WhatifAltHist / Rudyard Lynch - History youtuber, galaxy brained, no credentials and no sex

[Mudkipcorn]

View attachment 6004706

This is the exact same thing as his IQ take. In that case, he started with the conclusion he is far above average in intellect. The IQ test said he was a bit above average. Ergo, IQ is bunk. Here we have Rudyard starting with the idea that being bluepilled on women is fundamentally wrong. But bluepilled men exist and go after women. Ergo they never get any and probably change their dating "strategy" at some point. It can't be that he is average or that most women prefer men who are genuine over those who play games and are brainbroke from /pol/.

Does he really believe that in current year only redpilled men (whatever that means) get involved in relationships? Bruh, all my closest friends are married or in a long-term relationships and none of them are/are dating a redpilled man. I'm not a zoomer but even I know a couple and they date just as 20-somethings always have. But he "imagines" it doesn't work.

I'm not retarded. Obviously 'just be yourself!' won't work for everyone but I really can't fathom how a human being who is at least tangentially familiar with the real world can believe that normal people don't pair off in current year. I want to know exactly what he means by being red/bluepilled on women.

Edit: Forgot to add that there's also a classic Rudy wordfart. The dangling "yet it does" at the end of the Xeet doesn't agree with the sentence. What does what? He probably meant 'yet people do [maintain the bluepilled strategy for years]'. I don't think it's particularly incisive to point out someone's typos. We all do it. Just a bit funny that a 100% neurotypical hyperintellectual has grammatical errors every other Xeet. I don't tend to notice these in his video scripts. Could be because he actually proofreads those, or just that they slip by because it's audio and I don't pay as much attention.

 

[Amerikaner Teddybär]

This is the exact same thing as his IQ take. In that case, he started with the conclusion he is far above average in intellect. The IQ test said he was a bit above average. Ergo, IQ is bunk. Here we have Rudyard starting with the idea that being bluepilled on women is fundamentally wrong. But bluepilled men exist and go after women. Ergo they never get any and probably change their dating "strategy" at some point. It can't be that he is average or that most women prefer men who are genuine over those who play games and are brainbroke from /pol/.

Does he really believe that in current year only redpilled men (whatever that means) get involved in relationships? Bruh, all my closest friends are married or in a long-term relationships and none of them are/are dating a redpilled man. I'm not a zoomer but even I know a couple and they date just as 20-somethings always have. But he "imagines" it doesn't work.

I'm not retarded. Obviously 'just be yourself!' won't work for everyone but I really can't fathom how a human being who is at least tangentially familiar with the real world can believe that normal people don't pair off in current year. I want to know exactly what he means by being red/bluepilled on women.

Edit: Forgot to add that there's also a classic Rudy wordfart. The dangling "yet it does" at the end of the Xeet doesn't agree with the sentence. What does what? He probably meant 'yet people do [maintain the bluepilled strategy for years]'. I don't think it's particularly incisive to point out someone's typos. We all do it. Just a bit funny that a 100% neurotypical hyperintellectual has grammatical errors every other Xeet. I don't tend to notice these in his video scripts. Could be because he actually proofreads those, or just that they slip by because it's audio and I don't pay as much attention.

This shows how much Rudy understands relationships and their workings. He won't initiate conversation with a woman, he constantly has his head up his own ass with his egotistical takes, and just seems like a boring dude to be with. I recall a wise man's saying that a long-lasting relationship is the acceptance of an imperfect person, which is probably the biggest reason for Rudy's incel behavior. He can't accept anything that is different to what he wants in a woman.

On a different note, has anyone actually figured out if Rudy actually is 6'4 or does he just say that to make himself less insecure? If he is then by his logic he'd be with a woman already, probably would've dropped this shtick and probably would've done something other than stoke the flames of an incel revolution that'll never happen.

 

[Toji Suzuhara]

He can't accept anything that is different to what he wants in a woman

What does WIAH even want from a woman in the first place? He clearly isn't desperately attempting to get laid, like the average incel, and he also has a lot of attention and support coming from his audience, as well as him basically acting like an outcast due to his massive intellect, so it being the social norm can't be the cause. Unless his parents are pressuring him to find a girlfriemd/wife (which could be likely, as his parents were very religious, if I'm not mistaken), then I don't see what benefit he would get other than following his larp as a social elite from the ancient times, which you can do even with an ugly woman or a goldigger

 

[soulgains]

"A long-lasting relationship is the acceptance of an imperfect person"

Anyone whose been in any kind of relationship will get that. Theres boundaries and red lines, obviously, you won't accept your partner cheating or doing something extremely self destructive, like trooning out, committing serious crimes, joining a cult, etc etc, but for the most part you deal with people as they are and try to work within that. Politispergs think they can dictate to people, talk down to them and force them to embrace their autistic, niche ideology because of their own misunderstanding of historical examples like the Soviet Union, Nazi Germany, or even modern examples like China. The relationship between citizens and government is a never ending calculus, a government must always be ready to address the challenges it faces and maintain popular support. The same dynamic applies to relationships. You need to be adaptive and respond to the other person because you're two parts of a whole, lest the whole thing collapses. Domination and subjugation of another with zero benefit to that other is a non-starter. Any relationship will be built on a foundation of trust, and mutual recognition, be it on the personal level, or the governmental one.

 

[Mudkipcorn]

I do try to look at what people are saying in the YouTube Community Tab comments and in Twitter replies, but normally it isn't that interesting. The juxtaposition here made me smirk though. This is from the bluepilled men Xeet. The Pickme and the Pajeet.




In all seriousness I feel bad for her. She has a few funny tweets but mostly reposts mildly le based tweets, economic news, and her own zero-engagement posts about how no one cares about her and she wishes she were a man (I saw at least three of these). Single boys, time to set your Duolicious profiles to Finland.

Spoiler: Sad young woman

Will Rudy take notice?

 

[soulgains]

I do try to look at what people are saying in the YouTube Community Tab comments and in Twitter replies, but normally it isn't that interesting. The juxtaposition here made me smirk though. This is from the bluepilled men Xeet. The Pickme and the Pajeet.


View attachment 6005407

In all seriousness I feel bad for her. She has a few funny tweets but mostly reposts mildly le based tweets, economic news, and her own zero-engagement posts about how no one cares about her and she wishes she were a man (I saw at least three of these). Single boys, time to set your Duolicious profiles to Finland.

Spoiler: Sad young woman

View attachment 6005408
View attachment 6005426View attachment 6005427View attachment 6005425

Will Rudy take notice?

She's not conventionally unnattractive. Its the way she carries herself, even the way the PFP was taken makes her look offputting to normal people. If you're a woman and revolting to men, and you arent hideously ugly, or obese, something is wrong within your brain, something that can likely (hopefully) be changed and corrected. She thinks she hit "the wall" a decade before she'll actually hit it. Its the edgelord mentality of "I'm already dead so I'll do what I want" even when they have no intention of suicide, harming others, or having any impact on anything. Its just an excuse to be anti-social, and seperate yourself from everyone else when the only thing that distinguishes you from the rest of humanity is your own autism.

 

[Toji Suzuhara]

View attachment 6005458
View attachment 6005456
She's not conventionally unnattractive. Its the way she carries herself, even the way the PFP was taken that make her look offputting to normal people. If you're a woman and revolting to men, and you arent hideously ugly, or obese, something is wrong within your brain, something that can likely (hopefully) be changed and corrected. She thinks she hit "the wall" a decade before she'll actually hit it. Its the edgelord mentality of "I'm already dead so I'll do what I want" even when they have no intention of suicide, harming others, or having any impact on anything. Its just an excuse to be anti-social, and seperate yourself from everyone else when the only thing that distinguishes you from the rest of humanity is your own autism.

She looks like one of those old european dolls

 

[Local Fed]

Single boys, time to set your Duolicious profiles to Finland.

Well there you go, that explains the autism.

Unless she's doing a gimmick or a long con troll or something, she does come across as kind of socially retarded or at least terminally Finnish. Based on the picture above she's pretty average looking and definitely not bad looking, but she's got that unsettling vacant look to her that screams "Something is off."

 

[WelperHelper99]

Also, I don't think this has been mentioned before, but there's a pretty big Presbyterian YouTube channel called Redeemed Zoomer and I see a lot in common between him and Rudy. Only, Redeemed Zoomer focuses exclusively on Christianity and wants to "reclaim" mainstream churches from liberalism. He's clearly a big fan considering how many times he's replied to his tweets and uses ideas from him in his videos.

View attachment 5997884View attachment 5997885View attachment 5997886View attachment 5997887View attachment 5997889View attachment 5997890

You left out the one where he says he's (ethnically) Jewish. That'd make a lot of groypers and /pol/tards madder than any of the above.

https://x.com/redeemed_zoomer/status/1790871954401992750

View attachment 5998443

I just want to say this since I've been Christian my whole life: you both are missing the mark. So much. Instead of preaching the word you worry about the libtards. Christianity has seen far, far worse than them. The first 70 years of our existence we were nearly obliterated. The modern left isn't going to do us in when Nero couldn't. You have a political bent behind why you're saying you're Christian, and irks the fuck out of me.

 

[Toji Suzuhara]

You have a political bent behind why you're saying you're Christian, and irks the fuck out of me.

Christianity being percieved as a primarily political idea has been a long-lasting problem in the US and the West at large since at least the inter-war period, one which reached its peak on the internet sphere during Bush Jr., and reached rock-bottom thanks to the absolute morons and deviants of Nick Fuentes and AF and all of those that give them the time of the day. But regarding Redeemed Zoomer, he genuinely believes, follows, and most importantly, focuses, on the religious aspect of Christianity and its current problems

 

[Baraka Obama]

View attachment 6005458
View attachment 6005456
She's not conventionally unnattractive. Its the way she carries herself, even the way the PFP was taken makes her look offputting to normal people. If you're a woman and revolting to men, and you arent hideously ugly, or obese, something is wrong within your brain, something that can likely (hopefully) be changed and corrected. She thinks she hit "the wall" a decade before she'll actually hit it. Its the edgelord mentality of "I'm already dead so I'll do what I want" even when they have no intention of suicide, harming others, or having any impact on anything. Its just an excuse to be anti-social, and seperate yourself from everyone else when the only thing that distinguishes you from the rest of humanity is your own autism.

If that's her I'd wager to say she's at least cute but I have to really wonder who would actively choose such an unpleasant expession for a photo to display to the world.

Like, really? That was the best photo you could find or make?

 

[Amerikaner Teddybär]

I just want to say this since I've been Christian my whole life: you both are missing the mark. So much. Instead of preaching the word you worry about the libtards. Christianity has seen far, far worse than them. The first 70 years of our existence we were nearly obliterated. The modern left isn't going to do us in when Nero couldn't. You have a political bent behind why you're saying you're Christian, and irks the fuck out of me.

Granted RZ does go into detail about theology and knows his stuff which puts him above 90% of "Trad" Christians online. Still he does seem to have political reasons for being a Christian despite the fact Jesus told Saint Peter that the Church will not be overwhelmed by the gate of Hell.

View attachment 6005458
View attachment 6005456
She's not conventionally unnattractive. Its the way she carries herself, even the way the PFP was taken makes her look offputting to normal people. If you're a woman and revolting to men, and you arent hideously ugly, or obese, something is wrong within your brain, something that can likely (hopefully) be changed and corrected. She thinks she hit "the wall" a decade before she'll actually hit it. Its the edgelord mentality of "I'm already dead so I'll do what I want" even when they have no intention of suicide, harming others, or having any impact on anything. Its just an excuse to be anti-social, and seperate yourself from everyone else when the only thing that distinguishes you from the rest of humanity is your own autism.

I don't trust the turtleneck but if it is a girl she's not half-bad looking but her mindset is "Wah, men don't love me" when it comes to relationships.

"A long-lasting relationship is the acceptance of an imperfect person"

Anyone whose been in any kind of relationship will get that. Theres boundaries and red lines, obviously, you won't accept your partner cheating or doing something extremely self destructive, like trooning out, committing serious crimes, joining a cult, etc etc, but for the most part you deal with people as they are and try to work within that. Politispergs think they can dictate to people, talk down to them and force them to embrace their autistic, niche ideology because of their own misunderstanding of historical examples like the Soviet Union, Nazi Germany, or even modern examples like China. The relationship between citizens and government is a never ending calculus, a government must always be ready to address the challenges it faces and maintain popular support. The same dynamic applies to relationships. You need to be adaptive and respond to the other person because you're two parts of a whole, lest the whole thing collapses. Domination and subjugation of another with zero benefit to that other is a non-starter. Any relationship will be built on a foundation of trust, and mutual recognition, be it on the personal level, or the governmental one.

That is exactly what Rudy does not understand. The vast majority of people do not give a shit about politics but Rudy will think otherwise thanks to people on the internet that have nothing better to do then to complain about anything with the faintest scent of political messaging or to gain internet points.

 

[WelperHelper99]

Granted RZ does go into detail about theology and knows his stuff which puts him above 90% of "Trad" Christians online. Still he does seem to have political reasons for being a Christian despite the fact Jesus told Saint Peter that the Church will not be overwhelmed by the gate of Hell.

He's a jew, right? Switching to Christianity wouldn't be that hard technically speaking, you just add the new testament. I expect him to "know his stuff", he grew up with it. As for the politics in the church- this is how you get gay churches. You inject shit. It's strange to explain, but things auto correct over time when it comes to religion. As long as you haven't altered the books themselves, doctrine, it'll rebound. This has happened many times. Trying to artificially induce this is always disastrous.

 

[Toji Suzuhara]

He's a jew, right? Switching to Christianity wouldn't be that hard technically speaking, you just add the new testament.

I know about RZ, he has always been a presbitarian since he was born, altough he was very secularized when younger. He only became more conservative after going to the midwest

 

[soulgains]

Christianity being percieved as a primarily political idea has been a long-lasting problem in the US and the West at large since at least the inter-war period, one which reached its peak on the internet sphere during Bush Jr., and reached rock-bottom thanks to the absolute morons and deviants of Nick Fuentes and AF and all of those that give them the time of the day. But regarding Redeemed Zoomer, he genuinely believes, follows, and most importantly, focuses, on the religious aspect of Christianity and its current problems

I don't think Nick ever had the potential to do much damage. The world still turns. Rudy, on the other hand, has a far larger, more active audience than Nick has ever had. His ideas arent rooted in a church or established institution, they're rooted in his own autistic interpretation of the books hes read once over. He thinks hes the smartest in the room in any setting, which is a trait of a cult leader.

L. Ron Hubbard had the same kind of middling intelligence and ability to manipulate vulnerable people. He talked out of his ass endlessly about topics he had zero knowledge on. He lived with famed occultist and Aleister Crowley acolyte Jack Parsons. L. Ron saw the kind of shit in his life Rudyard pretends to see and know about, yet he ended up in a nearly identical position. Rudyard is the down syndrome version of a Hubbard, unable to connect with people outside his own audience and bring anyone into his way of thinking that doesn't already suffer from severe alienation/isolation from other people.

 

[Lindy64]

 

[Laughing Putin]

If he waits a few more years, he might be writing that history of the world as a she.

 

[Mudkipcorn]

More tweets about sex and women. Also another that illustrates the qualities of his analytic mind.

Spoiler: Women

The language on this one is wild. He can viscerally tell that women hate him on a biological level? What could that even mean?


On another note, some actual good advice that I hope he follows.

Spoiler: History

Rudy found a book with an ever so slightly subversive subtitle. He doesn't immediately understand and assumes it's Marxist garbage.

Clearly he red the blurbs.


The funny part is that a follower holds his hand by dissecting it a little bit and Rudy comes around.


Personally, I think the description makes it very clear roughly what this book will be about. I'm sure there's some stuff Rudy (and probably myself) would disagree with in there, but it certainly doesn't sound like postmodern drivel to me. If Rudy had any academic background or even curiosity about postwar academic developments, he would know that the 'The Invention of X' is a bit of a trope. It implies that the work will be a bit deconstructionist in nature, but not necessarily the sort of posttruth subjectivist stuff that he undoubtedly hates.

Given his interests in antiquity, historiography, public history, and even evolutionary psychology, it actually sounds like something he might be very interested in. To his credit, he does hear the follower out and acknowledges that his reading was a bit dumb.

Bonus extra asking what his fans disagree with him on. The answers might surprise you.


Very appropriate that the ad is something called Gnosis Pay.

That's enough for now. I find it all fascinating but none of these are really big so I'll try to be a bit more selective.

 

[Toji Suzuhara]

He doesn't immediately understand and assumes it's Marxist garbage.

The book ironically does the same that WIAH does in almost every one of his historical videos. He talks about an event of the ancient past, and tries to explain the entirety of a civilization from there, something which you can clearly see in this video of his, altough his position is even more simplistic as it focuses almost entirely on the geographical aspect.

Western men are the nicest and most acommodating they have ever been

WIAH either doesn't listen to any of his videos/comment section or thinks that been a doormat is the same as being nice, because even seeing a man holding the door for a woman is a rare occurance in the US, and also the language of the tweet literally reads as if it were initially posted on r/incels

 

[Overwritten Tapes]

Weird to see a thread on him, he always came off as kinda auto but he's charming in his way, one of my channels is subscribed to him.