Honestly, I think you're onto something with this one.
Looking back on it, "The 2000's" cultural zeitgeist as most people on here remember it was surprisingly short, lasting from just shortly after 9/11 up until around late 2007 at the absolute most.
The global recession of 2007-2009 and the rise of Obama were big gamechangers, as were all the things that always get namedropped in the "2007 was the year the internet went to shit" meme.
2007-2013 was honestly its own little mini-cultural zeitgeist that in a way felt like a prelude to the "Woke" era of the mid-late 2010's and 2020's but also was distinct enough on its own that it doesn't really fit in with either the popular memory of "The 2000's" or "Current Year"
I could see that. Occupy Wall Street briefly spooked BlackRock and Vanguard and ultimately led to the rise of woke leftism while stuff like Kony 2012, the Zimmerman trial, and GamerGate feel like the prologue to "Current Year"
Something that is very interesting you point out is how short the Golden Age, if you will, was.
Without PLing too much, the truth to me is that it really was roughly between 2004 and 2007.
This is only 3 years. I would argue rather personal reasons for this but I have the feeling most of you would agree because your personal reasons are likely to allign with mine.
I think, I'd dare say, the period between 2000 and 2004 was rather unsettling. I think
@Save the Loli talked about this before? Or was it
@Dom Cruise (PBUH)?. The 90s were pretty much alive between 2000 and 2004, but they were stale and tired and the 90s mindset and aesthetics was plain ridiculous after 911 and everybody was kind of waiting, wondering what was in store for them.
The Simpsons lost its shine during that time and everybody noticed how abruptly it happened, but, at the time, no one was entirely sure what has changed as the episodes were mostly indistinguishable from the previous ones, even funny and meme-worthy at times, just strangely soulless.
South Park lost
a lot of its edge around that time (Contrary to the SP Griefing Thread consensus that they've been 'tamed' relatively recently) and Family Guy killed the sort of 90s 'subversive' spirit that can be described as benign now and set the tone of things to come.
For instance, something like
Malcolm in the Middle will never, ever, happen again in our lifetimes.
In that period there was a nascent subculture and aesthetic that is often called the Matrix aesthetic since that film is thought to condense the subculture, the aesthetic and the period: Basically thinly veiled BDSM aesthetics with a technobabble coat of paint and brain-melting EDM music. This all died abruptly around the time of the Second Gulf War to be replaced to corny, cookie-cuter pop to be increasingly niggerified in the following years.
Now 2005 to 2007 is a period that, I've mentioned in another thread, it's really epitomized by Classic Christory.
Chris was always at his best when interacting with the world outside 14 Branchland Court, and the Pre-ED Christory will always be my favourite because of how perfectly, in a rather bizarre way, encapsulates that era. The Bush years reflect on Chris in a magical way, and Chris wanders around in that world being a misfit yet an unquestionable part of it. The world that involves spending an afternoon in a mall where pretty girls trolled around for shitty, slutty clothes and nerds wandered around the shelves of comic book stores discussing autistic stuff. The world where there were places where children played Pokemon and not-so-children played D&D and it was actually fun and even Chris-chan himself would have been considered mostly harmless as opposed to the current fetish-rotten, horrid troons that have infested such spaces. The world that was populated by characters like the odd yet lovable Megan Schroeder and her shitty family, the goofy Lucas White and Daniel Mimms, the greedy jew Michael Snyder, the plain, salt-of-the-earth girl next door Sarah Hammer and her failed stage magician boyfriend Wes Iseli, redneck hispanic Josh Martinez and nerd-jock Adam Stackhouse, the not-so-top-of-te-totem-pole-but-neither-too-nerdy gal-pals, especially Tiffany Gowen whose persona Chris misconstructed as a fellow misfit. The world in which conservatives like Bob Chandler and the Schroeders coexisted with rabid, deranged liberals like Cole Smithey and more garden-variety liberals (lolbertarians of the Trey Parker and Matt Stone variety as it was the predominant ideology of nerds at the time) like Lucas and Mimms. The world in which fucking Mary Lee Walsh (PBUH) existed.
This is a world that existed and I have experienced, and, alas, it doesn't exist anymore. I like this part of Christory for the same reason I like the early seasons of South Park, because it captures the essence of the 00s in a way that makes me feel at home.
And, when filtered by Chris warped perception, you get something like it's out of a movie Kevin Smith did while on crack. You get frankly amazing characters like MLW the witch, who might or might not be actually a deranged impersonator known as Slaweel Ryam, Allison Amber (?), Merried Seinor Comic (Kirby), ScotPalazzo, the B-Manajerk, the Turdi-Jerk, Count Graduon and the army of Jerkops.
This was really a rather optimistic period and the last time I remember most people being actually happy rather than just trying to get by. I might have not liked many things back then but God, would I go back.
2007 was not abrupt. Nothing went to shit overnight and everybody here that is trying to pinpoint when did everything exactly went to shit is being autistic as fuck.
2007 was a good year, and so was 2008. It was all very gradual. The only thing that was abrupt is that suddenly a lot of stuff stopped being the same, a lot of stuff suddenly became as stale, wasted and used and lame as all these 90s things were between 2000 and 2004, with the difference being that by 2004 a zeitgeist of 10 to 12 years was coming to an end while by 2007 we were apparently exhausted of a state of things that only lasted
3 fucking years.
And I remember that, even at the time, I was bewildered that so much stuff was happening that I was overestimating time periods and I would allocate half a year to a year for stuff that had really happened over 1 month. This is so wild that most people don't even realise that a lot of classic christory occurred in a really short timespan:
- The Megan Saga (2005 to 2007) - 2 years
- The PVCC Saga (2003 to 2005) - 2 years
- The overall Classic Chris Era (2007-2010) - 3 years
Nobody really noticed anything had changed, or, to be precise,
what had changed. We all suddenly found ourselves neck deep in shit by 2011 without really knowing what had hit us, end thus Occupy Wall Street, and thus Woke, and thus Gamergate, and thus /pol/, and thus the 2016 election, and thus the brutal woke counteroffensive.