Opinion Savage Love: I Am a Straight Man Into Extreme Kink—but It’s Easier to Find Gay Men Into What I Like

Link (Archive)

Savage Love: I Am a Straight Man Into Extreme Kink—but It’s Easier to Find Gay Men Into What I Like​

I’m extremely kinky, with an emphasis on extreme. To give an example, I love long-term and extremely restrictive bondage—think full-body casts or getting locked up for an entire weekend.

I’m a 32-year-old straight male who has been married for five years. In the last year, we opened up our marriage, because my sexual desires were putting too much of a strain on the marriage. My wife is incredible, and we do many wonderful kinky things together, but I needed more—more frequency, more intensity. Since then, I’ve seen some other women, but looking around, I came to the realization that gay men have all the fun! I often see these incredibly intense sexual experiences that I so desire in amateur gay porn or on various gay men’s fetish profiles. I think men have a higher propensity to pursue these kinds of things.

I’ve been talking to a guy who shares a very similar set of kinks, and it’s been great. He showed me Recon, which has opened up a whole new world to me.

I’m struggling right now. It’s like a battle between my identity as a kinkster/fetishist and my identity as straight man. I think the former is going to win, but certain things concern me. I don’t know if I’ll feel repulsed to have, say, a dick in my mouth. And I don’t want the poor guy who I play with to have to deal with my own internal psychological drama. I grew up in a very rural area that was extremely homophobic. I was bullied and called a faggot constantly. I’ve just recently been feeling less shame about being kinky, and now there’s this whole other level of shame that I am scared to contend with.

Am I silly for considering doing stuff with men, even though I’m a lot more attracted to women, just in order to fulfill these kinks?

Brooding Over Unmet Needs Daily

“I felt very much in this person’s shoes at one point in my life,” said bondage porn star James “Heavy” Woelfel.

Just like you, BOUND, Heavy was always turned on by extremely heavy bondage scenarios. That was the reason he chose “Heavy Bondage for Life” as his porn name. And just like you, BOUND, Heavy once felt conflicted about getting tied by other men, because he didn’t identify as gay or bisexual at the time.

“I was really worried that if I played with men, that meant my identity had to change, too,” said Heavy, looking back at that time in his life. “But seeking out other genders to play with doesn’t necessarily have to change your identity.”

Heavy’s identity ultimately did change—he now identifies as queer—but he wants you to know that your identity doesn’t have to change. “I view bondage the same as getting together with friends for a round of golf, or shooting hoops, or watching a movie or game together,” said Heavy. “I’ve had many bondage encounters that involved sex, but I’ve had even more that were simply about the bondage itself.”

What Heavy is suggesting here, BOUND, is that you can meet up with another guy for a heavy bondage scene and enjoy the bondage—and even get off on the bondage—without having “sex.” You can consent to being a guy’s bondage sub for an evening or a weekend without having to consent to sucking his dick or letting him fuck your ass.

“BOUND just needs to be direct about what he’s looking for when he reaches out to the guys he might like to play with,” said Heavy. “He needs to have the same conversations he had with his wife about limits, comfortability levels and intentions. And if someone’s pushy about certain things that he’s unsure about, then they’re likely not the right person for him.”

Bondage tops on Recon with the kind of gear required to put you in truly restrictive bondage will most likely have heard from other straight and/or straight-identified guys who were in it for the bondage, not the sex. If simply getting to tie you up isn’t enough—if a gay bondage top isn’t interested in a bondage-only scene with you—he’ll decline to play with you.

“The most important thing is to find good and genuine people to share these kinds of experiences with,” said Heavy. “Bondage is inherently dangerous, especially when you’re the one being put in bondage, and it requires a lot of trust. BOUND needs to make sure he’s putting his trust in the right people.”

So how do you know if you’re interacting, negotiating and possibly playing with the right kind of guys? In addition to trusting your gut—always trust your gut—check their references. If you’re meeting bondage tops on Recon, you can send messages directly to the guys listed as friends on their profiles. Someone with a lot of friends (and a lot of original play pics) is a much safer bet than someone with no friends or pics, BOUND, but if you’re tempted to play with someone without friends listed on his profile, ask to be put in touch with other men he’s played with. If he refuses, BOUND, don’t play with him.

“The gay men I played with when I was still identifying as straight were generally very respectful,” added Heavy. “I did have a few experiences where my limits weren’t respected. But thankfully, I’m OK, and I learned from those experiences.”

And Heavy wants you to know that there are women out there who are into intense bondage.

“It’s a myth that only men play to the level BOUND is interested in playing at,” said Heavy. “Though I’ve had many incredible experiences with men, I’ve met just as many women that wanted to lock me up in the most serious forms of restraint you could ever imagine.”

Follow Heavy on Twitter @for_heavy, on Instagram @_heavybondage4life_, and Only Fans at Heavybondage4life.


As we come into the holidays, I am dreading having to spend time with my sibling-in-law. They are fake, self-absorbed and delusional. At family dinners, they always serve themselves first. They don’t wait until everyone is served before starting, and they are often finished before everyone is served. They chew with their mouth open and talk with their mouth full. They talk about themselves constantly. They are rapidly approaching middle age and have never held a full-time or permanent job. As far as anyone knows, they have never been kissed or even on a date.

At first, I tried to cut them some slack. They are sheltered and don’t really have any friends. Recently, I have taken to muting them on social media so that I don’t have to see their insipid posts. I have also started skipping events with my partner’s family, but I feel guilty when I do this. Also, I feel like it would be inappropriate to tell my partner how I feel.

So, what do I do? Continue to suck it up, or further distance myself and risk hurt feelings for being absent? Or do I come clean with my partner and risk hurting them? I don’t know what I would expect them to do other than offer me absolution for missing events.

In-Law Lacking Substance

If someone has terrible table manners—if someone chews with their mouth open—don’t you want them to serve themselves first and finish before you sit down to eat? As for the rest of it … it’s hard not to feel sorry for your sibling-in-law, ILLS, but it’s easy for me to feel sorry for them, because I don’t have to watch them chew or listen to them talk about themselves. And while avoiding your sibling-in-law this Christmas would be pretty simple (just plead Omicron), I don’t see how you can avoid seeing your partner’s sibling in the future—seeing and tolerating and, perhaps, finding some pity in your heart for them.
 
Wtf is this even real?

Instead of telling the man it's not gay if he doesn't fuck so go full faggot, my suggestions would be to:
  1. Find a dominatrix
  2. Set up a threesome
  3. Shoot some scenes for kink.com's femdom brands
Just because you're a degenerate doesn't mean you should give people you aren't comfortable with sexual access to your body.
 
Wtf is this even real?

Instead of telling the man it's not gay if he doesn't fuck so go full faggot, my suggestions would be to:
  1. Find a dominatrix
  2. Set up a threesome
  3. Shoot some scenes for kink.com's femdom brands
Just because you're a degenerate doesn't mean you should give people you aren't comfortable with sexual access to your body.

It’s a Dan Savage column. It’s about as “real” as the old Penthouse Forum letters except it’s for LBGTQWERTY shit. He’s been running that column for two decades now. It used to be amusing when you could laugh at the weirdos.
Those were the days...
 
If you are that attached to your sexuality as an identity then wtf is wrong with you, just go have some fun. Don't get me wrong, your fun is messed up as shit but if your identity is getting in the way of you living your life maybe it's doing you more harm than good.

Also "my identity as a kinkster" this is the gayest thing I've ever seen. Far gayer than two men lovingly pounding one another's assholes within the context of a married relationship.

People out here identifying as everything under the sun, i'm just gonna identify as a human and get off to that I guess.
 
Last edited:
It’s a Dan Savage column. It’s about as “real” as the old Penthouse Forum letters except it’s for LBGTQWERTY shit. He’s been running that column for two decades now. It used to be amusing when you could laugh at the weirdos.
Those were the days...

I regret googling him.

I should learn to use one of the nerdy command line browsers that can't handle pictures in order to avoid making this mistake in the future.
Y'all can shit on my boy Dan (even though he thinks that's A Fetish Too Far) but he was the Editor of The Stranger when this foundational piece of modern terfery was published and I bless him for it:

 
I love long-term and extremely restrictive bondage—think full-body casts or getting locked up for an entire weekend.
I’m a 32-year-old straight male man who was born in 1989 thus was first gen internet porn poisoned since I would’ve been in middle school during the Conjunction of the Spheres initial intersection of widely available broadband and escalating porn degeneracy.

Anyway, to you being locked up for an entire weekend sounds fun. For your wife it sounds like she has to take care of the house and kids and yard by herself while you coom. Or, if you don’t have any of those yet, it sounds like never having those things, unless she agrees in advance that she’ll take care of everything.

Your kink is a problem when it interferes with you living your life and tbqh being put in a body cast on the weekends kinda sounds like interfering with your life in a huge way, if you’re married to someone who does not wish to be involved with that at all.
 
I’m a 32-year-old straight male man who was born in 1989 thus was first gen internet porn poisoned since I would’ve been in middle school during the Conjunction of the Spheres initial intersection of widely available broadband and escalating porn degeneracy.

Anyway, to you being locked up for an entire weekend sounds fun. For your wife it sounds like she has to take care of the house and kids and yard by herself while you coom. Or, if you don’t have any of those yet, it sounds like never having those things, unless she agrees in advance that she’ll take care of everything.

Your kink is a problem when it interferes with you living your life and tbqh being put in a body cast on the weekends kinda sounds like interfering with your life in a huge way, if you’re married to someone who does not wish to be involved with that at all.
Also it's not unusual that these ideas are sexy in your head but bringing them out brings out just misery because you won't be satisfied. Weekend is just too long to keep full nice turned on mood going, so he most likely will either try adding drugs for better buzz or try something even more extreme because maybe I didn't do it right. Either way he would be better of treating this idea is as fun mental image for masturbation rather letting it mess up his life.
 
I was bullied and called a faggot constantly.
So, everyone has known he is a flaming faggot (except his wife) for decades.

He's a total degenerate with a sex addiction (hence the need to constantly up the kink as he grows a tolerance and no longer gets a high from the regular dose) and quite possibly a serious mental illness that hasn't yet been diagnosed (or he's hiding that from his wife, too).

He should divorce his wife because she's too stupid to look out for her own self-interests and go full gay. Then he can enjoy his lifestyle without worrying it makes him gay and his wife can maybe have a shot at finding someone who actually is attracted to her.
 
If you are that attached to your sexuality as an identity then wtf is wrong with you, just go have some fun. Don't get me wrong, your fun is messed up as shit but if your identity is getting in the way of you living your life maybe it's doing you more harm than good.

Also "my identity as a kinkster" this is the gayest thing I've ever seen. Far gayer than two men lovingly pounding one another's assholes within the context of a married relationship.

People out here identifying as everything under the sun, i'm just gonna identify as a human and get off to that I guess.
It only took like 6 years and now we're praising the sanctity of faggot marriage.
 
Back