Diseased Rowling Derangement Syndrome - "TERF/Woke Author Bad!!1"

  • 🐕 I am attempting to get the site runnning as fast as possible. If you are experiencing slow page load times, please report it.
Surfin Terf said:
At best they'll come up with a single trait that is sometimes associated with Jews like being a banker or being hook-nosed, but most of the time even that is just made up
Click to expand...

I can honestly say I never considered Snape to be remotely Jewish until some much more enlightened, kind-hearted, broad-minded Social Justice cunt suggested it. Kinda thinking that's a "you" problem, not a Rowling problem.
 
  • Agree
  • Winner
  • Like
Reactions: Aliénor, Vetinari, rusty shackleford 1 and 22 others
F-14 Tomcat said:
Holy crap, we're back to the "woke author bad!!!!" era. Honestly quite incredible.
Click to expand...
Let us not pretend that Rowling isn't still a shithead liberal that supported everything that has happened to her when it happened to others. She literally celebrated Alex Jones getting sued into oblivion but now wants to pretend that harming people over speech is a bad thing.

We don't have to defend the target to criticize the behavior of a community of psychopaths. Rowling is a classic example of somebody who fed and supported a monster until she herself became a victim of it. At the the end of the day the proper thing to do is laugh at a community of insane sycophants who couldn't handle a celebrity they worshipped saying something that they had a minor disagreement with.
 
  • Like
  • Agree
  • Informative
Reactions: Vetinari, Bitchslapper, Chug Smuckle and 16 others
Mola Ram said:
I can honestly say I never considered Snape to be remotely Jewish
Click to expand...
You didn't see the guy who played both sides in a war where one side was clearly genocidal, only ever did anything that served his own interests, he only changed sides because it started effecting him personally very nice metaphor of NIMBYism, no one likes him but he is protected by powerful friends, internalized things that happened decades ago to the point where they became part of his identity, and tried to guilt trip you into thinking he was a good guy when he eventually got what he deserved was a jew? He's either a nigger or a jew depending on your flavor of prejudice. Of course, making the guy who betrays his friends and cozies up to a genocidal dictator an actual rat is a little on the nose, but it is a children's series after all. The only thing that contradicts the comparison is that Snape is an incredibly good wizard like he's only barely one tier below dumbledore and voldy in terms of magical power. That's why he was able to play both sides.
Sinner's Sandwich said:
That crazy fat dumb fuck deserved to get sued. The amount he has to pay is way too much but that is typical Burgerland insanity.
Click to expand...
Nigger
 
Last edited:
  • Autistic
  • Dumb
  • Political Sperging
Reactions: Bunny Tracks, Risky Horse Business, luigismanslave and 11 others
Does religion even exist as such in HP? There’s fucking magic. I don’t remember mention of even constructed religions, at all. I wouldn’t be surprised if there was a vague mention of muggles at least having Sunday services, but is HP meant to be a reimagining of the real world to the extent that real world religions are even tangentially mentioned? And ofc that’s not the same thing as drawing inspiration for the magic system from existing magic/mythology etc—there could be references there I missed/don’t recall. But it feels like claiming Mario and Luigi are Christians while Bowser is a Jew, ie batshit insane.
 
  • Like
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: Cnidarian, luigismanslave, Peepeepoopoo Witch and 4 others
grenouille crétine said:
Does religion even exist as such in HP? There’s fucking magic. I don’t remember mention of even constructed religions, at all. I wouldn’t be surprised if there was a vague mention of muggles at least having Sunday services, but is HP meant to be a reimagining of the real world to the extent that real world religions are even tangentially mentioned? And ofc that’s not the same thing as drawing inspiration for the magic system from existing magic/mythology etc—there could be references there I missed/don’t recall. But it feels like claiming Mario and Luigi are Christians while Bowser is a Jew, ie batshit insane.
Click to expand...

There's a big Christmas scene in every book, and there's a Bible verse on the Potters' tombstone. That said, it seems a fairly bland and nondenominational flavor of Christianity.
 
  • Like
  • Agree
  • Informative
Reactions: gmax alcremie, Richard Cheese, Aunt Carol and 15 others
Mola Ram said:
I can honestly say I never considered Snape to be remotely Jewish until some much more enlightened, kind-hearted, broad-minded Social Justice cunt suggested it. Kinda thinking that's a "you" problem, not a Rowling problem.
Click to expand...
I fucking guarantee you if she started talking about how the Zionist occupiers should be cleansed from Palestinian Land or some shit like that they'd instantly drop the antisemitism accusations.

Edit: Quoted wrong post.
 
Last edited:
  • Agree
  • Like
  • DRINK!
Reactions: assigned Karen at birth, luigismanslave, Marvin and 11 others
There's also a minor character called Anthony Goldstein in Dumbledore's Army, he's pretty obviously coded Jewish, but he also doesn't really do anything except exist.

There is a massive amount of anti-semitism baked into English and European folklore, for ...historical reasons... so it's inevitably going to turn up references in goblins, witches etc. So 'goblins as obsessed with money' is centuries old, making them bankers is a logical inference in a modern setting, the original association of goblins with money is not JKR's fault. Blaming JKR for this shit is ridiculous.

Terry Pratchett included goblins as a sort of native american / apartheid allegory in his last few books. He already had dementia by then so they're not great, and maybe it would have worked if he'd been at full power, but one of the reasons it doesn't work for me is because it just kind of ignores the mythology around goblins because it's inconvenient. The word goblin could be switched out for a lot of things - borrowing house elf / brownies terminology would make more sense for a start, and made me wonder if that's where he got the idea from, but JKR had a monopoly on house elves by that point and obviously he wasn't ever going to call the slaves 'brownies'...
 
  • Agree
  • Informative
  • Like
Reactions: Aliénor, Richard Cheese, Aunt Carol and 12 others
Prince Vegeta said:
C of E probably
Click to expand...

Her actual beliefs may run deeper than that -- she pretty famously claimed before the series ended that if anyone knew her religious beliefs they'd be able to guess the ending, and then Harry goes and dies for everyone else's salvation before resurrecting. But I don't see much evidence of that in her Twitter campaign against the troons.
 
  • Like
  • Thunk-Provoking
  • Informative
Reactions: Memento Malum, gmax alcremie, Richard Cheese and 12 others
Mola Ram said:
Her actual beliefs may run deeper than that -- she pretty famously claimed before the series ended that if anyone knew her religious beliefs they'd be able to guess the ending, and then Harry goes and dies for everyone else's salvation before resurrecting. But I don't see much evidence of that in her Twitter campaign against the troons.
Click to expand...
Perhaps she feels that her medico-political activism doesn’t need to cite religion as her beliefs are grounded in physical reality. Also, in a society as secular as the UK, she could easily lose ground with the people she’s trying to convince if she relied on doctrine. It’s also very much not her style to rely on institutional authority.
 
  • Like
  • Agree
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: gmax alcremie, Richard Cheese, Vecr and 8 others
Candidate No 7 said:
Right, I have to say something. This idea that porn is responsible for troons seems to be one of the few things GCs and Kiwi Farmers agree on, but I'm not convinced by it at all. In fact it makes little sense to me because sissy-type porn is an extremely niche drop in the ocean of straight and clichéd porn out there. You really have to look to find it, indicating a pre-existing interest.

I know some of the prominent "thinkers" in trannydom have confessed to that sort of trajectory, but they seem to me to be the exception. Most of the trans-identified people you see posting on social media seem to be more in a state of arrested development, and many seem to understand on one level or another that they are kissing their love/sex life goodbye. They all want to be seen as the opposite sex and are repulsed by "chasers".

A lot of the bizarre understanding of sexual/gender identities they have seems to have more in common with fantasy/gaming where you make up your character by choosing parameters.
Click to expand...
Its not entirely about the sissy stuff,

Pooners do the same things, just in the opposite direction. How many trans boys are BTS fans? How many watched the shit out of Ouran High School Host Club? How many were tumblr Supernatural fanfiction freaks? Most of them are freaks about cute boys and consumed so much rot that they tried to be it.

Its not that there was media to convince them they were trans, its that they tried to become the thing they were most attracted to and they had an echo chamber to help them along and give them excuses and terminology to justify trying to make their fetish reality.
 
  • Like
  • Agree
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: Richard Cheese, Aunt Carol, Arkin O'Brien and 15 others
Mola Ram said:
There's a big Christmas scene in every book, and there's a Bible verse on the Potters' tombstone. That said, it seems a fairly bland and nondenominational flavor of Christianity.
Click to expand...
Harry didn't even recognize that verse. It was about defeating death and I remember he was worried because it sounded like a Death Eater concept.

I always wondered about religion in the books. It's basically non-existent, the Christmas celebrations are completely devoid of any religious meaning, the Christmas Mass in the seventh book is probably the first time the story acknowledges the existence of religion.
 
  • Like
  • Agree
Reactions: Aliénor, gmax alcremie, Richard Cheese and 8 others
Mola Ram said:
I can honestly say I never considered Snape to be remotely Jewish until some much more enlightened, kind-hearted, broad-minded Social Justice cunt suggested it.
Click to expand...
When they started accusing Rowling of antisemitism a few years ago I did think Snape was the only character who that could apply to, because as Eurotrash the association goblins = jews is just so stupid. But she made Snape the hero so that made no sense either.
 
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: Vecr and luigismanslave
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back