The card for Double or Nothing is a mess.
- The Hookhausen Pre Show Match is, admittedly, kind of fun. I don't remember being this invested in a PreShow match, and its even sadder that I am more excited for said match than I am most of the main card. Obviously Hookhausen wins.
- The TBS Title match is random. I think Cargill is a great attraction they've developed and I like Anna Jay enough, but there is no story here and a title change is impossible. Its just filler
- The Death Triangle Vs. House of Black SHOULD be AEW's version of The Shield Vs. The Wyatt Family. As is, AEW has so many stables and groups, that this thing just got lost in the shuffle. What's even the story? One dark and spooky group doesn't like the other? OK. The match itself could actually be a bit of a sleeper hit, but they could have made this a top attraction and instead, it just feels like filler. House of Black is afforded the most protection of the two groups, so they will likely win.
- For the Owen Hart tourney matches, the finals for the men will most likely be Cole Vs. Joe which is...fine, I guess. Personally, I don't care about Joe all that much anymore. Cole should win.
- For the Women's Brackets, I can tell you the Finals will suck because they are doing Britt Vs. Toni in the Semifinals on Wednesday. The comparison I will make is that King of the Ring tourney where Jericho Vs. Angle was in the first round. Once that happened, the rest of the tourney was fucked. Well here, Britt and Toni are the two top girls and that would be the ideal finals. Since that's not what's happening, you create a lackluster finals where either the star talent obviously wins, or it'll be stupid if she doesn't. I mean if Ruby or Statlander beat Britt or Storm, I'll roll my eyes.
- 3 Way Tag Title Match will be a pinball match where all six guys just bounce around. I guess its neat having powerhouses like Lee, Hobbs, and Luchasaurus in there to keep it from being a complete flippy floppy match, but its going to be mindless action from bell to bell. Champs retain methinks.
- Thunder Rosa Vs. Serena Deeb for the Women's Title is another one that feels like it should be a really good match but outside of the promo on this week's Dynamite, it has virtually no story. I like Deeb and I felt she was underrated during her main run in WWE, so hopefully she gets to shine here, but I don't think there will be a title change or anything. Champ retains.
- Hardys Vs. Bucks...ok, these two teams had an awesome Ladder Match in ROH on the WrestleMania weekend where they made their return at Mania. It was a hell of a two night showing for the Hardys, but that was a few years ago, and Jeff looks downright awful now. Honestly, it looks like the hellacious bumps finally caught up with him. Because of that, I don't think we'll be getting the all time classic that this is meant to be. Bucks will likely do most of the work and hopefully get the win, but I don't expect much here.
- Jericho Appreciation Society Vs. Blackpool Combat Club in Anarchy in the Arena Match...whatever that is. So I'm confused. Are Kingston, Santana, and Ortiz with BCC now or are they merely teaming up to take down a mutual enemy? That wasn't clear to me. Anyway, this will be the wild free for all match on the show and will likely be fun given who is involved, but again, the build up hasn't grabbed me.
- MJF Vs. Wardlow is not official yet, but come on, we know its going to happen. This has far and away been the best feud in AEW heading into this show. Wardlow is honestly the hottest face in the company right now. I say he wins and then get booked on the path to getting a belt sooner than later.
- Punk Vs. Hangman for the title feels like a main event done out of obligation. Punk is a star they want to use for the card and Hangman has nobody else lined up to face him so....here it is! The match will probably turn out well but I am nowhere near as excited as I should be for a main event.
And it is also worth noting that a ton of significant names are left off the card, including Darby, Sting, Sammy, Scorpio, FTR, reDRagon, and either Britt or Toni. I'm not arguing that everybody needs to be on every PPV, but it seems weird that FTR and reDRagon got left out while Team Taz and the Swerve/Lee team are in the title match. It seems weird they are doing a Hardys/Bucks match at this stage, when I'd honestly rather see The Bucks go up against Sting and Darby. It seems weird that either Britt or Toni will get left off the card while Anna Jay and either Statlander or, God help me, Ruby Soho got on.
I think part of the issue is that during the build up to this show, we had the ROH purchase and the NJPW joint show announcement. This saw an influx of new titles and talents being crammed into the show, derailing the direction for this event, and making everything kind of a mess.