Valedictorian Pulls Switcheroo on Commencement Speech

You know the drill. Every valedictorian has to get her speech approved before she delivers it at commencement. You can’t let high school kids — even really smart, hardworking, responsible kids — just get up and say whatever they want to say. That leads to chaos and rioting.

So Paxton Smith, the valedictorian of Lake Highlands High School’s Class of 2021, with her 104.93 average, submitted her speech ahead of Sunday’s commencement ceremony at the high school stadium. It was about media and how much of it she consumes and how that consumption has shaped the way she sees the world.

But another matter kept nagging at her. She couldn’t stop thinking about the “heartbeat bill” that Gov. Greg Abbott had signed into law last month. The law prohibits abortions as early as six weeks, before many women know they are pregnant, and it matters not if the pregnancy results from incest or rape. Abortion rights activists say it is the most restrictive law in the country. It will go into effect in September.

The more Smith thought about it, the more she was drawn to the conclusion that there was nothing more important that she could address with her time at the microphone.

Smith talked to her three parents about her decision. Two of them read her new speech and approved; the third wasn’t thrilled but agreed to keep quiet.

She’s an outgoing person by nature, but knowing what sort of reaction her remarks might spark filled Smith with trepidation leading up to Sunday. She practiced the speech again and again, to the point that she didn’t need to think about the words. On Sunday, as she climbed the stairs to the stage, her mind went blank.

At the lectern, with a shaky voice, she began by thanking one of her coaches. Then she pulled from her bra a single piece of paper, folded in quarters, and told people what was on her mind. Her voice grew stronger with each sentence. At the end of her three minutes, she was in full command of that stage.

See for yourself. Smith’s speech starts at the 4:30 mark:


Two days after her speech, Smith says, “It feels great. It also feels a little weird. Whenever I have opinions that can be considered political or controversial, I keep them to myself because I don’t like to gain attention for that kind of stuff. But I’m glad that I could do something, and I’m glad that it’s getting attention. It just feels weird for me personally, that I’m linked to the attention that the speech got.”

Some of the attention she got, of course, was from administrators. She heard from a couple who initially said that the school could withhold her diploma, but nothing has come of that. Smith is headed to UT Austin and says she doesn’t yet know what she wants to study.

I asked her if there was anything else she wanted people to know.

“Oh, my goodness,” Smith said, as she considered the question. “Well, I would like them to know that they should register to vote for the next election and to stay involved in local elections because those have more power than I think the media gives them credit for.”

From her lips to God’s and Gov. Abbott’s ears.

***

Paxton Smith
Valedictory Address
May 30, 2021
As we leave high school we need to make our voices heard. I was going to get up here and talk to you about TV and content and media because those are things that are very important to me. However, in light of recent events, it feels wrong to talk about anything but what is currently affecting me and millions of other women in this state.
Recently the heartbeat bill was passed in Texas. Starting in September, there will be a ban on abortions that take place after 6 weeks of pregnancy, regardless of whether the pregnancy was a result of rape or incest. 6 weeks. Most women don’t even realize they’re pregnant by then. And so, before they have the time to decide if they are emotionally, physically, and financially stable enough to carry out a full-term pregnancy, before they have the chance to decide if they can take on the responsibility of bringing another human into the world, the decision has been made for them by a stranger. A decision that will affect the rest of their lives.
I have dreams, hopes, and ambitions. Every girl here does. We have spent our whole lives working towards our futures, and without our consent or input, our control over our futures has been stripped away from us. I am terrified that if my contraceptives fail me, that if I’m raped, then my hopes and efforts and dreams for myself will no longer be relevant. I hope you can feel how gut-wrenching it is, how dehumanizing it is, to have the autonomy over your own body taken from you.
And I’m talking about this today, on a day as important as this, on a day honoring the students’ efforts in twelve years of schooling, on a day where we’re all brought together, on a day where you will be the most inclined to hear a voice like mine, a woman’s voice, to tell you that this is a problem. A problem that can’t wait. I refuse to give up this platform to promote complacency and peace, when there is a war on my body and a war on my rights. A war on the rights of your sisters, a war on the rights of your mothers, a war on the rights of your daughters.
We cannot stay silent.

 
Why does bodily autonomy matter when it comes to killing babies but not when it comes to me wanting to keep my money?

I always thought the idea of a paper abortion was good. Basically if the woman wants to keep it and the man doesn't then he can terminate all rights to the child, never allowed contact, etc.

Sounds fair, right? Nope. The amount of pro-life arguments used to justify why the man is still on the hook is insane.

"Should have kept it in his pants"
"It's a living being and it needs all the support"
"The man should have used a condom"

Just shows that it's not about bodily autonomy but an excuse to wield power over another individual while being allowed fo justify their own selfish actions.
 
I always thought the idea of a paper abortion was good. Basically if the woman wants to keep it and the man doesn't then he can terminate all rights to the child, never allowed contact, etc.

Sounds fair, right? Nope. The amount of pro-life arguments used to justify why the man is still on the hook is insane.

"Should have kept it in his pants"
"It's a living being and it needs all the support"
"The man should have used a condom"

Just shows that it's not about bodily autonomy but an excuse to wield power over another individual while being allowed fo justify their own selfish actions.
I mean I was talking about taxes but these are good points.
 
I always thought the idea of a paper abortion was good. Basically if the woman wants to keep it and the man doesn't then he can terminate all rights to the child, never allowed contact, etc.
It's pretty terrible imho. It fucks over the only innocent party here: the baby. The man had a choice to be there, the woman had a choice to be there, but the baby didn't. And you can't just throw money at a child and call it done. And 99.9% of the time, that financial abortion isn't enough to raise 50% of the child.

If you're not willing to deal with the potential consequence of a baby, don't have unprotected sex.
 
If you're not willing to deal with the potential consequence of a baby, don't have unprotected sex.

Agreed, hence why abortions should be illegal. Keep your pants on and legs closed unless you want to deal with the consequences.

Im assuming you hold your opinion across both sexes and not just the man who help to a high standard of parental responsibility, right?
 
Last edited:
Maybe you wouldn't be, but others in this thread sure would be. They'd be calling her "based" and other autistic things
No, most of us would agree with her while still saying she‘s being a narcissist and that it’s not the appropriate place.

It’s possible (for most people here) to support someone’s position and still think they expressed it in a retarded fashion.
 
Pro-choicers who treat abortion like it is a form of contraception unrionically shifted me towards the pro-life angle. I seriously never understand why they can't afford the extremely cheap contraceptives available at their local pharmacy.
It’s more than that really. Before I would’ve been in the same boat. Abortion is something that’s a grim or unnerving, but ultimately understandable thing that probably has to be around in some form; but they’re so self-righteous and smug about it. It’s hard to put to words how fucking grotesque and off-putting that is.
 
It’s more than that really. Before I would’ve been in the same boat. Abortion is something that’s a grim or unnerving, but ultimately understandable thing that probably has to be around in some form; but they’re so self-righteous and smug about it. It’s hard to put to words how fucking grotesque off-putting that is.
The age old conundrum of
>I agree with this position due to raw principle
>But holy hell the people on my side are a bunch of retarded cunts

I feel like most of my positions end up like that.
 
No, most of us would agree with her while still saying she‘s being a narcissist and that it’s not the appropriate place.

It’s possible (for most people here) to support someone’s position and still think they expressed it in a retarded fashion.
I highly, highly doubt that. You guys would be simping hard for her because she'd be "based"
 
I highly, highly doubt that. You guys would be simping hard for her because she'd be "based"
I'd be willing to give the benefit of the doubt on this one. I personally agree this law is gay and dumb, but I'd be cringing my ass off if I was forced to sit through this shit. No one wants to be ambushed by politics at a celebration.
 
The age old conundrum of
>I agree with this position due to raw principle
>But holy hell the people on my side are a bunch of retarded cunts

I feel like most of my positions end up like that.
And eventually it makes you question what their real motivations are, which usually just leads to frustration and feeling like you’re being lied to.
 
The age old conundrum of
>I agree with this position due to raw principle
>But holy hell the people on my side are a bunch of retarded cunts

I feel like most of my positions end up like that.
It’s like I used to say about Twitter - debate abhors a vacuum, and only the craziest can shout forever, because everyone else either gets what they want, finds compromise or eventually just qgree to disagree.
 
It’s more than that really. Before I would’ve been in the same boat. Abortion is something that’s a grim or unnerving, but ultimately understandable thing that probably has to be around in some form; but they’re so self-righteous and smug about it. It’s hard to put to words how fucking grotesque and off-putting that is.
I wish I had saved it but there was this upload of a TikTok clip where some lady gloats about how she's going to abort the baby like a fucking child. She goes as far to drink wine while showing a little of a bump if I recall.
 
Back