Time for my sperging:
Even shit parents that refuse to watch their kids could put parental controls on devices even from the time I was a kid. There is nothing this law is going to do that actually matters. It's literally only a downside.
I'm early Gen Z and grew up during "Web 2.0". I remember during elementary school for our computer class we would be watched like hawks to make sure we weren't accessing something we weren't supposed to, even then the teacher who was basically the "IT department" only had whitelisting for specific websites enabled through the school network. We were also taught how to type, do various keyboard controls (this wasn't graded, mainly a showoff), and basic troubleshooting. I remember us having to watch
NetSmartz Kids in class and how to practice basic kid-level cybersecurity: don't open an email randomly (always check the sender, subject, attachments, don't run random programs, inform an adult if there was something that seemed wrong, and how a child could determine that without any experience or knowledge, couldn't tell ya), but basically, "Kid, don't be a fucking retard and stay in your lane." At the time during the 2000s, there was always a
huge emphasis on parental permission before doing
anything online, let alone just going online. Disney Channel (or any kids TV channel) promoting something on their website would also be ended with, "ask for parent's permission before going online." As kids, my brother and I would always play local PC games (Roller Coaster Tycoon, Zoo Tycoon, Rocket Power) our parents got with the PC bundle of the time (I think it was Windows 98, my infant memory for whatever reason is very good and I can remember pretty vivid details still) and basically our Dad would deflect any question about the internet, since one, he didn't fully understand it yet himself, plus it was Dial-Up until like 2003, and calls were always coming and going out the house. Even when the internet came more accessible, parents would talk to the technicians at BestBuy on how to setup the parental controls and how to use them. Right around the early 2010s social media boom, that all that went out the window since everyone had their own mobile device, mainly thanks to the iPod Touch, and there were virtually no guard-rails in place for kids anymore.
The arguement I hear from people is, "well then they will just get on these things at a friends house". Which is so fucking dumb to me. There is a big difference between having 24 hour access to all this stuff
How many kids these days actually have time limits for their devices? I remember only having like 90 minutes a day, then being forced to play outside afterwards once time was up, and my mom would take that shit to work with her, if we got banned from it.
Just recently, I had to setup parental controls on routers in my apartment complex because the parents don't know what to fucking do about control their kids internet usage. I have internet cutting out on specific devices at bedtime so even if the kid gets the device after bedtime, they can't use it (at least on their home network). When they ask me what else they can do, I tell them to be better fucking parents and assert authority over their kids young so when they're teens, they're hopefully less rebellious.
If most parents dont give a fuck about what their children view, why should the rest of us lose our privacy and anonymity/pseudonimity to some gigatech company for something that has no popular support?
I always tell conservatives who support age verification, that the underlying principle is the same when it comes to firearms. "Why do responsible gun owners have to be punished when someone else does something wrong with a gun?" It's hilarious watching them short-circuit, because you call out a contradiction in their stance on the underlying principle. They're all about personal safety and responsibility when it comes to gun ownership, so why is it different when it comes to the internet? They don't go crying to the government for more regulation when someone does something wrong with a gun, except to punish the criminal. So why are you going to the government crying for regulation because you are terrible parents and can't control your kids online behavior?