Crime Somerton Man identified as Melbourne electrical engineer, researcher says

3 hours ago
A black and white image of a deceased man

A man dubbed the "Somerton Man" was found dead on an Adelaide beach in 1948.(Supplied)

A researcher in the case of the Somerton Man says he has solved the decades-old mystery, identifying the figure as a Melbourne-born electrical engineer.

Key points:​

  • The mystery Somerton Man has been identified as Melbourne-born electrical engineer
  • Researcher Derek Abbott spent decades researching the case
  • The mystery started in 1948 when a body was found lying on Somerton beach in Adelaide

Adelaide University researcher Derek Abbott believes the unknown man found slumped and lifeless at Adelaide's Somerton Beach on December 1, 1948, was Carl "Charles" Webb, a 43-year-old engineer and instrument maker.

The case has long baffled detectives and amateur sleuths, and is regarded as one of Australia's most enduring mysteries because of strange clues linked to it, including a suspected code and a book of Persian poems.

While the mystery man's remains were exhumed last year by SA Police, Professor Abbott has in the meantime persisted with his own independent efforts to crack the case.

He said after using hairs from a plaster bust of the man to gather DNA evidence, researchers in Australia and America had further narrowed the search "to build out a family tree containing over 4,000 people".
Somerton Man image

A post-autopsy reconstruction of the Somerton Man.(Image: Daniel Voshart)
Working in conjunction with US investigator Colleen Fitzpatrick, Professor Abbott said that, in March this year, suspicions fell on Webb, who was born in 1905 but later identified "as a person with no death record".

Professor Abbott, who last week spoke to the ABC about his work, added "the final pieces of DNA proof came into place" on Saturday, "triangulating to Charles Webb".

Professor Abbott said that Webb was born in Footscray on November 16 in 1905 to Richard August Webb (1866 - 1939) and Eliza Amelia Morris Grace (1871 - 1946).

He said their investigations had also found a link to the name "T. Keane" which was printed on the Somerton Man's tie.

"It turns out that Carl Webb has a brother-in-law called Thomas Kean, who lived just 20 minutes drive away from him in Victoria.

"So it's not it's not out of the question that these items of clothing he had with T. Keane on them were just hand me downs from his brother-in-law."
Professor Abbott also said there was a potential explanation as to why the Melbourne resident was in Adelaide.
"We can't say for sure, but we can speculate.

"We have evidence that he had separated from his wife, and that she had moved to South Australia, so possibly, he had come to track her down."
University of Adelaide's Professor Derek Abbott.

University of Adelaide's Professor Derek Abbott says he has solved the decades-old mystery.(ABC News: Sarah Mullins)

Relatives alive​

Professor Abbott said the team had used popular genealogical DNA databases, like Ancestry.com, to find Mr Webb's distant relatives.

"The first cousin we found was on his paternal side and the second one we found was on the maternal side," he said.

"So, it's a triangulation from two different, totally distant parts of the tree, so that's very convincing."

He said he had tracked down and spoken to Mr Webb's living relatives.
"I have spoken to them, except they're all of a generation well below him and so none of them knew him and have no photos in their old family albums or in their garden sheds, unfortunately.

"I'm hoping, as his name gets out there, there will be somebody that will have an old photo album in a garden shed somewhere."

He added that there was sufficient DNA evidence to "definitively" disprove any links with his wife Rachel Egan, whose father — ballet dancer Robin Thomson — was believed to have potentially been a descendant of the Somerton Man.

"The fact he (Thomson) has a rare dental and ear condition matching the Somerton Man appears to be an extraordinary coincidence."

Search continues​

Professor Abbott said after more than a decade on the case, the discovery felt like summitting a mountain.

"It kind of feels like climbing Mount Everest, and having that mixture of elation that you're at the top, but also tiredness and exhaustion," he said.
However, he said his work was not over.

"Now there's the historical work of actually digging further and finding out about the man's life and his circumstances and what might have exactly led to this particular situation.
"So there's still work to do."

SA Police have been contacted for comment.

 
He said their investigations had also found a link to the name "T. Keane" which was printed on the Somerton Man's tie.

"It turns out that Carl Webb has a brother-in-law called Thomas Kean, who lived just 20 minutes drive away from him in Victoria.

"So it's not it's not out of the question that these items of clothing he had with T. Keane on them were just hand me downs from his brother-in-law."

Seems like something an investigator could have followed up on without waiting 80 years.
 
I wonder if Abbot was disappointed to find out his wife wasn't a relation.

I also wonder if Jestyn was telling the truth about not knowing the Somerton Man. A lot of weird coincidences and odd details in this case. Seems like there's probably a few questions that are impossible to answer at this point.
 
Seems like something an investigator could have followed up on without waiting 80 years.
How could they have followed up on it? Thomas Keane lived in another state (Victoria). I don’t think investigators had the resources 80 years ago to personally follow up with everyone with the surname “Keane” in Australia, especially since they suspected the man was foreign.

The Abbott guy is kind of fascinating. There’s a podcast series about him although I forget the name. He actually met his wife in the course of investigating her potential connection to the Somerton man and they have several children together. I also wonder if he’s disappointed.
 
How could they have followed up on it? Thomas Keane lived in another state (Victoria). I don’t think investigators had the resources 80 years ago to personally follow up with everyone with the surname “Keane” in Australia, especially since they suspected the man was foreign.
At some point in the last 80 years it should have been possible to put out the information and see if anybody knew/was a man named Keane who may know the victim. You could eliminate the women because the name was written on a neck tie.
 
At some point in the last 80 years it should have been possible to put out the information and see if anybody knew/was a man named Keane who may know the victim. You could eliminate the women because the name was written on a neck tie.

The police assumed that because he was wearing clothes with Keane on them, that Keane was the name of the missing man. They looked extensively for any missing people with that name. Another assumption was that the clothes were stolen or from a charity shop, but nothing turned up on those fronts.

It's easy in retrospect to say that he was wearing his brother in law's clothes (if he was) but who the hell suspects that? And for whatever reason the brother in law didn't come forward even though the case has been famous for decades. Maybe Keane himself died soon afterwards. Maybe there was family estrangement going on and he didn't know his brother in law was dead.

People were also a lot harder to track down by surname in 1949. None of the digital records we have today, heavy postwar immigration and population movement, etc.

I think you must be unfamiliar with the case and how much time and effort has gone into solving it over the years.



I actually started thinking about her as soon as I heard about this! Cold War mysteries are my favorite, even if it turns out (as it might in this case) that they're unrelated to Cold War issues.
 
I saw where they're saying the codes he had in his poetry book were the starting letters of horses from races. He liked to place bets and they were supposedly listed according to gate position.
It wasn't just the code, it was the books connection to others.

I'm not disputing the DNA evidence, but all of this is far too convenient.
 
It wasn't just the code, it was the books connection to others.

I'm not disputing the DNA evidence, but all of this is far too convenient.
They're handwaving that away as the guy liked poetry and sometimes wrote his own, hence the torn page.
I'm with you, it fits a little too neatly for my tastes. just passing along what I've seen in statements.
 
They're handwaving that away as the guy liked poetry and sometimes wrote his own, hence the torn page.
I'm with you, it fits a little too neatly for my tastes. just passing along what I've seen in statements.
It's just so...neat and tidy.
Not that they WOULD tell people he was a spy though, which is fine, understandable, but they would have been better off leaving it as a mystery, instead of this George Glass style backstory.
 
The idea of him being a spy was always just the fanciful explanation that only works because we are missing a few pieces of information. I always thought the explanation would be very simple, and the coolest aspect of the story is that a few diligent people finally found those missing pieces. It's so cool, and I'm glad there's finally closure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pee Cola
It's said that he died of Digitalis and Ouabain poisoning. That is very odd, especially for that time period. I doubt many people, except those in the medical field, were aware of the toxicity of digitalis at that time. Even more so for ouabain which was never widely used and had very specific medical indications, but, again, would likely be known to people in medicine. Given the unusual knowledge needed to use these poisonous substances whose only use was in medicine, the most likely culprit is Jessica Thomson. During her time as a nurse she likely would have been aware of those two medicines, and that would be the right time period where ouabain was used before being displaced by medicines with safer therapeutic indices. She also lied to the police about knowing Charles Webb. Her daughter later told the police that her mother told her she did know the man, and he was known to people far above the police, which is why she lied. Of course, Jessica Thomson has been dead for nearly 15 years now. So, overall, it doesn't really matter if she did do it.

The other interesting thing is that a Salvation Army chaplain presided over the burial of Charles Webb. The chaplain's name? Em Webb. I don't know how common the last name "Webb" is in Australia, but it seems like a strange coincidence.
 
I still wanna know what the connection between him and the woman who spoke fluent Russian but refused to talk about him, even with her own children was. That was pretty fucking weird.
 
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: make_it_so
Back