- Joined
- Oct 1, 2022
This has probably already been brought up but did the Air Nation genocide even really happen?
How could you possibly genocide a global race of nomadic peoples?
Okay so the people in the air temples are largely pacifists but that doesn't mean that they would just sit down and die.
Apparently that's what they did. Eliminating an entire race only happens when the last pureblood dies out over a century latter.
But don't let real life get in the way of this overrated cartoon.
A lot of the expanded material explains this stuff: Sozin attacked the air temples first during the comet. While the air benders did put up a fight, they were simply no match for the power and the numbers of the Fire Nation soldiers. A lot of them were wiped out in the temple attacks. Some did survive, but the Fire Nation began hunting them down and setting up traps to lure them into. Which ended up killing off a lot of the surviving air benders.Not good enough for me. They can literally just fly away. Fire Nation didn't even have blimps till 100 years later.
If they were talking about a cultural genocide wherein their way of life has died out then I could understand it but the lack of airbenders elsewhere ATLA goes to show that they went with the ethnocide angle
As far as how the Fire Nation reached the temples without airships: it was a misconception that the temples could only be reached by flight. While difficult to do, all the temples had pathways that could be reached by foot. During that one episode with the Northern Air Temples, we see the Fire Nation troops doing just that.
There possibly were air benders that survived the genocide, but they all likely decided to go into hiding and blend into places like the Earth Kingdom or Fire Nation. The reason where there were no more air benders by the time Aang came out of the ice berg is because they lost access to their bending. The Kyoshi novels went over that air benders could sometimes lose their air bending when they abandoned their spiritual teachings.
It is likely that there were people that were descended from air benders that survived the genocide but weren't benders themselves because of this. Many fans have theorized that Ty Lee was the descendant of an air bender given that her facial features almost perfectly matches Aang's and all the other Fire Nation characters have completely different features that she doesn't have.