Horrorcow Hollie Dance / Lisa Pittaway / Ella Carter / Archie Battersbee / Lauren Summers/ Dignity For All / Archie's Army / Spread The Purple Wave - The Mama Nails of Essex, Her Whiteknights, and Her A-Logs

Was there no evidence about a cord or ligature or anything at the scene or scissors or a knife to cut him down? Didn’t Ms.Dance originally say she cut him down and he fell several feet?
Ms Dance gave several differing accounts of how she found him. I seem to recall that the one where she said she cut him down was the first account she gave (and I apologise if I am wrong, and it wasn't).

And thanks @False Witness for your updates of the inquest, invaluable additions.
 
Ms Dance gave several differing accounts of how she found him. I seem to recall that the one where she said she cut him down was the first account she gave (and I apologise if I am wrong, and it wasn't).

And thanks @False Witness for your updates of the inquest, invaluable additions.
The media pretty much consistently reported he was found with a ligature around his neck.
 
The media pretty much consistently reported he was found with a ligature around his neck.

The Press Association in the UK abide by the Samaritans reporting guidelines on suicide for prevention of copycat attempts and fatalities.

 
Last edited:

Unsurprisingly has changed her story yet again and is now claiming she believes archies death was an accident and that he accidentally fell from the stair bannister and causing the injury that killed him. Gee, what happened to the tiktok challenge gone wrong. Now he accidentally fell after accidentally putting himself in a position to fall, after accidentally tying a noose around his neck. Thats quite the series of accidents going on in that house
 
Here's the Daily Mail version with archive
Just a bonus from the article of a lovely family
scary Family.png
 
1675830910436.png
1675832265948.png

1675832281557.png
1675830477297.png

1675832317983.png
1675830492138.png


Inquest Day 1 Bullet Points:
  • Hollie's Testimony
    • Hollie states Archie was bullied at school.
    • He was "taken out" of main stream education.
      • She fails to state that his behavior was so awful that he was excluded and it took 2 years to find a district to take him.
    • She has him in MMA and gymnastics every day.
    • She knew he was on Tiktok and Whatsapp while underage.
    • She states he wasn't down he was just bored.
    • She states that he was told he did not have what it takes to be professional.
      • She then states he proved them wrong by winning a gold medal.
        • Thing is she also admits his first match wasn't until the week after he hung himself.
    • She states the EMS should have drove an him to another hospital an hour away instead of to one 5 minutes away.
  • Investigators states that he was making suicidal comments on Whatsapp and messages in the week before his death.
    • Hollie denies seeing any of this.
  • There is hints that they thought he was self harming or had self harmed.
    • Hollie states he would strip his clothes off when he got home so she would have seen it.
  • Hollie's story about finding him has changed again.
    • The bunny in bag exists, but she instead of getting mad talked about going to the movies.
    • When requestioned her story changed again.
      • "I think he climbed on the bannister and probably fell, causing serious injury to his neck, resulting in unconsciousness."
  • She has backtracked on her it was a Tiktok challenge thing and now states she does not beleive so.
    • In the same breath she states the police know he was on TikTok and that he was on it the day before.
      • It has already been confirmed by police he was not looking up any challenges.
  • She states that Archie was against anything loud or bullying.
    • Videos in the OP will prove this wrong with him being into gang shit and stuff as well as being quite loud.
  • Hollie states when she found Archie she ran outside screaming for help instead of calling 999.
    • She states she then went inside and called 999.
      • Neighbors and EMS reports conflict this it was NOT Hollie who called.
  • Neighbor's report is he heard screaming found Hollie outside.
    • Hollie never started CPR or called EMS.
      • Neighbor started CPR and called EMS.
        • He says it took 4 mins for EMS to arrive, against Hollie's stories of it taking much longer.
  • Paramedic Testimony
    • Archie had no spontaneous breathing even in response to CPR.
      • They got a brief return to circulation, but it immediately went away and never returned.
    • Hollie complained about lack of neck brace.
      • EMS stated that he was already in a good position and it would involve more movement and risk of injury to put a neck brace on him.
    • Hollie's complaint about him going to Southend was brought up again.
      • EMS states that with Archie being in cardiac arrest the best decision was to get him to a hospital ASAP and that a hospital an hour away was not even in their protocols.
        • Hollie wanted them to drive an hour with a child in cardiac arrest instead of 5 minutes away.
    • EMS stated that when Tom arrived a verbal argument began between him and the police.
      • ""She added that at one point, a brother of Archie had arrived at the scene and “there was a loud, verbal exchange with the police” before Archie was taken to hospital."
    • Archie had a "pulseless electrical rhythm."
      • This is an unshockable cardiac arrest.
        • This is probably the polite way to say Archie was already dead.
    • Hollie never called Paul to let him know what happened.
      • He found out when Archie was unreachable for a planned phone call.
        • Finally he got through to Hollie who told him Archie was "up the hospital."
Archive of one of many articles on inquest.
Echo Live Blog Archive for Day 1.
 
"Hollie never called Paul to let him know what happened.
He found out when Archie was unreachable for a planned phone call.
Finally he got through to Hollie who told him Archie was "up the hospital.""


All the adults in this story are terrible but Jesus Christ. What a self absorbed bint. Imagine this is how you find out your pre-teen killed himself.
 
Still no mention of a ligature anywhere? Is that something they would just leave out? I find it strange that they haven’t ran through how he was lying on the floor, or that there was a ligature on him or nearby etc?
I don't think that there's anything sinister about the necking details being omitted from the reports.

In post #8,765 you'll see that @Screwed linked to The Samaritans press guidelines for the reporting of suicides and, having read them, I can understand why the details of the (assumed) suicide have been omitted from the reports.

It appears that the majority of the UK press follow these guidelines and only refer to the suicide method obliquely e.g. 'found with a ligature around his head' rather than 'found with a noose around his neck, swinging from the bannisters like a human pendulum'

I'm sure the full details will be in the court documents and final reports and, assuming a copy can be obtained, will appear here
 
Archie’s Inquest - Day 2

Coroner enters the court​

I’ll endeavour to post the blow-by-blow updates as they happen.

I’ll keep adding to the posts but the time limits on editing a post will mean that the updates will be split over multiple posts.


Director of Southend Hospital details how Archie arrived at the hospital

Coroner Brookes is reading a statement to the court from Dr Claire Willis, associate medical director of the Mid and South Essex Hospitals Trust, based in Southend. In the statement, she is detailing how Archie was received into Southend Hospital by the ambulance staff.

She said that the A&E department received a pre-alert from the ambulance saying a 12-year-old boy was being brought to them in cardiac arrest. Dr Willis said Archie was given a “rapid systematic examination of his airway”, which was to identify “any potential life-threatening problems”.

Dr Willis said Archie had a temperature of 39.5C and his pupils were “large and not reacting to light”, and it was indicated Archie was in a “deeply unconscious state”.


Dr Willis says that after medical examinations it was determined he needed to be moved to a different hospital

Dr Willis continued, saying that it was determined Archie was “critically unwell” and had a “build-up of acid in the blood” which is “commonly seen” for people in cardiac arrest, which is treated by oxygenation, ventilation and fluid resuscitation.

Dr Willis said at 5.30pm, more information was obtained from Archie’s parents, and it was determined Archie would need a tertiary unit for further ongoing care, leading to his transfer to London later that day.


Doctor responds to family's concerns Archie shouldn't have gone to Southend Hospital

Dr Willis has responded to concerns from Archie’s family about him being taken to Southend Hospital first before the Royal London Hospital hours later.

She said: “As Archie was in cardiac arrest it would be expected for the ambulance service to convey him to the nearest emergency department for assessment and treatment.”

Dr Willis said it was common for those in cardiac arrest to re-enter spontaneous recirculation but it would then be followed by a return to cardiac arrest quickly. She also addressed concerns from the family about the way Archie was handled by the ambulance teams, but she said this would have had no bearing on the “devastating brain injury” that he had already received before his mother discovered him.
 
Last edited:
Doctors got no response from Archie during tests and determined it was 'not a survivable injury'

Dr Malik Ramadhan, a medical director of the Barts Health NHS Trust, is now giving evidence to the court. Dr Ramadhan was not a treating clinician of Archie’s, but is giving an overview of his care on behalf of the Royal London Hospital.

Dr Ramadhan said tests were carried out including electrical scans of Archie’s brain to see if they could get any response.

He said: “It showed he had no electrical activity. Music was played to see if there was any response to stimulation, with his mother with him. There was no response to any outside stimulation.

“There was no coughing or breathing when on the ventilator. This was not a survivable injury and there was a process to conclude if that was the case or not, and at the end of that process we withdrew the care and he died in August."

Coroner Brookes confirmed to the court that the direction to withdraw care was made by the High Court. A medical cause of death was recorded as a catastrophic hypoxic-ischemic brain injury.

Dr Ramadhan confirmed he believed that to be the most likely cause on the balance of probabilities.


Archie was on 'the brink of death' when he arrived at hospital

Dr Ramadhan said that Archie was on “the brink of death” when he arrived at Southend Hospital, and remained that way for months. He detailed how a hypoxic brain injury like Archie’s meant the entire brain was affected - making surgery difficult.

He said: “The conclusion was - and the literature would support this - that surgery would not be appropriate.”

When asked by the coroner if surgery would have made Archie worse, Dr Ramadhan said there would only be “therapeutic” benefit and that “it would make onward care very problematic".


Archie was 'kept alive by completely artificial means' for four months

When asked to give his opinion on Archie’s condition, Dr Ramadhan said: “Archie was on the brink of death when he was in Southend and remained on the brink of death for the next four months and was kept alive by completely artificial means.”

He added that the condition was not survivable.


Family grateful for doctors' care despite legal disagreements

Jonathan Dingle, representing Archie’s family, has asked a few questions to Dr Ramadhan, but stated that the family were very grateful for all the care and compassion shown to Archie during his time with them, “even if they disagreed in the courts” and asked for it to be passed onto his team.

Dr Ramadhan said he would, and offered his “sincere condolences” to the family.

The court has now broken for ten minutes with the doctor’s evidence now concluded.
 
Last edited:
Archie's half-brother says he was 'never aware' of any online challenges he would do

Tom Summers, the older half-brother of Archie Battersbee, has had a statement read out in court. He said he and Archie were very close and he got on well with his older friends. He said until concerns were raised by his mother about Archie’s mindset, it “hadn’t even entered his mind” as he always thought his brother was very happy.

He said: “I was never aware of any sinister online challenges that Archie was doing, he never mentioned it to me, but I am not on TikTok, so I’m not able to comment on anything he followed or posted.

“I don’t believe that Archie was suicidal or that the incident was intentional in any way. He never said anything to me that caused me concern for his emotional well-being.”

Tom added his brother was “focused” on training for his upcoming MMA fight before he was hospitalised.


More family members say they didn't see Archie in low moods

Lauren Battersbee, another relative of Archie’s, also had a statement read out to the court.

She said Archie was “funny, sporty and a joker”. She said despite the events of April last year, she “still cannot recall any sense of Archie being in a low mood or any unusual behaviour”.


Archie's headteacher says his 'gut reaction' is that Archie was not trying to take his own life

Matthew Badcock, head of Earls Hall Primary School in Westcliff where Archie went, said in his statement that he truly believed the youngster would not try to harm himself.

He said: “My gut reaction is that Archie was not trying to kill himself. He adored his mum and I can’t believe he would do anything like that to upset her.”


Essex Police examined Archie's electronic devices but were not allowed to look at texts

All written statements have now been read, and we’re onto evidence from Essex Police.

Detective Sergeant Tiffany Gore is now in the witness box. She shared how when she attended the scene, she seized various devices including Archie’s phone, an Apple laptop and an Xbox games console.

She said under usual circumstances the police would not examine seized devices belonging to children unless it was for a coroner or for a criminal investigation. However, in late April, DS Gore said Hollie Dance had requested them to examine parts of Archie’s phone as she feared he had been taking part in an online challenge.

DS Gore said written authority permission was given by Ms Dance, but in a bid to protect Archie’s privacy - as he was still being treated in hospital at the time - she did not give permission for them to examine Archie’s text messages.
 
Last edited:
Police found it difficult to access Archie's TikTok history but never found evidence he did online challenge

DS Gore has discussed the challenges of analysing a phone - not only getting into it through the PIN code, but then also how they can analyse it online and offline. The officer said that under law, data on the phone obtained through the internet belongs to Archie, so they couldn’t take the phone off flight mode.

Regarding TikTok and the fears of Archie taking part in an online challenge, due to the lack of data being available from the TikTok app - as the “tokens” between app and phone had long expired - DS Gore said that the police “can’t say for absolute certainty” that Archie didn’t see an online challenge, or videos of suicidal thoughts, or challenges, or a game.

However, she continued: “But we can say for certainty that Archie never videoed or photographed himself to prove that he took part. He never searched the internet for any blackout or online challenges, and never accessed YouTube for challenges, and we can say with certainty that he never communicated with friends about an online blackout challenge.”


Abusive voice notes found sent to Archie claimed his mother wanted to 'abort him'

The inquest has heard how an analysis of Archie’s phone found two voice notes from the same number on April 3, including a claim that his mother wanted to abort him.

DS Gore said the two voice notes were a few seconds long, with the first saying “Oi, Archie, you know why you’re angry, because you know your mum wanted you to be an abortion” - plus another abusive message.

The sergeant also revealed that there had been a “bravado” exchange between Archie and another number on February 15 that year, where threats were made to him. However. DS Gore said there was no evidence to suggest these threats were carried out.
 
Last edited:
Interesting that the loving mother wouldn't give permission for Archie's text messages to be examined, but leaned straight into the online challenge narrative from the start.
What could a 12 year old possibly have to hide?
Angry messages from Mummy?
Probably at least things she knew about but doesn't want to come out. Maybe nothing bad, not even from her, but maybe things that would paint her in a less flattering light.
 
Back