Perfume and fragrance chat

  • 🐕 I am attempting to get the site runnning as fast as possible. If you are experiencing slow page load times, please report it.
Anyone know of another brand that has a scent similar to Demeter's Zombie for Her? Or am I just weird for enjoying it and they're the only brand?

Also an alternative to Gucci Bloom would be lovely.
 
Currently my favorite perfume is Jean Paul Gaultier Le Male Elixir
1736337333865.png
It's the most popular fragrance on fragrantica right now, but I haven't smelled anyone using it IRL.

There is now a minor drama around Dior Homme Parfum 2025 reformulation, you can read the reviews.

I've also recently found a lolcow perfumes by a tryhard designer (look at the notes):
Inexcusable Evil
Antichrist A-
 
Tried some new (popular) perfumes this week.

Glossier You: Finally got around to trying this insanely popular fragrance, and ... Yeah, it's true what so many people say about it (that it smells different on everyone). When I smelled it from the bottle and sprayed it on a card, I thought it actually smelled gross. It was screechy with the pink pepper top note along with this pungent animalic smell that honestly reminded me of body odor. Then, I tried it on my skin, and it completely transformed. On my skin, it's a really fresh and sweet musk (kind of like D&G Light Blue, but without the fruit/citrus notes), and it's lovely! It clings onto my clothes really nicely, too. I might need to get a full size of this once the weather gets warmer ...

Mon Guerlain: I wasn't interested in trying this out because I've been told how sweet it is, so I assumed it was just another fruity floral with a vanilla base. Then, I recently found out that it has a prominent lavender note and so I had to try it. I absolutely love it. The lavender is really strong, and with the vanilla and licorice in the base, I'm actually reminded of Lush's Twilight/Sleepy fragrance quite a lot. The lavender almost smells "toasted" and warm to me, just like Twilight/Sleepy does. To me, this stuff smells like a warm hug.

Amouage Guidance: I was able to get a decent-sized sample of this for under $10. People have hyped this up as one of the greatest perfumes of all time. Because I've been told how strong this one is, I've only smelled it on a card so far ... And so far, it's fine? I just smell sandalwood and hazelnut. When I'm ready to try it on myself, I'll give an update.

Update: Been wearing Guidance this afternoon on my wrist. Meh? It's not gross, it doesn't offend me, and I don't mind wearing it ... But I'm not smelling this "complex masterpiece of femininity" that the internet has sold to me, haha. On my skin, I can smell the sandalwood, amber, and pear ... And that's about it. It just smells ... "perfume-y" to me rather than something that leaves an impression.

I would be more impressed if this were a Bath & Body Works scent, tbh. As a perfume that costs almost 400 bucks for a full bottle, though? No thank you.
 
Last edited:
Amouage Guidance: I was able to get a decent-sized sample of this for under $10. People have hyped this up as one of the greatest perfumes of all time. Because I've been told how strong this one is, I've only smelled it on a card so far ... And so far, it's fine? I just smell sandalwood and hazelnut. When I'm ready to try it on myself, I'll give an update.

Update: Been wearing Guidance this afternoon on my wrist. Meh? It's not gross, it doesn't offend me, and I don't mind wearing it ... But I'm not smelling this "complex masterpiece of femininity" that the internet has sold to me, haha. On my skin, I can smell the sandalwood, amber, and pear ... And that's about it. It just smells ... "perfume-y" to me rather than something that leaves an impression.
Amouage is ridiculously overpriced for what it is, imo. They usually smell like some kind of incoherent mess, which is unacceptable for a 400 dollar frag.
 
Anyone know of another brand that has a scent similar to Demeter's Zombie for Her? Or am I just weird for enjoying it and they're the only brand?

Also an alternative to Gucci Bloom would be lovely.
CB I Hate Perfume (CB for Christopher Brosius, the same man who founded Demeter) has one called Black March you might like, it smells like crunchy autumn leaves underfoot. If you like Zombies, wear Zombies lol. To get that same quality of earthiness, Olympics Orchids Night Flyer or Olympic Rainforest would be your best bet. What part of Gucci Bloom makes you want an alternative? There's lots of good jasmine/tuberose perfumes out there.

Got my sample of Lolitaland by Lolita Lempicka. I was hoping for a sweet explosion of tropical fruits, but instead it's more like a mango aftershave? A fail from the unfortunate Leslie Leonor era of ownership, I'm afraid. In contrast, the 20 mL mini-bottle of Lolita Lempicka EdP from the much better Pacific Creations era smells like licorice hairspray and I mean that as a compliment. Light and fun, it will be great in summer.
 
CB I Hate Perfume (CB for Christopher Brosius, the same man who founded Demeter) has one called Black March you might like, it smells like crunchy autumn leaves underfoot. If you like Zombies, wear Zombies lol. To get that same quality of earthiness, Olympics Orchids Night Flyer or Olympic Rainforest would be your best bet. What part of Gucci Bloom makes you want an alternative? There's lots of good jasmine/tuberose perfumes out there.
I was just looking for familiar scents to Zombies since I really enjoyed its very earthy tones!
As for Gucci, moreso just something quite similar without as big of a price tag so I can save my Gucci bottle.
 
If anyone is familiar with Versace Bright Crystal, is there anything that’s similar? I absolutely love it, but kinda want to change things up.

On the other hand, I bought Miss Dior hair perfume and absolutely loathe it. It’s too spicy
 
If anyone is familiar with Versace Bright Crystal, is there anything that’s similar? I absolutely love it, but kinda want to change things up.

On the other hand, I bought Miss Dior hair perfume and absolutely loathe it. It’s too spicy
You could try the Absolu version. I prefered that one.

You could give the Coach fragrances a try. Affordable and in that realm.
 
I have a really strong sense of smell, which makes me really smell-averse. I can't stand strong scents of any kind, they give me a migraine. For hygiene purposes I tend to gravitate towards really low-key, neutral sorts of scents.

I prefer citrus-ey body washes and shampoos (I use a lemon scented body wash and a vaguely lime-scented shampoo) and really light sports deoderant. I use laundry detergent w/ Febreze because it's pervasive but not cloying, so even after a long day my clothes don't reek.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Super Guido
So, uh, Amouage Guidance is definitely one of the most "Beast Mode" perfumes I've ever used.

Because of my ever-growing belly from pregnancy and my reluctance to waste money on maternity clothes, I've been borrowing some of my husband's long sleeved tees to wear around the house (yes, I've become one of those wives lol). I wore Guidance for one day last week, literally did laundry a few days ago, and I can still smell it on the shirt.

So ... If you want a truly strong perfume that doesn't go away, then check out Guidance. lol. I'm personally a little annoyed with how strong it is, especially since I find the fragrance to be pretty ho-hum for its hype.
 
I've tested Jean Paul Gaultier - Le Male today as I didn't try it before, and generally I enjoy both Jean Paul Gaultier perfumes and Le Male collection.
It smells somewhat like these Asian massage places, and it isn't a bad smell per se, but it doesn't fit as a male fragrance to me.
Unfortunately it was so potent that it started to make me nauseous, and I wanted to wash it off, but it couldn't be helped, lol.
After some agonizing hours it faded, definitely has good parameters, but I need a detox from fragrances now :mad:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pee Cola
I've tested Jean Paul Gaultier - Le Male today as I didn't try it before, and generally I enjoy both Jean Paul Gaultier perfumes and Le Male collection.
It smells somewhat like these Asian massage places, and it isn't a bad smell per se, but it doesn't fit as a male fragrance to me.
Unfortunately it was so potent that it started to make me nauseous, and I wanted to wash it off, but it couldn't be helped, lol.
After some agonizing hours it faded, definitely has good parameters, but I need a detox from fragrances now :mad:
I tend to test on a paper first, then if I like it, try it on the wrist or sleeve. If I still like it, I then put it on my clothes to get the full effect. This helps avoid scents I hate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chris Konon
for 2025, i started keeping a notebook of written notes for all of the perfumes i sample/try, so here's the collection of perfumes i tried in january. i've either worn these once or twice, for a full day on skin. usually i can get a third weartest out of a sample, but after one wear i can decide if it's for me or not, and after two i can decide whether i'd buy a full bottle or not. so without further ado.

first, a couple i tried before keeping the notebook but were notable enough that i brought/want to buy a full bottle.

Fève Gourmande, Guerlain - 10/10
i don't think i even sat on my thought of buying this for a day after wearing it; it's completely delicious, and exactly what i wanted and expected from the notes. this is a rich, smooth fragrance that reminds me of turkish delight - cocoa & rose that dries down to a very soft, sweet woodsy smell. it's very elegant and i wouldn't say it's edible like many of the gourmands released in the last couple of years; it's very sophisticated and just so... quality, but i expect that now of the L'Art et La Matiêre line from Guerlain.

Ex Vetiver, Juliette Has A Gun - 8.5/10
this awakened me into realising that i really, really like 'green' scents; i was completely surprised by how nice this is, it's bright and citrussy on the opening and dries down into a floral woody vetiver. such a starkly different vetiver to that i love in ELDO's Fat Electrician and Frustration, and is definitely more universally appealing. just a really, good, fresh springtime vetiver, that i never thought i'd love, or even like.

and now for the january samples

HITS

Angélique Noire
, Guerlain - 9/10
so, so interesting, and so, so beautiful. musky, sugary vanilla with bitter, fresh angelica on top - it comes together to make a very 'cold' vanilla, which is so different to any vanilla i've smelled before. the angelica is so green and dewy, kinda of peppery, and it's once where i just can't stop smelling my wrists. i will buy a full bottle of this when i can work up the courage to drop £295 at guerlain again.

Solo Ella EDP, Loewe - 8/10
this is beautiful. Loewe make beautiful clothing and bags, but i didn't expect them to make beautiful perfume, too. it's bright, fresh and clean, and very nice in the cold weather. the top notes are so juicy - i get a green apple rind with peach and pear juice - and the dry down is equally as pretty, but clean and woodsy. great longevity for such a fresh fragrance. most likely will buy.

Cuir Beluga, Guerlain - 8/10
soft and comforting, and very vanilla forward on me. it's the beautiful guerlain vanilla that can do no wrong in my eyes. it surrounds me in a cloud of fragrance but it's so hard to describe and i don't know why. i get a very slight, smooth leather and creaminess from... somewhere. on my second wear i realised that this smells like an amplified, 'perfume-ified' version of my dog's skin and fur; she's a whippet so tends to pick up the smell of the bedlinen and blankets, and mixed with her skin it's this soft, musky... honestly lovely smell. looking at the notes i think this smell/effect is from the heliotrope. really pretty and quite... oddly emotive. i'm not sure if i'd pick up a full bottle though - it's fucking expensive, and guerlain has so many fantastic fragrances.

MIDS

Agua Drop
, Loewe - 7.5/10
sharp, fresh ans fizzy; it reminds me of lemon sherbet sweets, but without being too sugary or immature. a very good citrus, as it doesn't lean into the cleaning products category, but it also lasts and projects really well, even the citrus notes themselves. i like it, but i don't think i'd buy a full bottle, because... it's just not 'me' enough, i don't think. and for the price it's asking i need to love it a bit more.

Pur Muguet, Cartier - 7.5/10
pure lily; very fresh and uplifting, but also with the green dewiness and sweet, heady nectar of the flower. cartier have captured the lily really well - including the part where if you sniff too deeply, it's almost sickly and migraine-inducing. when not huffing it though, it is serene, delicate and beautiful. i love the smell of lilies but don't buy them because i have a very curious dog, so it's nice to have it in perfume form. it isn't anything more, less or beyond a lily; the pricepoint is very steep for a soliflore though.

Nomade Nuit d'Egypte, Chloe - 7/10
very opulent and kinda creamy. it's (softly) spicy, floral and oriental - the myrrh stands out for me, it has an incense-like quality, but the sticks rather than the burning of the incense, if that makes a lick of sense. it's pretty linear throughout and not particularly long-lasting, but it is nice.

Athalia, Parfums De Marly - 7/10
clean, soapy, powdery floral. the orange blossom is instantly recognisable and it compliments the iris really well by adding a citrussy creaminess. it really does smell beautiful, refined, and classy... until about 2 hours into the drydown, where everything has faded except for the sweaty, pissy smell of amber. the first couple of hours are a solid 9, 9.5 for me, but i can't justify ever buying a full bottle that eventually leaves me smelling of piss.

Mulberry Fig, Floris - 6/10
not exactly what i wanted for a fig perfume - the violet leaf overpowers a lot of the other notes, and it's not a note i particularly enjoy. it is very green, fresh and uplifting, and once the violet leaf fades, the dry down is really nice where the vetiver, cedar, orris, and even the coconut, come through. longevity is kind of... lacking. i have a whole 10ml of this to play with though, so maybe wearing it in warmer weather will make it work better. but a great fig perfume? this is not.

Vetiver Extraordinaire, Frederic Malle - 5/10
very fresh and earthy - i get soil and mint, though the notes don't suggest either. the vetiver is very much overpowered by everything else, and i was wanting it to be vetiver heavy. very masculine as well - i don't pay much attention to whether fragrances are listed as being masculine or feminine, but some things do just really Smell Like A Man (albeit nice). the drydown however is very nice and brings it back into something more unisex. performance is lacking for the pricepoint though - you can probably get something that smells and performs the same, for a lot less; it's not an uncommon or special scent profile.

SHITS

Perfect Intense
, Marc Jacobs - 3/10
a pretty standard designer floral, but green. it's leafy and herbaceous in the top but it doesn't really mesh well with what is a standard designer perfume counter floral underneath, which dries down to a very plain sandalwood anyway. the notes state there's a roasted almond note, but i just get no nuttiness atall. despite being labelled 'intense' it doesn't last for shit - the second time i wore it i forgot i was even wearing it. MJ's Daisy line is one of my guilty pleasures, Perfect is not the same.

Babycat, YSL - 2/10
every single harsh note listed comes through - pink pepper, black pepper and saffron - and stay. forever. it's an overly spicy suede. this is a highly revered fragrance and really it's not it - i don't get any of this sexy vanilla, it just stinks. it smooths out a bit when it dries down but then... it's just suede. lasts forever which would be great... if i liked it

Pur Magnolia, Cartier - 2/10
very dewy, slightly waxy, and citrussy if you get really close. otherwise, deeply unpleasant. it has that horrible, sickly sweet smell of a baby wipe (used), particularly from a distance. i'm guessing that that's just what magnolias actually smell like. it's what i imagine the colour magnolia to smell like anyway.

Oud & Ambre, Cartier - 2/10
initially very spicy, sweaty and sickly - very antiquated and smells like the saliva of someone with bad dental hygiene. a nice smokiness develops, for which it gets points, but jesus christ what i'm pinning on the amber is pretty nasty. i'm beginning to think that amber-heavy perfumes are not my thing; halitosis and sweat is all i get. i do have Oud & Santal from this same line to try, so i should be able to pinpoint the source of the stink i got. lasts for ages too - all of the fragrances that fucking stink to me seem to.

Cherry Blossom, Floris - 1/10
this is somehow the faintest, fruity floral that somehow still nearly took my eyebrows off on the opening blast. very, very generic and basic floral; i think rubbing some fabric softener into my skin would be a much cheaper way to smell like this. good longevity in fragrance is a bonus but it isn't what makes a fragrance 'good' to me - but this actually takes the piss, farts linger for longer than this. linear.

Divine Le Parfum, Jean Paul Gaultier - 1/10
basic, consumer friendly designer perfume. i genuinely cannot pick out any of the notes, even stinky amber, because it's blended into a mess. on paper it sounds so interesting - lily, solar notes, frangipani and sea salt - but it's so fucking BORING and basic. i don't understand how those notes are supposed to translate into this smell. it's also horrendously strong in the beginning to the point that i was worried i'd choke someone out, but then just completely vanishes a couple hours into the wear. this pissed me off rather than smelling awful.

fin.
order more samples today since it's been a couple months and my list of fragrances to try was piling up;

L'Orchestre Parfum - Discovery Set. Like the sound of a lot of their fragrances so said fuck it and brought the set, there's enough i want to try that it's cheaper to buy samples that way.

Guerlain - Iris Torréfié
Guerlain - Pêche Mirage
Maison Crivelli - Iris Malikhân
Regime Des Fleurs - Fleur Eclair
Kerosene - Promises, Promises
Kerosene - Unknown Pleasures
Kerosene - Sweetly Known
Diptyque - Philosykos EDP
Zoologist - Cow
Serge Lutens - Santal Majuscule
Serge Lutens - Vetiver Oriental

+ Orto Parisi's Brutus, Stercus and Boccanera for the other half (to complete his set)
really wanted to get Serge Lutens - Iris Silver Mist too but i cannot find a sample in the UK for love nor money
 
I've tested Jean Paul Gaultier - Le Male today as I didn't try it before, and generally I enjoy both Jean Paul Gaultier perfumes and Le Male collection.
It smells somewhat like these Asian massage places, and it isn't a bad smell per se, but it doesn't fit as a male fragrance to me.
Unfortunately it was so potent that it started to make me nauseous, and I wanted to wash it off, but it couldn't be helped, lol.
After some agonizing hours it faded, definitely has good parameters, but I need a detox from fragrances now :mad:
Do
So, uh, Amouage Guidance is definitely one of the most "Beast Mode" perfumes I've ever used.

Because of my ever-growing belly from pregnancy and my reluctance to waste money on maternity clothes, I've been borrowing some of my husband's long sleeved tees to wear around the house (yes, I've become one of those wives lol). I wore Guidance for one day last week, literally did laundry a few days ago, and I can still smell it on the shirt.

So ... If you want a truly strong perfume that doesn't go away, then check out Guidance. lol. I'm personally a little annoyed with how strong it is, especially since I find the fragrance to be pretty ho-hum for its hype.
Do you think being pregnant has affected your sense of smell?
 
I am far from a fragrance expert but I have heard it said that when it comes to complexity of fragrance, you often have to sacrifice longevity. idk if this is true or not but it sounds vaguely logical/
Amouage would like a word.

One example of theirs might be Opus XV – King Blue, which is very underappreciated (a boon for the price point, IMHO). The description starts:

> An opening of vibrant mandarin leads unexpectedly to a bold, animalic and effortlessly sophisticated base of oud.

Most people form their opinion at the initial oud part, which can be earthy and "cheesy," something akin to Limburger, but it's gross, just a lil funky.

Once you get past that portion, which can be an hour or two, then you are greeted with a fantastic olfactory experience as the black currant becomes more prominent, with support from sandalwood and earthy patchouli, interlaced with resins and amber.

Another (sadly) discontinued gem is Myths Man. This is the only chrysanthemum-focused masculine fragrance I could find and it's a masterpiece. It goes from floral top notes (orris is akin to iris), to a dusty/hay-like rose and rum mid, and finishes with ash and resins. It's a ethereal experience from start to end.

Both King Blue and Myths Man have solid projection and longevity.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: Ninon42
Do you think being pregnant has affected your sense of smell?
That's definitely possible. I've always had a "strong" or "sensitive" sense of smell, but I think pregnancy has amplified it even more (and it did for my first baby too).

A lot of my favorite perfumes have still been my favorites, so none of that has changed during pregnancy. I just don't think that Guidance "fits" me, if that makes sense. Clean perfumes and floral perfumes are what I mostly gravitate towards (with the occasional oriental-leaning gourmand during the colder months of the year).

I'll give Guidance another try before it starts to warm up outside (and I'll be very VERY conservative with how much I spray since I don't want to be a total perfume cloud around a newborn baby). Right now, though, I'm not impressed with how it transforms on my skin. As it stands now, a lot of the more interesting notes completely disappear on my skin, so all I smell on me is a watery pencil shaving scent (a STRONG watery pencil shaving scent that clings to my clothes like nothing I've ever worn before lol). It's not bad, but it's not my favorite. It smells better when I spray it on a card, in my opinion.

It's funny because my current perfume obsession is Glossier You-- been wearing it every day for almost a month straight now, and that fragrance gets called a "pencil shaving" scent by a lot of people who don't like it, haha. On me though, Glossier You smells like the cleanest and brightest musk ever and I can't get enough of it.

My prediction is that Guidance will become something that I appreciate more on other people, but not on me. The way people talk about this perfume makes it sound amazing, but it might just boil down to body chemistry. There have been a lot of perfumes that have done this for me. For example, I don't like wearing YSL Black Opium myself because I don't think it "fits" me or my tastes, but I think it smells really freakin' good on other people ... And Carolina Herrera Good Girl smells like a perfume-y mess on me, but I'll never forget how incredible it smelled on my sister-in-law on her and my brother's wedding day.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: ChompChomp
Back