US Loudoun County asks parent to pay $36K for FOIA request for documents regarding 'sexual assault' or 'rape' - Wayde Byard, a public information officer with Loudoun County Public Schools, said there were 100,065 “potential documents” in response to her request.

1638571416801.png

A parent was told by Loudoun County Public Schools in Virginia that it would cost tens of thousands of dollars to gain access to all the public records relating to sexual assault and rape incidents across several months this year.

The parent, Michelle Mege, was informed $36,000 would be the tab for the county to fully respond to her Freedom of Information Act request on Oct. 18, according to the Daily Caller. In particular, she requested access to "all communications, including press releases, statements, emails, or other correspondence in any format within the LCPS possession" which contained the words "sexual assault" or "rape" between May 1 and Oct. 18.

Wayde Byard, a public information officer with Loudoun County Public Schools, said there were 100,065 "potential documents" in response to her request.

"Retrieving these documents would take a half hour's work by the supervisor of information technology at a cost of $36.08," he added. "Review of these documents, at the rate of 200 per hour, is estimated to take 500 hours. This work would be performed by the public information officer at the rate of $72.15 per hour. Loudoun County Public Schools estimates it would cost $36,111.68 to fulfill this request."

Ian Prior, the founder of Fight for Schools, told the news outlet that the amount of money requested by the county was "concerning" and amounted to a "roadblock."

Mege made the FOIA request after two sexual assaults that occurred at two separate schools involving the same teenager about which parents have accused the county of a cover-up.

The 15-year-old male pleaded no contest last month to charges of abduction and sexual battery for what a prosecutor said was him forcing a female student into an empty classroom and then touching her breast. The no-contest plea means the teenager conceded that there is enough evidence for a conviction but does not admit guilt. The incident occurred in October, months after the defendant switched to Broad Run High School while there was a sheriff's investigation into the first incident in May at Stone Bridge High School, for which he was convicted of rape. He will be sentenced on Dec. 13 for both cases.

Scott Mineo, another Loudoun County parent, who runs an organization called Parents Against Critical Race Theory, also made a FOIA request. He was charged $180.37 for roughly two and a half hours of work and was asked to pay $432.90 for five hours of work in order to search through 958 emails that contained "exemptions and possible redactions," according to the report.

The Washington Examiner reached out to LCPS for comment.


 
A parent was told by Loudoun County Public Schools in Virginia that it would cost tens of thousands of dollars to gain access to all the public records relating to sexual assault and rape incidents across several months this year.

The parent, Michelle Mege, was informed $36,000 would be the tab for the county to fully respond to her Freedom of Information Act request on Oct. 18, according to the Daily Caller. In particular, she requested access to "all communications, including press releases, statements, emails, or other correspondence in any format within the LCPS possession" which contained the words "sexual assault" or "rape" between May 1 and Oct. 18.
With how popular Me Too accusations got I would imagine there are tons of kids that started treating all sorts of interactions as sexual assault and complained to the school about it.
 
They're reports, not confirmed assaults.
Yeah, but the entire school population (81,326) is smaller than the number of documents related to sexual assaults in the county.


That kind of indicates there is something seriously wrong there even if a lot of those are just bullshit reports.
 
They need a venal and slimy lawyer to initiate a nuisance lawsuit to compel discovery, which the school district would be required, by law, to produce under a deadline, for free. This would also require the school district to spend real money on their own venal and slimy lawyers,who would love nothing more than to be able to generate many, many billable hours. At some point, when the billable hours and fees start drastically cutting into the school's budget, the parent's lawyer can tell them they'd settle for the records they originally requested. And attorney's fees.

It's a teachable moment, as educators like to say.
 
Over 100k documents? Sounds like something to crowdfund because that many documents just for THIS YEAR alone is sickening.
You realize that this is so, insanely broad it covers things like emails saying "sexual assault awareness week! Be on the lookout!" And thousands of pages of documents referring to policy and procedure. It is literally everything in the school system that even has the words "sexual assault" in it.

What they should've done is request everything in regards to this specific incident, which would probably be on the order of hundreds or maybe low thousands of pages.
 
You realize that this is so, insanely broad it covers things like emails saying "sexual assault awareness week! Be on the lookout!" And thousands of pages of documents referring to policy and procedure. It is literally everything in the school system that even has the words "sexual assault" in it.

What they should've done is request everything in regards to this specific incident, which would probably be on the order of hundreds or maybe low thousands of pages.
They want to know how many more tranny bathroom rapes were covered up. Everyone knows about this incident.
 
With how popular Me Too accusations got I would imagine there are tons of kids that started treating all sorts of interactions as sexual assault and complained to the school about it.
For every 1 genuine incident, I too believe they'll find 500 instances of "Jimmy says I had cooties" -tier "sexual assault" .
 
May 1 through Oct. 18 is:
31+30+31+31+30+18 = 171 days.
31+30+31+31+30+18 = 79 days, if I just lop off the months I assume are summer vacation.
(31+30+31+31+30+18)/7*5= 57 days, excluding weekends

100,065 potential documents split into 57 days is 1,755 documents per business day.

According to Moon1488, there are 81,326 students. Assuming each document is one report from one student, 1,755 documents would be like if 2% of the student population made a report every school day.

2% feels like a small number, but daily?

I sure hope a lot of those documents were just CC's of a single email and not acutely reports/accusations made by students.

Right, and they could've FOIA requested "any documents that relate to sexual assault cases or allegations that occurred on school grounds." Asking for literally any document that contains "sexual assault" is insane.
I think they'd still be stuck with the 100k potential matches and the $32k bill, since they would likely still do the same search and use a human to filter it down.

I wonder just how many potential matches I would say are unimportant though... If someone was stupid enough to have a Google alert set for "school rape trials" then it might not be relevant to the school, but that would probably create a lot of hits. On the other hand as part of a sex ed consent course, it would be reasonable but I can't imagine it being more than a dozen hits. Especially because as stated earlier, over half of the search period should have been over summer vacation when the students were out.
 
Why should the parents pay for checking for reviewing to make redactions or other details? That should be on the school if they are concerned about censoring data.
 
Right, and they could've FOIA requested "any documents that relate to sexual assault cases or allegations that occurred on school grounds." Asking for literally any document that contains "sexual assault" is insane.
This schoolboard has already shown itself to lie, sometimes you're forced to cast a wide net.

I can't imagine anyone simping for Loudon' schoolboard, but here we are, I guess.
 
This schoolboard has already shown itself to lie, sometimes you're forced to cast a wide net.

I can't imagine anyone simping for Loudon' schoolboard, but here we are, I guess.
The problem is that if you cast your net too wide when making FOIA requests, you end up with this exact situation. The district is required to comply with the request; they are not required to do it for free (outside of very specific scenarios that would require a much narrower request).
 
Back