I sure as fuck didn't watch Phil's full fictional story regarding this "robbery", but at any point did someone ask why the fuck someone that had the balls to walk out of a store without paying for anything would do so with a cart full of someone else's random groceries rather than a cart full of items they picked out to sell or use themself?
This isn't even one of those made up stories that sound like it could have happened to someone else somewhere at some point.
I do like the thought of this fictional deranged person getting home and opening up Phil's bags only to realized they risked jail time for a bottle of cherry juice and a 20 lb bag of potatoes. If they existed, they'd probably come back to the store next week to shank Phil.
Ironic that he led into this story with his previous story of his wheel getting stolen (or "tire assembly" as he referred to it for some fucking reason), because both stories are about equally as plausible.