- Joined
- Aug 13, 2022
NASA Inspector General has reviewed the current status of the Human Landing System, the missing link in the Artemis program.
Nothing particularly shocking, generally concludes the "commercial" approach NASA is taking us a good one and recommends some bureaucratic improvements, which management have agreed to.
The juiciest bits from the summary:
Nothing particularly shocking, generally concludes the "commercial" approach NASA is taking us a good one and recommends some bureaucratic improvements, which management have agreed to.
The juiciest bits from the summary:
However, both SpaceX and Blue Origin have experienced schedule delays and face technical and integration challenges that have the potential to further impact lander costs and delivery schedules. In particular, SpaceX’s lander will not be ready for a June 2027 lunar landing. To accelerate lander development to meet a 2028 lunar landing date, NASA is assessing proposals from both SpaceX and Blue Origin, but it is too early to determine the technical feasibility, financial implications, and schedule impacts of these proposals.
We noted NASA is proactively taking measures to mitigate and prevent hazards associated with the landers, such as requiring lunar ascent tests as part of the providers’ uncrewed demonstration missions. However, despite these efforts, and considering the lunar landers carry the highest probability of crew loss, gaps still exist in the Agency’s risk reduction methodology. For instance, while HLS Program officials believe the Program is following Agency Test Like You Fly guidance, we found key missed opportunities to apply these principles to the SpaceX and Blue Origin uncrewed demonstration missions. Additionally, NASA and SpaceX disagree on whether the provider is meeting the intent of the Agency’s manual control requirement. Incorporating the manual control capability is a key element of HLS’s human-rating certification and part of an essential crew survival strategy. Key decisions on Blue Origin’s manual control design have yet to be made.

