UN Farmers rally over first lady’s comments on banning dog meat - I thought they might have stopped eating dogs after seeing the number of pet dogs on the streets over there

1682480891991.png

SEOUL, South Korea (AP) — Dozens of dog farmers in South Korea rallied Tuesday to criticize the country’s first lady over her reported comments that support a possible ban on dog meat consumption.

Eating dog is a centuries-old Korean practice. But there have been growing calls for outlawing it in South Korea as animal rights campaigns have influenced public perception and eating dog meat has fallen out of favor with most younger people.

In late 2021, a government-civilian committee was launched to reach a social consensus on ending dog meat consumption, but no breakthrough has been reported yet. Farmers demand authorities present more concrete compensation steps or allow them to maintain their businesses for about 15-20 years until older people, who are the main source of demand for the meat, die.

About 50 dog farmers gathered Tuesday near the office of President Yoon Suk Yeol to protest remarks made by his wife, Kim Keon Hee, during a private luncheon with animal rights activists earlier in April.

Some local media outlets reported Kim told the activists that she would effort an end to dog meat consumption for the duration of Yoon’s term, which ends in 2027. Dog farmers argued Kim isn’t entitled to make such a policy promise because she isn’t a government official. They also accused her of undermining their rights to their livelihoods and happiness.

Yoon’s office declined to confirm the contents of Kim’s conversation with the activists because their luncheon was organized as a closed-door meeting.

Attendee Jo Hee Kyung, who heads the Korean Animal Welfare Association, said Kim’s comments reported in the media were largely taken out of context. Jo said Kim did not discuss policies but rather expressed her personal hopes for the end of dog meat consumption during an informal meeting meant to cheer up animal rights activists. Jo said Kim told them that TV programs reporting animal abuses made her heart ache. She said they felt grateful to Kim for sharing her views backing a potential ban.

Kim and Yoon are known as pet lovers. They raise six dogs and five cats. Jo said Kim had long held interests in animal rights movements even before Yoon became president in 2022.

But Ju Yeongbong, an official at an association of dog farmers, said he believes that animals rights activists were trying to cover up Kim’s comments.

During the rally, farmers pumped their fists and chanted slogans demanding Kim withdraw her reported comments and the government formulate steps to support the farmers. “Guarantee our livelihoods! Guarantee!” they shouted.

They said they later visited a police station to file complaints against Kim for allegedly hurting their rights to maintain livelihoods, seek happiness and select jobs.

Chae IlTaek, an activist at the Korean Animal Welfare Association, called dog meat consumption “an anachronistic business” that should have been shut down.

About 1 million dogs are slaughtered for food annually in South Korea, a decrease from more than 3 million annually about 10-20 years ago, according to Ju.

Dog meat is neither legally protected nor explicitly banned in South Korea. During election campaigning, Yoon said he personally opposed dog meat consumption but formulating a policy on outlawing it would require a public consensus.

https://apnews.com/article/south-korea-dog-meat-farmers-c0f7cc77c9ece49d38b5ef30f1d6441d (Archive)
 
Dog consumption has been steadily dropping in recent years, more and more people actively find it disgusting/ unethical/ unclean. I tried it once myself back in 2010 and was unimpressed (the taste is overly greasy but with stringy texture ) and it is overpriced compared to livestock meat.

The strangest thing to me, is that despite canine consumption being a centuries old tradition in Korea, dogs are not categorized as livestock. So that there is no requirements for hygiene or care for the farmed dogs. An idiot, like me, might see this as a grand opportunity for the dog meat industry to set their own standards of cleanliness and quality to help quell fears of potential consumers. But they have done nothing of the sort. The industry has chosen to end dog meat consumption themselves by the choices they have made.
 
On one hand its just killing another animal for meat, if you don't like it blame mother nature.
On the other hand dogs were bred for higher emotional attachment and interaction so it just does strike me as wrong.
On the other hand (I have 3 now) huge numbers of dogs are abandoned all the time and suffer similar fates.

Not sure about this one but personally I would prefer the usual, beef, pork, chicken and lamb.
 
How could you even think about eating a dog?

What kind of human looks at a dog, who is nothing but love and loyalty, and think...yum!

I stand by my opinion that Asian's are not human but rather some Denisovan off shoot race.
My guess would be that it's famine food that a few people got nostalgic about, much in the way some of us might feel about the cheap ramen we ate in college, and now pass off as a cuisine. There are small pockets of Europe where you can get dog meat, but this is Asia, where a mass starvation event is pretty much guaranteed more than once a century.
 
How could you even think about eating a dog?

What kind of human looks at a dog, who is nothing but love and loyalty, and think...yum!

I stand by my opinion that Asian's are not human but rather some Denisovan off shoot race.
In their defense, the dogs they raise for meat consumption are not breeds that are kept for pets. I'm not saying it's right, just that they aren't exactly butchering Lassie.
 
just that they aren't exactly butchering Lassie
According to the super accurate facts on wikipedia, they sometimes do:

The primary dog breed raised for meat is a non-specific landrace commonly named as Nureongi (누렁이), or Hwanggu (황구).[36][37] Nureongi are not the only type of dog currently slaughtered for their meat in South Korea. In 2015, The Korea Observer reported that many different pet breeds of dog are bred to be eaten, including, for example, labradors, retrievers, and cocker spaniels, and that the dogs slaughtered for their meat often include former pets.
 
My guess would be that it's famine food that a few people got nostalgic about, much in the way some of us might feel about the cheap ramen we ate in college, and now pass off as a cuisine. There are small pockets of Europe where you can get dog meat, but this is Asia, where a mass starvation event is pretty much guaranteed more than once a century.
Yep. Same reason my mother grew up eating raccoon and possum. Nobody in her family eats either now, but they were poor af in the 60’s and deer populations weren’t recovered from the Depression yet, so a possum trap in the woods meant they’d have meat once in a while.
 
Cultural biases aside... I've always read that predator meat tastes terrible to begin with so I've never understood why people would make an industry out of it.
Alligator supposedly tastes good. Always forget to try it when I have the chance, unfortunately. Almost got to go to a place that served rattlesnake as a kid. My mom was outraged, so no rattlesnake for me.
 
Alligator supposedly tastes good. Always forget to try it when I have the chance, unfortunately. Almost got to go to a place that served rattlesnake as a kid. My mom was outraged, so no rattlesnake for me.
Eh, alligator is pretty chewy and I think they're closer to birds than mammals* which means they should be delicious since birds often are. I guess I should have clarified that mammalian predators tend to taste awful or at least I always read that.

*Not a biologist.
 
Back