Speaking of Brightline this is what the ride is like:
Edit added the video of the orlando spur he took:
This guy is great if you want a mild dose of train autism.
The segment from West Palm Beach to Miami looks like a normal commuter rail line, not HSR.
The video guy mentioned the train has a top speed of 79 mph on that segment (which is similar to other commuter rail lines like BART) but has a lot of slow zones plus station stops, meaning the average speed is lower. Outside of rush hour, it's probably faster to drive there on the highways. He also mentioned that there was some form of security checkpoint, so there goes one of the "advantages" that HSR advocates say trains have over planes.
The major problem is that it is incredibly expensive. For the 45 mile/45 minute drive between Boca Raton and Downtown Miami, the video creator spent $52 with a promotion for a first class seat (he didn't say how much the economy ticket cost him).
From Brightline's website, an economy ticket for that segment tomorrow costs costs $31.50 in the early morning and late at night, $56.50 during both morning and evening rush hours, and $41.50 between rush hours. I also checked a month out and the prices are even more. A round trip is over $100 if taken during reasonable hours.
They also sell a commuter rail pass with 40 rides a month for $399. I know the carfuckers would say that $400/mo is cheaper than owning a car, except that is significantly more expensive than just driving 90 miles a day and the Brightline membership is only good for a commute so one would still have all the non-marginal costs of a car for non-commute travel. The sample commute costs $210/mo (half of what Brightline costs with the pass) for 20 working days assuming $3.50 gas in a 30 mpg car.
This commentor did the same math as me (but for the full Orlando-Miami route):
This commentor is the first use case I've seen that makes sense for the HSR segment (especially now that the Disney World to Port of Miami route isn't happening because the Disney World station was canceled), but it doesn't sound like that common of a situation:
lmao:
