Sorry straight white men, Doctor Who was never made for you

Article | Archive

From the moment I saw Ncuti Gatwa dancing the night away in a bright outfit during the 2023 Christmas special, I knew I would fall in love with his iteration of The Doctor.

Not everyone was as excited by such an unapologetically queer Black Doctor Who though. A vocal contingent of keyboard warriors took to social media to claim the show had gone too ‘woke’.

From arguing that the show has been ‘torn apart by woke ideologues’ to creating their own social media trend #RIPDoctorWho, you don’t need to go far to find the litany of tired complaints.

But I’d argue that the show has always been socially-progressive and inclusive.

I started watching the show during David Tennant’s run as the 10th Doctor over 15 years ago, and immediately fell in love with the beautiful themes of found family, combined with the captivating space-and-time adventures. I never looked back.

Over the past 60 years, the iconic British TV show has cultivated a devoted fanbase – following the timey-wimey adventures of an alien known as the Doctor and his human companion in the TARDIS.

Jinkx Monsoon in Doctor Who
Drag queen Jinkx Monsoon will have a role in the new series (Picture: James Pardon/Bad Wolf/BBC Studios)
In a nutshell, there is no world too crazy, time too far, or creature too strange. Not even the end of the universe is the limit.

So for a show so versatile, and with fluidity so naturally imbued into its bones, it’s truly baffling that a non-straight, non-white Doctor feels so unbelievable to so many people.

It’s not the first time this ‘woke’ accusation has been levelled at the show.

Ncuti’s predecessor Jodie Whittaker (the 13th Doctor) battled intense public scrutiny as the first woman to take over the beloved role. Angry viewers similarly accused the show of pandering to woke times, causing Jodie to tell the press ‘it’s terrifying that a woman being given a particular job can cause so much rage’.

Now Ncuti has been forced to justify his place in the sci-fi series since news of his casting in May 2022.

In a recent interview with Attitude, the Sex Education star has spoken about the irrelevance of trolls: ‘You are so angry over something so inconsequential that you can’t be an interesting person. You can’t have much in your life.’

But the bigoted straight white men who have spiralled into a meltdown clearly haven’t been paying attention to the reboot’s rich and ever-evolving history of multiculturalism and LGBTQ+ inclusion.

When Queer As Folk creator, Russell T Davies, brought Doctor Who back in 2005 it was clear from the get-go that this is a show for all the outcasts in society.

Class commentary was placed front and centre through Rose Tyler (Billie Piper) and her mum Jackie who lived on a London council estate. And left-wing sentiment has been a common thread throughout the series.

In this season, viewers were introduced to queer companion Captain Jack Harkness (who shared a same-sex kiss with The Doctor in the season finale on primetime TV as far back as 2005).

Alongside the steady drip of LGBTQ+ side characters, in 2008 Freema Agyeman made history as the first full-time Black female companion, Martha Jones. One episode (Family of Blood) sees her proving her worth as a Black female Doctor while trapped in the past.

At the time, Agyeman too faced racist backlash from the public, which she later revealed: ‘What I didn’t anticipate – and maybe I was naïve – was the racism from certain sectors of the fanbase… yeah, I couldn’t rationalise that.’

Since the early reboot days the ‘woke’ momentum has only picked up, and with it the accuracy of the representation.

Behind the scenes, screenwriters such as Vinay Patel and Malorie Blackman have penned historic stories about partition and the civil rights movement. While Segun Akinola did a tenure as Doctor Who composer from 2018 to 2022.

On screen in recent years – under the helm of showrunners Steven Moffat and Chris Chibnall – we’ve seen a South Asian Master (the Doctor’s recurring arch-nemesis) played by Sacha Dhawan and Jo Martin magnificently embodying the Fugitive Doctor.
 
The sheer, petulant seething. 😆 In a few months, this dog faced streetshitter bitch will be penning another whopper blaming those same straight white men-the ones the show was never meant for, according to this hateful cunt-for the show finally getting axed.
 
Here’s the trailer. Last I checked, the writing seemed like something out of fanfiction. Has that changed any?
It's a show made for children to watch with their parents. The writing is targeted to children. It's just slightly deeper than the average episode of the smurfs, and never more complicated than batman the animated series.
 
In a recent interview with Attitude, the Sex Education star has spoken about the irrelevance of trolls: ‘You are so angry over something so inconsequential that you can’t be an interesting person. You can’t have much in your life.’
Then you won't mind if we make Dr. Who straight, white, and male again, right?
 
Here's the thing.

Doctor Who has had a huge gay fanbase for years. As far as I know, it's well known for that in Britain, but not as much in the US. Gay British kids in the 80s and 90s gravitated towards this sexless, alien hero who didn't fit in.

Russell T Davies and Chris Chibnall, two of the last three showrunners, are such people.

But...

They aren't all or even the majority of fans. Showrunner Stephen Moffat and two of the recent actors, David Tennant and Peter Capaldi, were mega fans since childhood too. And they are straight.

Russell T Davies restarted the show in 2005 as a fan, but not as a gay fan. He made it for everyone. He had black characters and gay/bi characters and nobody much minded. But it was a mainstream show, so much that it became an international phenomena.

This new iteration is not for everyone. It is Gay Science Fiction, created for gay, lesbian, bi, trans, queer, genderspecial and whatever. He brought back David Tennant specifically to shit on his legacy-make him bi, make him get owned about pronouns and not being a woman anymore. It was a definitive slap in the face to any fan who wasn't queer to say "this show isn't for you now. If you want to watch, you are allowed, but this is not a show meant for you."

I don't know what happened to Davies in the last 10 years. But he made a conscious decision to create a Queer Sci Fi show by and for queers. Ncuti Gatwa presents as specifically gay. His dialogue is coded as gay. He dresses gay. Davies could have created an entirely new show to do this because as a gay man it is clearly important to him. He seems to feel now he has to have a show that caters to trans issues, stars a gay hero, overly represents disabled people as being superheros and never bad, everything that he feels he didn't address enough before.

He could have made a whole new show, but the BBC and Disney came to him begging him to save the show and his values and agenda happened to wholly align with theirs. Why create a new show when you could use the name recognition of an internationally known hit?

And that's fine. If he and the BBC and Disney want to make a queer sci-fi show, good for them. But I have no desire to watch it. It's not for me. I'm sure Empire is a fine show. But it's by and for black people, about their culture. It holds no interest to me. So I don't watch it. And I have zero desire to watch this new Doctor Who.
 
I don't mind and not just because I've never watched an episode (and never wanted to) but also because Doctor Who always had a left-wing tint. Even the earliest episodes were "Discrimination is bad, segregation is bad, racism is bad, we're all human beings so why can't we come together and live peacefully?". The writers were and are hippie dippie lefties and something like this was inevitable. It was either "Gay and black Doctor Who owns the DaleKKK chudderinos who do not believe in heckin equalityrino" or "Doctor Who builds a gay eco-friendly anarcho-communist utopia throughout time and space" either way.
TL;DR who should fucking care about this, lol.
 

Sorry straight white men, Doctor Who was never made for you​


I know these article titles are clickbait made to get people riled up so they'll read and be served ads in the process, but this is pants on head retarded. I watched Dr. Who in the 80s and 90s on PBS. It was on every weekend like a special event. And nothing I remember about it was tailor made for queer women of color or whatever this retard is going on about.

I'm tired of seeing what amounts to "Sorry. But that thing you liked? It's all mine now so fuck off" in articles. It's rude, crude and childish. It's like you stole some kid's toy are are hoping he'll cry so you can laugh at him. These articles deserve to be ignored. Don't give any attention to these infantile brats. They already stole the fandom communities and they can't stop rubbing it in. It's just the grown up version of "Haha! I have your ball now! Go home and cry to mommy". It's pathetic and we need to stop giving these people attention.

Just because a show is weird and features a cast of unusual characters does not mean it's somehow made for LGBTUV123's. I'm so tired of this. Stop claiming everything is queer. Can't you just enjoy things without interjecting your sexual identity into it? I'm sorry but all my faves are not queer because you have insecurities with your sexual identity and don't know how else to cope.
 
Dr. Who has first, foremost, and always been a show for children.

Yes, quite. Dr Who was for little children, to introduce them to emerging ideas in science. Then it became a nerd magnet for slightly older children, fizzled out and retired gracefully as a beloved nostalgia name that lived on in audiobooks, comics and the occasional fan made animation. Douglas Adams wrote fan scripts for Dr Who!

Then they tried to reboot it with Paul McGann as an action film (???) and it didn't work at all, what the fuck was that? The BBC then rebooted it as a British Buffy The Vampire Slayer for slightly older children, and struck autism gold in America, the Holy Grail and only focus for British TV post-millennium.

So, really, this progression into the depths of LBQTP+ Hell with a literal gay nigger from outer space makes perfect sense: these American autists have grown up into trannies and nonbinary dangerhairs, and the corpse of the show now skinwalks with them. The twerking Klingons made less sense than this stunning and brave new direction of Dr Who which draws a straight line from the 00s to now.

Perhaps more alarmingly, this is a Disney product.
 
MOTHERFUCKERS GIVE ME MY SCHIZOPHRENIC MARY POPPINS BACK 1000040285.jpg
 
this article is nearly flawless bait. respect to the disgusting bug person who gestated this monster in their esophagus before it burst through their thorax and skittered onto our screens. I admire its purity.

But I’d argue that the show has always been socially-progressive and inclusive.

I started watching the show during David Tennant’s run as the 10th Doctor over 15 years ago,

this is a hilarious stance that has become standard among faggy column writers like this that are running cover for - among other things - the globohomo self-suck spectacle known as modern Dr. Who. durr I got into a 60 year old show just a few seasons ago but let me argue this insipid point about culture war bullshit like it's always been true. our fathers and grandfathers lived their lives with a deep, quiet resentment for the former vassals of the fallen Empire intruding into the homeland, which is one reason why our generation is overcompensating so hard, but also one of the stalwarts of British media from the 20th century was actually heckin' progressive and inclusive in the same way cultural libs understand the terms today.

So for a show so versatile, and with fluidity so naturally imbued into its bones, it’s truly baffling that a non-straight, non-white Doctor feels so unbelievable to so many people.

it's because it's a fucking stupid fantasy. nobody thinks it's cool or impressive that the Doctor turned himself into a gaynigger except for joyless, shallow, emotionally stunted retards like you. a phone booth that defies physical reality and slips through time and space or a fuckin screwdriver that can conjure force fields or evil alien squids in trash can armor are all cool shit that doesn't exist in reality and stimulates the imagination. gayniggers, on the other hand, exist in reality, are not interesting, and most importantly, aren't fucking relatable. a dumpy white guy with shitty teeth is relatable for like 80% of the British public. black genderfreaks make up like 1% of the population, meaning they're shit you only see on Graham Norton or whatever awful faggy talk show is popular over there right now, as a symbol of what's Cool and Interesting according to the media fags, as opposed to you, the disgusting untouchable viewer.

In a recent interview with Attitude, the Sex Education star has spoken about the irrelevance of trolls: ‘You are so angry over something so inconsequential that you can’t be an interesting person. You can’t have much in your life.’

this is the worst part of Current Year. everyone knows this is disingenuous as hell. the media is trumpeting how amazing and triumphant it is that this dude is taking over the role, and how awful and disgusting it is that anybody has a problem with it, but at the same time, the haters are just "trolls" who are "irrelevant" who are "angry over something [...] inconsequential". this is one example of the doublethink that's driving everyone insane, how cultural libs can accept and regurgitate shit that's obviously not true, while they obviously also don't actually believe it's true. to them, the Message is more important than anything, more important than not lying, even more important than following your own values. and the only thing that comes close in importance is deceiving, denying, and destroying the nonbelievers.

But the bigoted straight white men who have spiralled into a meltdown clearly haven’t been paying attention to the reboot’s rich and ever-evolving history of multiculturalism and LGBTQ+ inclusion.

When Queer As Folk creator, Russell T Davies, brought Doctor Who back in 2005 it was clear from the get-go that this is a show for all the outcasts in society.

and there goes the supposed 60 year history of Social Progressivism and Inclusivity that Dr. Who supposedly represents. tiresome.

Dr. Who has first, foremost, and always been a show for children.

this goes without saying as it is made for a British audience
 
Back