Chris Pratt draws ire for razing historic 1950 LA home for sprawling mansion - Actor and wife Katherine Schwarzenegger dismantle 1950 Zimmerman house designed by architect Craig Ellwood

From The Guardian, 19 April 2024
Archive, link to original

375_640_2490_1493.jpg
The Zimmerman house in 1953. Photograph: Julius Shulman/J Paul Getty Trust, Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles

Chris Pratt has drawn ire from architecture aficionados after news broke that the actor and his wife, Katherine Schwarzenegger, had razed a historic, mid-century modern home to make way for a sprawling 15,000-sq-ft mansion.

Last year, the couple purchased the 1950 Zimmerman house, designed by the architect Craig Ellwood, in Los Angeles’s Brentwood neighborhood for $12.5m. The residence, with landscaping by Garrett Eckbo – who has been described as the pioneer of modern landscaping – had previously been featured in Progressive Architecture magazine.

It was most recently home to the late Hilda Rolfe, the widow of Sam Rolfe, co-creator of the series The Man from Uncle. Video of the property from December 2022 shows a light-filled home that appears to have been well-preserved, with large windows, wood floors and mid-century furniture.

The single-story home and its grounds have since been cleared and in its place will be a massive home in the modern farmhouse style that has come to dominate US suburbs.

0_172_4032_2688.jpg
The lot once occupied by the home designed by Craig Ellwood. Photograph: Adriene Biondo

Architect Ken Ungar, whose portfolio largely features high-end modern farmhouse-style residences, will design a home for the couple, Architectural Digest reported. The property, which is just across the street from Schwarzenegger’s mother, Maria Shriver, will also feature a three-car garage and a secondary unit near the pool.

The Los Angeles Conservancy, a non-profit that seeks to save and protect historic buildings, warned of the impending demolition in January and said that the residence appeared “to be highly intact and a noteworthy example of modernist design from this era”.

The city’s SurveyLA program had identified the property as potentially historic, but no protections were afforded, the conservancy wrote on Instagram.

161_443_2731_1821.jpg
The interior of the home in 1953. Photograph: Julius Schulman/J Paul Getty Trust, Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles

The Eichler Network, which covers mid-century homes in California, lamented the destruction.

“At the same time as architectural homes are being marketed as high-end, collectible art, others are being torn down to build new,” the writer Adriene Biondo said. “Perhaps a historic-cultural monument designation could have saved the Zimmerman house, or allowed the necessary time to delay demolition. Tragically, calls for preservation fell on deaf ears.”
 
Last edited:
That's a bummer, I can't imagine what will replace it will be anything near as cool. I think it's gross on a moral and aesthetic level, I know it didn't have landmark status. Can a house be given landmark status, is that a thing? If a house has a historical designation, is it a huge pain in the ass if you want to update it at all? Can you only get certain fixtures from the era it was made in? Can you renovate it at all? What happens if you do say, "Fuck it?" and demolish it anyway?
 
Other photos I managed to find of the house before demolition:

View attachment 5930028
Source

View attachment 5930033 View attachment 5930035
Source

View attachment 5930041
Source

View attachment 5930042 View attachment 5930045
Source

Looked better on the inside than it did on the outside if you want my honest opinion. Might have also looked better in black & white AFAICT but I can't find any colour shots of the interior.
The exterior shots look like a cheap motel.
 
Can a house be given landmark status, is that a thing? If a house has a historical designation, is it a huge pain in the ass if you want to update it at all?

It is here in the UK. Houses of particular historical or archetectural interest get something called Listed Building status. Once your house is designated as a listed building, having any work done costs something like four times what it would normally cost. First, you need to get consent from your local authority to have any work done at all. They might say no. Assuming they do say yes, they'll go on to specify how the work needs to be done. So, if you're replacing a window, say, they'll expect it to be done in a manner that's consistent with how the original window was made. Which will mean using a specialized craftsman to do the work. Who are very limited in numbers, always busy and consequently, very expensive.

And we have whole neighbourhoods designated 'Conservation Areas' where the same rules apply to all the houses in that area. The city I live in has 36 conservation areas covering 9% of the city. That's 19,000 properties.

Doing the work without getting permission first is a criminal offence. I don't think the Crooked House was a listed building or in a conservation area, but they're forcing them to rebuild it brick by brick just because they didn't get planning permission to demolish it.

"The Crooked House was not a listed building, but was a non-designated heritage asset, registered on the Historic Environment Record as a building of local importance."

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news...ed-house-pub-after-fire-ordered-to-rebuild-it
 
Last edited:
Other photos I managed to find of the house before demolition:

View attachment 5930028
Source

View attachment 5930033 View attachment 5930035
Source

View attachment 5930041
Source

View attachment 5930042 View attachment 5930045
Source

Looked better on the inside than it did on the outside if you want my honest opinion. Might have also looked better in black & AFAICT but I can't find any colour shots of the interior.
Looks like trash, what the architectural marvel is he made it look like a fucking square block?

And sure the interior may be nice but if you arent living there whos the fuck is ever going to see it?

That's a bummer, I can't imagine what will replace it will be anything near as cool. I think it's gross on a moral and aesthetic level, I know it didn't have landmark status. Can a house be given landmark status, is that a thing? If a house has a historical designation, is it a huge pain in the ass if you want to update it at all? Can you only get certain fixtures from the era it was made in? Can you renovate it at all? What happens if you do say, "Fuck it?" and demolish it anyway?

Why would you want to preserve this fucking shack-tier exterior design?
 
Last edited:
I'd wager Cali would have no problem with the removal of historical statues, plaques and monuments if it was an inconvenient historical truth. I have no sympathy. Plus, building science has advanced exponentially since this was built. I'd wager the new house will be 90-95% more efficient with energy use than the previous, Brady Bunch style of home. That's a good thing, right Green Cali?
 
That's a bummer, I can't imagine what will replace it will be anything near as cool. I think it's gross on a moral and aesthetic level, I know it didn't have landmark status. Can a house be given landmark status, is that a thing? If a house has a historical designation, is it a huge pain in the ass if you want to update it at all? Can you only get certain fixtures from the era it was made in? Can you renovate it at all? What happens if you do say, "Fuck it?" and demolish it anyway?
Sort of, it depends on where you are.


IMG_7662.jpeg

People always take architecture like this for granted. We barely have any Art Deco buildings left because people in the 70-90s thought they were eyesores.
 
Dude’s literally moving in next door to his mother-in-law, he’s got enough problems already.

Besides, the house was from the early 50’s, and the last resident was 99. In all likelihood the wiring was never updated, there was a ramp for every exterior door, the bathroom was remodeled for a sitting tub, and the furnace was permanently stuck on the max thermostat setting.

And that’s not even mentioning the old person smell.
 
Back