People keep talking about A&H like it's some different country where the board culture is completely different from the rest of the site and I don't see it.
If you post on A&H there's no magic barrier that makes you not post on the rest of the site. A&H posters have a Kiwi Farms account.
-
Anyway, my rant on the issue:
Forums are first content, second discussion. You post something a lolcow did/ something about a tv series you saw... well probably a vtuber/something about a news article you read. Or you comment about someone posted on it. Yeah you also talk and it's a big part, but it's still the second thing you do. 'Here's a funny video, image, post, article, what do you think'. That's what forums are.
And debate is not a thing on forums. Debate is a formal discussion. Casual discussions are 'discussions', 'small talk' or 'arguments'. The fact we use debate nowadays to refer to anything from forum shitposting to youtubers screaming at each other is worse than 'literal' and 'phobic'.
Don't debate things on forums, don't try to go for 'a higher standard of discussion', don't try to go 'we must represent every opinion so there's diversity of thought'.
Encourage content you'd like to see.
-
That seems like the core issue, cause well I can't quote null due to the bug but he says:
@Null said "Autism Thunderdome has no standard. There is no way for a person to help me moderate it because there are, effectively, no rules. I can't help set up these guidelines because I don't like talking about politics. I don't want to moderate political discussion. I don't want to deal with people sperging out about abortion and circumcision. I don't care, because I believe I am completely powerless to effectuate political change, so there is no reason to waste breath on it. Therefore, I cannot run a board about politics."
so it's like he doesn't know what content he'd prefer to see on A&H and that fucks up any moderation he tries to implement. Or rather he doesn't like any political content because he thinks he's helpless and so doesn't want to think about it.
And most A&H people like the content presumable so they'd just want more of the same.
And anyone else want to turn it into something else which wouldn't be the right way to go either.