Jim Sterling / James "Stephanie" Sterling / James Stanton/Sexton & in memoriam TotalBiscuit (John Bain) - One Gaming Lolcow Thread

If he was smart (and not lazy), he would have kept the three things separate instead of forcing them all into one video.

RedLetterMedia are, as always, a good example: They divide their content into different shows, because analytical discussion of niche films has a different audience to contemporary film reviews or laughing at B-movies, though I'm sure there is a lot of crossover since it's all film-related. If they tried to cram Nerd Crew, Best of the Worst and re:View content into one episode of Half in the Bag, though. it would be a total clusterfuck.

If Jim wanted to do his political/gender shit and his wrestling crap he could have made separate channels or at least separate shows, but he knows JQ is the only reason anyone knows who he is so he used it as the vector to force this other shit on people who are there for one thing only, and that never, ever works (just look how popular Nostalgia Critic's sketch comedy insertions were).
Believe it or not, Jim is smart enough to understand that concept. His videos used to be a lot more focused. But he's lazy, and so he started amalgamating all those videos that should by all rights be their own thing, or at least part of different series, into his flagship series; Jimquisition. It's like he thought to himself "wrestling videos would get no views, but I want people to see my fat ass wobbling around in a shiny spandex suit... oh, I know! I'll tack them on to my flagship show so the audience has to go through my wrestling footage before they get to what they want to see! What ever could go wrong?!", and now he's suffering the consequences of it going wrong.

He could go back to multiple shows, absolutely. His "heaving (toy) chest" videos seem to be an attempt to go back to that model. But I think he realized that requires effort. He doesn't have enough content for a 10-minute weekly or even biweekly wrestling show, even if the show was unscripted and only required minimum editing. All he's got are 3 minutes of footage of him wheezing and posturing around a makeshift ring. Fuck, he doesn't even have enough content for Jimquisition, that's why he's so repetitive. He has fallen into the trap of autistically sticking to very limited subjects, while at the same time promising regular content.

If Jim had the ability to get off his ass and actually work, he could try to pivot Jimquisition into a more documentarian format, something like what Stu "Ahoy" Brown does: longer-form videos on very specific subjects, with independent research. Make it like an actual inquisition: an investigation on a subject. Ahoy releases a video every full moon, but the algorithm loves him because his long-form content grabs eyeballs. Round out the gaps in Jim's content by creating another channel with shorter and to-the-point news videos and his dumbass Squirty Plays and there you have a business model. But that's all too much effort for our dear gendertrash Jimbo. He'd rather wallow in his growing irrelevance instead.

OT: Right that's 3 porno games in a row now, can we call this more than a coincidence yet??
So far my suspicions that his reservations about the kind of content he posts (let's be honest, he never really had standards) are being eroded by the gendercult seem to be correct.
 
Also can be because stuff like this drives views. I don't think Jim is unavare of subscriber bleed.
2 years ago he was getting 7 to 10 million views a month.
A year ago he was getting ~5 million views a month.
Now he's getting less than 1.5 million views a month.

Jim knows he losing subscribers and views. He either doesn't care or doesn't know how to get more views. (Or both)

I'm expecting some hilarious sperging when he drops under 800k subs or gets less than 1 million views in a month.
 
He could go back to multiple shows, absolutely. His "heaving (toy) chest" videos seem to be an attempt to go back to that model. But I think he realized that requires effort.
He also probably noticed the absolutely pathetic views those toy videos got and it either hurt his ego or made him double down on the realisation the only way to get people to watch his other inane bullshit was cramming it into the only show people care about.
If Jim had the ability to get off his ass and actually work, he could try to pivot Jimquisition into a more documentarian format, something like what Stu "Ahoy" Brown does:
I agree, but I would hate to see Jim and his snarky, miserable attitude attempt long-form documentaries in the style of Ahoy.

I can already imagine his Silent Hill retrospective; constantly cramming in 'FUCK KONAMI' memes and that trailer for the pachinko machine every five seconds.
 
2 years ago he was getting 7 to 10 million views a month.
A year ago he was getting ~5 million views a month.
Now he's getting less than 1.5 million views a month.

Jim knows he losing subscribers and views. He either doesn't care or doesn't know how to get more views. (Or both)

I'm expecting some hilarious sperging when he drops under 800k subs or gets less than 1 million views in a month.
You could say that if Jim was known to adhere to a solid thought-out plan for long periods of time. This looks more like a damage control attempt, because interest boost from Jim transitioning into Jim faded away and subscribers are still leaving. This could help somewhat, because all kinds of vaguely erotic shit drive clicks(and possibly subs) from randoms. Never understood why it works, because not only there are loads of actual porn in the internet for free, you can find full-on frontal nudity on youtube itself. But one has to be a real "spechial" kind of individual to search it specifically on youtube. Regardless, it should somewhat work. At least usually it does. Maybe that's why Jim only looses 1K subs a week, and not 1.2K or 1.5k.
 
Maybe that's why Jim only looses 1K subs a week, and not 1.2K or 1.5k.
Jim loses more than that. The rate of his sub loss is increasing.

jims-subs-fucking-off.png
 
Even then I think his channel had the same problem it has today, its sheer repetitiveness. Jim has always only had a handful of topics that he would talk about at any one time, and the fact the Jimquisition is a weekly show meant he would often talk about the same things over and over again to fill up time. Even at his best he was only enjoyable in small doses.
There really was a point in time where Jim could look at a decent variety of topics without them feeling like they just all overlapped. The repetitiveness came as he started to equate everything together like some sort of "Beautiful Mind" conspiracy theorist. His videos are covered with those red threads tacked from story to story now and it all just started to run together. All his Jimquisitions now can basically boil down to "Capitalism Bad, Transphobia, Genocide, Catch Phrase, Catch Phrase" Cue the fucking song.
 
I swear I'll never understand how people like Jim can go from having tantrums about "realistic depictions of women, oversexualization, pandering to the male gaze," and all that other moralism they spew and then turn right around and play games that crank all of it to eleven like the words had never crossed their mouths. If it weren't for double standards and all that, I suppose.
Almost if he was a contradicting hypocrite
 
The theme is: laziness.

Jim doesn't have the camera on for those "Squirty Plays" (any Britbongs around to explain what's the joke in that name?), and they're ultra low-effort videos without scripting and minimal editing. So he just takes a promotional image or a screencap, puts some text over it, and calls it a day.
The ooollllddd "Squirty Plays" logo was in white and had dribbling bits off the end. Yes, it was a masturbation/jizz joke.

I still remember when he changed the name to something else to make his 'brand' more 'marketable'. Looks like he un-did that while losing what little bit of sanity he still possessed.
 
View attachment 2664052
Seems like the rate of sub loss is decreasing, rather than increasing. If it was increasing, the "80%" would be in red, with a downward arrow.
It's 80% more of a loss. The site wasn't coded with the expectation of people losing subs.

He lost 6k in September and is on pace for 9k this month. It tracks the last 30 days, not specific months.

Due to whatever the release schedule was, it is possible that the period it is being compared with had 5k subs lost.

5k * 1.8 = 9k
 
The ooollllddd "Squirty Plays" logo was in white and had dribbling bits off the end. Yes, it was a masturbation/jizz joke.

I still remember when he changed the name to something else to make his 'brand' more 'marketable'. Looks like he un-did that while losing what little bit of sanity he still possessed.
He was fixated on cum for a while. His reason that Steam should have quality control involved a scenario in which you go to Toys R Us for a teddy bear, and find them covered in jizz. I think he even made that comparison on the Co Optional Podcast.
 
He was fixated on cum for a while. His reason that Steam should have quality control involved a scenario in which you go to Toys R Us for a teddy bear, and find them covered in jizz. I think he even made that comparison on the Co Optional Podcast.
Pretty sure thats the title of a jimquisition
I mean, "cum covered teddy bears" is the joke in a segment of FistShark Marketing, an old improv comedy podcast Jim used to do.

The bit is called High Demand in episode 108, it is the first segment of the episode, lasting from 0:40 to 10:25. There is 9 minutes and 45 seconds of the joke "jizz covered teddy bears". It was during the shittiest days of FSM IMO. Like FSM wasn't ever good, but I enjoyed it, I am sure most of us here enjoyed Jim's work at some point, and at one point I shared Jim's sense of humour, then he devolved into an even bigger degenerate and I stopped sharing it. FSM is also an under discussed portion of Jim's lore, probably because it was a non-gaming related side project he managed to actually keep away from his gaming content, so fuck it, just for some change lets revisit this old podcast together.

The premise was entertaining enough to me, and the absurd super natural Nightvale-esque lore was something I liked. I still listen to it as background noise from time to time. An interesting thing about having re-listened to all 145 epsodes multiple times is I can track the rot of Jim during the four years or so it ran, and one thing I will say, you can see that Jim got objectively shittier with all his endeavors due to Trump Derangement Syndrome. The whole idea was the main cast worked for some cartoonishly inept and immoral corporate marketing firm (also you can tell no one on the show actually understood what marketing firms actually DO, not to mention the company seemed to lack any form of focus or specialization in who it represented or even what it actually did, but suspension of disbelief is a thing), and as time went on it was revealed that things definitely weren't normal, legal, or even sane. It had a setting kind of like a knock off Nightvale, but corporate and based in Boston for some reason. They also make all the various celebrities they seem to represent seem like complete nutters, so this must be some alternative universe shit for any of this to make sense.

Episodes 1-50 were definitely the best, the rot was minimal and it seemed like Jim actually enjoyed the project. There was a solid chemistry between him and Conrad, with Caitlin Cooke being a good balancing force. The formula worked and this is when much of the lore was established and it was a good time. There are very few misses during this section, though in episode 50 we run into the first "scripted" episode, where Cait is written out and dies at the end.

Jim and Conrad did fine for the half dozen or so episodes of just them together until they had Jonathan Holmes join them as Paulson Sear, who lacked the right chemistry with Jim and Conrad. Him being the innocent, normal, not cartoony straightman kind hearted person was a good role for him, he knew how to play the part, and the idea was sound, he just didn't have the chemistry with Jim and Conrad to make it work. This is also where more political episodes start slipping in, I still like the majority of these episodes, but it was starting to become hit or miss here, I remember these being the first times new episodes would come out and I would go "man, this one just isn't working" or "when does the next segment start? This bit sucks" while listening to it. However, like Cait, Paulson gets killed off in episode 100, though they did try to play up towards it narratively and set it up and is the only time the story was really a big part of the podcast. That said 100 is a rather shit episode that just didn't work. The follow up, 101, was actually pretty good. I liked it, and is the last episode to really play off of the story of Paulson, and is a Jim and Conrad only episode. Any plans for actual storytelling end, and it is back to the usual call backs and references to previous bits of lore as far as continuity goes.

The last 44 episodes from 102 to 145 are only down hill, this was FAR more miss than hit. It is only Jim and Conrad, and Trump Derangement Syndrome is in full force, not to mention Jim has now been doing Podquisition for quite a while with LKD, so the dumb degenerate shit was really starting to eat at Jim's brain in earnest. These are some of the most random and political episodes of the entire series, and there is only one episode here I remember fondly, and that is episode 114: The New Frog. This one is unique, as it is entirely its own bit, isn't framed as a meeting in the office but rather a presentation to various investors, and I just like it. This section also has the most call backs to old lore, shit references to real events happening in the world, politics, and degeneracy. These 44 episodes date themselves harder than the other 101 episodes ever did.

Without warning in episode 145 the change the outro from "FistShark is" to "FistShark was" as they read out the credits, as a subtle way to hint they just killed the series. Not only that, but they started to set up a potential storyline in that episode that had me interested to see where it would go, just to immediately blue ball me. Why did they kill the series? Well apparently because "Jim's career is going so well, and Conrad is a super serious and professional game developer now (who only went on to ever make one game) also it is hard to make an absurd parody of reality when reality is so crazy itself!". [ARCHIVE] So they killed FistShark Marketing and sneakily turned its patreon into Conrad Zimmerman's personal patreon so he could soak up the money from all the people who were already subscribed and didn't bother to unsub rather than kill it and start a new one. I think Boston's Favourite Son is in the same universe and is a spiritual successor to FSM, but I haven't bothered sitting down and listening to it all yet to decide that, I got better things to do and I want to actually examine that podcast so I can rip into it sometime.

Speaking of Jim's podcasts and Conrad Zimmerman, let me give you the message Gavin "Miracle of Sound" Dunn gave as the reason he was leaving Podquisition in September of 2019 [ARCHIVE]. Him leaving was the last straw for me and that postcast, I appreciated his optimism, and you could tell LKD and Jim didn't share his views on video games, both hating the industry, and Jim in particular just hating video games by that point. How does Conrad relate to this? Why, he replaced Gavin on the Podquisition of course!
 

Attachments

Apropos of nothing I decided to go back and compile a collection of JQs over time to chart the viewcount drop-off. I tried to pick relatively innocuous topics to discount spikes from viral stories.

JQ Views Over Time.png
Some other interesting data points I gathered in my trawling through this year's JQs:
  • Only one video managed to break 500k views ('I Can't Believe A Developer Tried To Kill My Channel', 507k views)
  • No other video got north of 400k
  • 9 JQs (out of 43 published in 2021) broke 300k
  • Average JQ viewcount in 2021 is roughly 240k
  • Average JQ viewcount in 2019 was roughly 640k
No idea what I expect anyone to do with this info but I was clearly feeling autistic this morning and decided to crunch some numbers.
 
Apropos of nothing I decided to go back and compile a collection of JQs over time to chart the viewcount drop-off. I tried to pick relatively innocuous topics to discount spikes from viral stories.

View attachment 2666506
Some other interesting data points I gathered in my trawling through this year's JQs:
  • Only one video managed to break 500k views ('I Can't Believe A Developer Tried To Kill My Channel', 507k views)
  • No other video got north of 400k
  • 9 JQs (out of 43 published in 2021) broke 300k
  • Average JQ viewcount in 2021 is roughly 240k
  • Average JQ viewcount in 2019 was roughly 640k
No idea what I expect anyone to do with this info but I was clearly feeling autistic this morning and decided to crunch some numbers.
I don't want to be unfair, but in my personal opinion, these thumbnails suck. The thumbnails don't tell you much about the video, since any textspace is taken up by both Sterling and the Jimqusition text, so there isn't any sign of what the video is about at a glance. The one on the left is particular is awful, since it feels so cluttered, either isaac needs to be removed or Sterling should have made their logo slightly smaller. So is the second one from the right.

The other ones, if you forced me to guess about their topics, I'd assume (left to right)
  1. Mobile games/games in general and how they're trying to force your friends to get hooked as well
  2. Problems with Pw2/DLC/AAA industry
  3. Either greedy devs, someone faking to be a community figurehead, or scams
The second one from the right? I don't know, modern art?

I'm not saying his videos are dying because of this or dropping in veiws, it's just something I don't really like.
 
I stopped listening to Podquision after Gavin left. I wasn't a huge fan of Gavin anyway but he was a *much needed* counterweight to Jims and the trans's insanity. I still remember LKD running a gofundme to get his dick chopped off and then the subsequent episodes after that just made me uncomfortable as hell.
 
I stopped listening to Podquision after Gavin left. I wasn't a huge fan of Gavin anyway but he was a *much needed* counterweight to Jims and the trans's insanity. I still remember LKD running a gofundme to get his dick chopped off and then the subsequent episodes after that just made me uncomfortable as hell.
If it makes you feel better on the bright side at least LKD will never be able to have children.
 
Back