- Joined
- Jan 14, 2019
first: Whataboutism, disney wasn't mentioned by anon as being better than her, but Lily only knows how to defend something by attacking something else.
second: just because the characters have similar elements doesn't mean they are copies, I'm sure there must be several stormtooper traitors, a grumpy jedi who doesn't believe in the Order anymore, and someone who fell for the dark side who was on the side of the heroes in Star Wars before
on the other hand, Aliana is perceived not only as a mash of characters but also of the author's ideas for the simple fact that she has literally access to the equivalent of Wookieepedia in the story, she knows everything that happened, even information that would be lost, she knows the motivations and thoughts of the characters (Lily's interpretation actually), knows every form of combat and force power, even those coming from the jedi, and even with 20 something years old she understands all this information perfectly to lecture everyone and never be wrong or be challenged.
Aliana is a character made to subvert everything that Lily doesn't like in Star Wars even to the detriment of established lore, logic and other characters, as I said Lily doesn't know how to defend her ideas without attacking everything else