Can you tell me all about their bad decisions and incompetency? I have to deal with 3 Scuttles that are way more passive aggressive than the one in this thread.
As a Nijifag I can provide some examples:
- Failure to deal with the internal drama that caused the graduation of Meiro and long hiatus of Roa. I'm a bit sympathetic in this regard because as information has come out it seems like Meiro really was to blame and that it would be a difficult situation to handle, but still, it is a failure.
- Generally hands-off approach to foreign branches, reaching to the point of neglect. Anycolor prior to NijiEN seems to have had the idea that it is best to just hire some locals to run each foreign branch and then let them do their thing. Kinda worked in ID where the management was seemingly very well liked and respected by the vtubers, but failed dramatically in KR where they let internal drama in that branch fester for ages and failed to put in the effort to promote their livers. EN is the first foreign branch that hand hands-on management from Japan, and I think it's telling that after EN's success they basically canned ID and KR as separate branches and folded their management under Japan as well.
- Some bad merchandising decisions. Generally I'd say Anycolor was better at merchandising their vtubers than Cover, at least early on, but they've made some calls that have ticked fans off such as making changes to expected merchandise and whatnot. Thinking recently of the Hajiki stuff.
- Lack of promoting less popular livers. I should say here that I think this problem is
very exaggerated by some people here, because they do actually promote less popular livers fairly often, like through concerts or official collabs. Think of Onomachi Haruka being a part of Koshien last year, their biggest yearly event. I do think they could definitely do more, however.
Overall I'd agree with the assessment that Anycolor has their share of fuckups, just as Cover has. I think Cover has been more effective when it comes to promotion and business decisions, though the gap there has closed in 2022. I think both agencies have improved - people here tend to forget that Cover at one point literally had to apologize for their management being so incompetent that they didn't even secure streaming rights for games.
Scuttle probably overreacts to criticism (which is mostly just bait at this point) of Anycolor, but given that the Holofags here drop essays defending their company routinely and get triggered almost weekly by the Welsh antichrist, I don't think there's any real difference. Tribalists tend to stick by their sides to hell and back.