.

edit. even general culture seems to be turning against them some senator called lgbt stuff filth and only really got some cnn posts and a couple thousand trannies and the like seething at their failed attempt at trans floyd.
 
Last edited:
Ethanisonline has been going back and forth with Alex Rosen (EDP445 Pedo catcher)

1709846072835.png

Ethan's response
1709846116111.png
1709846131008.png
1709846193071.png

1709846204404.png

This is Ethan by the way
1709846263155.png
 
These were from Adam Something's post on how sending troops in Ukraine DOES NOT MEAN WWIII guys. Don't be a silly.
Screenshot_20240302-183550_(1).png
Involving NATO means invoking a war, retard.

Some enlightened comments:
Screenshot_20240302-183635_(1).png
Irony. Adam Something is infamous for saying Stepan Bandera was "misunderstood" when debating Haz and has been insistent Ukraine will win. Meanwhile, History Legends, a Russian YouTuber, has consistently shown how terrible it is. Of course Adam doesn't care, he's too busy complaining about transit.
 
When I was in highschool I was a big fan of Kyle Kulinski / Secular Talk. Doubt I would have ever been a fan of Vaush. I only listen to Vaush because it's good rage fuel.
I used to be a big Secular Talk fan. I gained respect for him in 2020 because he was just about the only left wing youtuber who didn't either fully cuck himself to Biden or swing in the other direction to "hErE's WhY eLeCtOrAlIsM dOeSn'T wOrK" stuff. Last I checked he fell in line for Biden anyway though so I guess it was only a matter of time.
Today I was shown the following thumbnail for a Breadtuber I've never watched called Dead Domain, with the video titled "TRANS PERSON INFILITRATES CPAC (Part 1)".

View attachment 5773171

I haven't had time to watch the whole video and honestly don't think I have the interest to bother, but I was curious to see what undercover looked like. For comparison, here's Dead Domain in their regular persona:

View attachment 5773178

And here is Dead Domain undercover as "Keith":

View attachment 5773174

I don't have much more to add. I just found it to be kind of a self-own, or maybe remarkably self-aware, that they didn't even bother to try passing as a woman. If another Kiwi has the time and autism to do a deeper dive, please report.
Reminder that "transphobia" is the only form of bigotry that completely disappears with nothing but a change of clothes.
 
Last edited:
These were from Adam Something's post on how sending troops in Ukraine DOES NOT MEAN WWIII guys. Don't be a silly.
View attachment 5795855
Involving NATO means invoking a war, retard.

Some enlightened comments:
View attachment 5795856
Irony. Adam Something is infamous for saying Stepan Bandera was "misunderstood" when debating Haz and has been insistent Ukraine will win. Meanwhile, History Legends, a Russian YouTuber, has consistently shown how terrible it is. Of course Adam doesn't care, he's too busy complaining about transit.
People like Adam Something, and Yugopnik make me extremely fucking depressed. They're part of that generation of Eastern-Europeans/Balkaners where their parents either didn't live under communism or were too young to remember anything. They more than likely didn't live with any grand parents or extended family, and they grew up with the internet at the tip of their fingers. Completely divorcing them from the reality of where they live and ironically Americanizing themselves.

At no point in their lives have these people talked to someone who has lived through that system who could tell them "No you fucking retard, communism was just as corrupt and inept as the capitalists you cry about, if not more!" Not only that, but they think they're better than their fellow country men.

As for the N-th retarded take of his. The war became extremely unpopular in europe as soon as people started getting hit in the wallet. Now you want to have their kids come back in pine boxes? I'm sure that's gonna work out great.
 
Involving NATO means invoking a war, retard.
While that's the common interpretation of Article 5, it's actually vaguely worded in such a way that it falls to tell each member how they will react to "an attack against them ... in exercise of the right of individual or collective self-defence recognized by Article 51 of the Charter of the United Nations, will assist the Party or Parties so attacked by taking forthwith, individually and in concert with the other Parties, such action as it deems necessary". They could all respond with a strongly worded condemnation, but this outcome would risk something almost as dangerous, a complete dissolution of NATO as they realize that the treaty isn't as meaningful as they thought it was.

Either way, sending actual NATO troops into Ukraine would definitely be brinksmanship.
 
These were from Adam Something's post on how sending troops in Ukraine DOES NOT MEAN WWIII guys. Don't be a silly.
View attachment 5795855
Involving NATO means invoking a war, retard.

Some enlightened comments:
View attachment 5795856
Irony. Adam Something is infamous for saying Stepan Bandera was "misunderstood" when debating Haz and has been insistent Ukraine will win. Meanwhile, History Legends, a Russian YouTuber, has consistently shown how terrible it is.
Even though I agree with Adam on the Ukraine war, I still think it's obviously the start of WW3 when NATO steps in. Hell, WW3 has already unofficially started. We're just waiting for China and NATO to get involved. The Israelis are bombing the Gazans, the Americans are fighting Houthis, Ukraine and Russia are slapfighting for the east, with NATO not far behind. India and China are already gearing up for war with each other. What is that if not a world at war?

Of course Adam doesn't care, he's too busy complaining about transit.
At no point in their lives have these people talked to someone who has lived through that system who could tell them "No you fucking retard, communism was just as corrupt and inept as the capitalists you cry about, if not more!" Not only that, but they think they're better than their fellow country men.
That's always been my feel with Adam Something. Dude sounds like a Tankie. He bitches about things in Europe that are not problems across the rest of the world, where people have real problems like crushing poverty, corruption, runaway crime and disorder, government coups, among other things. Dude is the very definition of a guy whining about first-world problems. Then he has the temerity to praise commie blocks while shitting on suburbs. Like come on, your average dude who lives in a commie block wishes he lives in an American suburb.

Adam Something tries to hype Europe up while shitting on American malls. He peddles the line that American malls are going to go the way of the dodo while European malls are here to stay. I live right next door to an American mall that sees a ton of business every single day, and every mall I've been to in America has the same, so I can tell for a fact that he's talking out of his ass. Meanwhile, the cosmopolitan European population that lives off those European malls is dwindling. It won't be long until Adam starts eating his own words.

There's even articles that question the common wisdom of malls in the USA dying.

 
Last edited:
Adam Something tries to hype Europe up while shitting on American malls. He peddles the line that American malls are going to go the way of the dodo while European malls are here to stay. I live right next door to an American mall that sees a ton of business every single day, and every mall I've been to in America has the same, so I can tell for a fact that he's talking out of his ass. Meanwhile, the cosmopolitan European population that lives off those European malls is dwindling. It won't be long until Adam starts eating his own words.
There is one reason American malls are dying out and it isn't for the reason Adam thinks. It's demographics, and how one particular demographic thinks going to the mall means sucker punching Asians and whites and trashing businesses until they have to close. The same will happen to Europe with their unlimited immigration policies.
 
There is one reason American malls are dying out and it isn't for the reason Adam thinks. It's demographics, and how one particular demographic thinks going to the mall means sucker punching Asians and whites and trashing businesses until they have to close. The same will happen to Europe with their unlimited immigration policies.
Then in that case, Europe has that problem even moreso than America. Some American cities at least have cops milling in malls that will arrest said demographic that plays the knock-out game; I've seen more than a few dragged out by cops for causing trouble. Meanwhile, I don't think European police are going to touch the more militant migrants without a ten-foot pole; they sure as hell don't want to be accused of being RACIST and getting fired from their jobs.
 
Shaun released a video on the Israel-Palestine conflict and what struck me as significant is Shaun's inability to understand Israel's perspective. I would go so far to say that Shaun is anti-Jewish. Not anti-semitic as he does not hate the Jewish people, but he would oppose the beliefs of Judaism and the cultural values of the Jewish people if he learned about them.

Shaun views Israel as a colonial project and that all of horrible things Israel has done to the Palestinians is due to the oppressive nature of a colonial project. He is puzzled at why Israelis celebrate certain actions (an example being Israelis setting up lawn chairs to watch the bombing of Gaza in 2014). He is shocked that apparently the Jewish people did not learn the lesson of the Holocaust, about the need to treat everyone as equal. He wishes that discriminatory values such as the "master race" and "God's Chosen People" would be replaced with universal respect for everyone. Such comments indicate ignorance about Judaism and the Jewish people.

Judaism is connected to the concept of Israel. It is the religious and historical homeland of the Jews, promised by God in exchange for his chosen people to uphold specific laws. The ultra-orthodox anti-zionists only oppose the State of Israel because the messiah has not come. The messiah can only establish Israel. Shaun neglected to mention the initial peaceful attempts to purchase land in Palestine and instead connects initial Zionism with the later right-wing Revisionist Zionism which advocated violence. Is it any surprise that such an ideology would grow in popularity especially during the 1930s? The Revisionists had a perfect example for why Jews needed their own state and the Holocaust demonstrated why Jews needed to fight for it. "Never Again" meant never again will the Jewish people be oppressed. The shared history of exile and persecution will be over once the State of Israel exists. It will be established no matter the cost.

Shaun lacks any understanding of nationalism, viewing it as a regressive thing (nevermind how the Palestinian identity is only established through nationalism) and thus can never understand the Israel-Palestine conflict. It is a demonstration of ignorance or at worst, deliberate misinformation, that Shaun made a nearly hour and a half video on the conflict and could not understand the Israeli perspective. He says that there is no justification for Israel bombing children in Gaza but rationalizes the actions of Palestinian groups (which killed children) as the inevitable result of there being no means for a peaceful solution. Hypocrisy is synonymous with Breadtubers but this video really demonstrates the lack of analytical thinking.

 
Shaun released a video on the Israel-Palestine conflict and what struck me as significant is Shaun's inability to understand Israel's perspective.
This is a recurring thing with these pro-Palestine "rational" people. Anytime Israel launches a military action they will bemoan the "fact" that this will just further radicalize the Palestinians. After all, who has ever heard of military action ever dissuading more military action from your enemies?

At the same time, they just can't conceive of any possible reason that Israel would elect rightwing governments or allow settlers to harass Palestinians or crack down on civilians who aid terrorists.

I find a lot of "soft bigotry of lowered expectations" arguments to be facile, but it does almost feel like anti-Arab racism, like they don't believe that Arabs are capable of not immediately responding with terrorism and Islamic fundamentalism and ultra-nationalism to any perceived insult. Meanwhile they expect the Jews to be Vulcan-like and to reject all nationalism and refuse to take advantage of their biggest strength (military force) because it might cause undue suffering to the people who keep on trying to kill them.

It's a combination of extreme empathy towards the underdog and absolutely no empathy for the top dog that we all know to expect from leftists at this point. It's what we see with trannies, with criminals, and rioters where no action from the afore-mentioned groups can be too vile and even the mildest pushback from their "privileged" victims (or just people who empathize with their victims) is fascism.
 
Shaun released a video on the Israel-Palestine conflict and what struck me as significant is Shaun's inability to understand Israel's perspective. I would go so far to say that Shaun is anti-Jewish. Not anti-semitic as he does not hate the Jewish people, but he would oppose the beliefs of Judaism and the cultural values of the Jewish people if he learned about them.

It should also be noted that if anything, the Palestinians are even worse than the nazis.

Even the nazis involved in the concentration camps had to drink heavily in order to cope with what they were doing.

The Palestinian ragheads openly celebrate acts of murder and torture of jews on social media. They're barbaric even by the low standards set by the middle east, to the point that when Israel asked Egypt to take control of Gaza, they refused.
 
It should also be noted that if anything, the Palestinians are even worse than the nazis.

Even the nazis involved in the concentration camps had to drink heavily in order to cope with what they were doing.

The Palestinian ragheads openly celebrate acts of murder and torture of jews on social media. They're barbaric even by the low standards set by the middle east, to the point that when Israel asked Egypt to take control of Gaza, they refused.
Muslims already treat each other like shit. How do you think they'd treat infidels?

One thing I remember about Muslim civilization was how worse it was compared to feudalism. Reading a book about the Crusades from Muslim Eyes, even the author had to admit that the Crusader lords treated Muslim peasants with more respect, allowing them to make good money so long as they didn't turn against the Christian ruling class.

That's right, the way the Muslims rule each other is so bad that feudalism is a fucking improvement compared to how they usually live. Put a Muslim country under the oppressive thumb of a medieval Christian ruler, and dollars to doughnuts, the average Muslim pleb will live better under the Christian ruler than his own kind.

Modern academia usually blankets the mind with stories of how good the Muslim rulers are to their subjects, how tolerant and scientific they were. Which is, of course, complete hogwash; most of their science was stolen from the Byzantines and the Persians, and the tolerance came with a price of the Dhimmis constantly being humiliated and forced to pay taxes, and they could be massacred anytime.

Shaun doesn't understand that, and so, when he sees the Israelis retaliating against the Muslims, all he sees are evil white colonialists killing nice and tolerant Muslims, so of course, the Israelis, despite bringing money and jobs to the region, are despised as invaders because they're white people colonizing and oppressing those oh-so-tolerant Muslims. Nevermind that the Muslims do it to each other, like when the Seljuks conquered a chunk of Muslim and Christian lands and took away power from the local Arab rulers, or how the Ottomans united most of the western part of the Muslim world under them-through violence.
 
Last edited:
I keep hearing that bread tube is dead and I just am not convinced.

Hbomberguy made huge waves with his plagiarism video and still has a lot of patreons.

Contrapoints still gets mad views

Hasan is bigger then ever and he is a mainstream celebrity at this point. He has said so much shit that would get anyone else banned on Twitch yet he remains untouchable.

Vaush is kind of dead but his followers went to other breadtubers so not a loss for the group as a whole

Second Thought and his depgrogram podcast are still rapidly growing.

Bad Empanada is still growing rapidly despite being a crazy person.

I just don't see how bread tube is dying, maybe some of the random no namers have quit making videos after they failed to get popular but isn't that normal ? I see people say that white identitarianism is growing rapidly and the left claims it is such a threat, can you name me a pro white influencer that is growing as fast as any of the above influencers ?
 
Back
Top Bottom