Yes, the pro-abortion side argued for all or nothing, which I thought was the most interesting takeaway of the day.
The pro-abortion side said they can't uphold Mississippi's 15-week ban and say that Roe and Casey are still in effect. They clearly wouldn't be because the justices would have to ignore all the text of the decisions to let the 15-week ban stand. The pro-life side said that the viability standard is nonsensical and unworkable, and nothing else the court tries to sub in as a better standard is going to be any less arbitrary, since viability is subjective and premies are being born earlier and surviving all the time. An abortion compromise such as Roe has to, by its nature, be extremely technical, and a court is not well equipped to create that standard.
Neither side left the judges much room to maneuver for a compromise. This puts Roberts and maybe some other fence-sitters in a tough spot. From today's arguments, I think Kavanaugh is fully on board with "return it to the states" being the best compromise that can be found. It's just going to be hard for them to go digging into the Constitution to come up with some third standard that makes sense, as both sides have told them not to bother. Either this is settled constitutional law, don't fiddle with it, or scrap it and start over. That makes it easier for them to throw up their hands and say, "You guys figure it out." A particularly strong point is that legislators are perfectly equipped to write definitions about what "viable" means if a state wants to allow some abortions, whereas the Court just creates a standard and leaves it untouched for 50 years. They're the only ones who can "update" it, and people are going to keep coming back to them for updates until they wash their hands of it.
If they do that, I hope they give the opinion to Thomas. Barrett would be a good choice because she's the conservative woman, but Thomas writes beautifully on this issue.
He started talking during Trump's term. Him speaking up is basically him putting his hand on Roberts' neck and whispering, "My court now."