WhatifAltHist / Rudyard Lynch - History youtuber, galaxy brained, no credentials and no sex

Also, I don't think this has been mentioned before, but there's a pretty big Presbyterian YouTube channel called Redeemed Zoomer and I see a lot in common between him and Rudy. Only, Redeemed Zoomer focuses exclusively on Christianity and wants to "reclaim" mainstream churches from liberalism. He's clearly a big fan considering how many times he's replied to his tweets and uses ideas from him in his videos.

View attachment 5997884View attachment 5997885View attachment 5997886View attachment 5997887View attachment 5997889View attachment 5997890
I just remember he got BTFO a debate with Jay Dyer, and he seethes about the Orthodox in his discord, to the point he banned them and the Catholics for "trying to get others to convert". He just has some retarded takes on theology, It also doesn't help that all his vids are the "EVERY type of X in Y minutes" meme.
 
I just remember he got BTFO a debate with Jay Dyer, and he seethes about the Orthodox in his discord, to the point he banned them and the Catholics for "trying to get others to convert". He just has some retarded takes on theology, It also doesn't help that all his vids are the "EVERY type of X in Y minutes" meme.
Only the shorts are "every type of X in Y", but if he banned Catholics from his Discord, then that platform proves once again that's one controversy away from being basically a tool of the devil. It's always Discord what gets the worst side of a person, no exceptions
 
The guy's obviously just grifting by saying what young people want to hear. OTOH he says Karens are going to destroy civilization so maybe he's onto something? 🤔
 
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: Vecr and Bloudwulf
I just remember he got BTFO a debate with Jay Dyer, and he seethes about the Orthodox in his discord, to the point he banned them and the Catholics for "trying to get others to convert". He just has some retarded takes on theology, It also doesn't help that all his vids are the "EVERY type of X in Y minutes" meme.

 
To be fair here, i'm pretty sure RZ apologized for this, along with some other things. But it does seem to be a common occurrence where he pisses off a certain group of Christians, says something stupid, then backtracks on it and apologizes
 
I just remember he got BTFO a debate with Jay Dyer, and he seethes about the Orthodox in his discord, to the point he banned them and the Catholics for "trying to get others to convert". He just has some retarded takes on theology, It also doesn't help that all his vids are the "EVERY type of X in Y minutes" meme.
Lmao. Buddy, I'm neither of those, and I would never try stopping conversions because they're still spreading the word. The thing about Christianity is that we are a family. All of us say the other is retarded, sure, but at the end of the day, we're fighting for the same cause. This guy got converted late in life, that is evident.
 
Lmao. Buddy, I'm neither of those, and I would never try stopping conversions because they're still spreading the word. The thing about Christianity is that we are a family. All of us say the other is retarded, sure, but at the end of the day, we're fighting for the same cause. This guy got converted late in life, that is evident.
I'm a Catholic, and if the opposite happened and there were mass conversions to presbitarianism/orthodoxy, I would be sad but not hold any ill will, why? Because in the end, we don't 100% know whether or not being part of a different branch of Christianity will always end up with you going to Hell, but what we do know is that not sincerely believing in the faith certainly does
 
I'm a Catholic, and if the opposite happened and there were mass conversions to presbitarianism/orthodoxy, I would be sad but not hold any ill will, why? Because in the end, we don't 100% know whether or not being part of a different branch of Christianity will always end up with you going to Hell, but what we do know is that not sincerely believing in the faith certainly does
In the end it comes down to the choice of the individual. That cannot be taken away ever. It doesn't matter what you or I think, if we both present our arguments and this person chooses a third church, there's nothing to be sad over. If you give your best effort, God will be happy. Getting mad over it, not so much.
 
Lmao. Buddy, I'm neither of those, and I would never try stopping conversions because they're still spreading the word. The thing about Christianity is that we are a family. All of us say the other is retarded, sure, but at the end of the day, we're fighting for the same cause. This guy got converted late in life, that is evident.
That's the problem with trying to treat the Truth as a sport, especially with these zoomer laymen starting YouTube channels despite barely knowing the theology.

It's like the story of the Japanese man going to Mt. Athos, and a bunch of the monks and others were asking him questions and trying to convert that way, which annoyed him. Later on, a saint had sat down with him and gave him an orange, which I believe helped the man convert.
 
That's the problem with trying to treat the Truth as a sport, especially with these zoomer laymen starting YouTube channels despite barely knowing the theology.

It's like the story of the Japanese man going to Mt. Athos, and a bunch of the monks and others were asking him questions and trying to convert that way, which annoyed him. Later on, a saint had sat down with him and gave him an orange, which I believe helped the man convert.
I will say this, especially with the Bible, it takes years of dedicated study to get a MERE grasp of it. It's absolutely ancient and has MANY versions (KJV for the win!!!), just understanding what's going on in a chapter, or heck, a VERSE, may take multiple readings. Even then, you might seriously consider attending a Seminary if you want to truly deepen your understanding.

I'm not trying to rag on converts, they are great people. But if you are starting at zero, and are now trying to preach, you just lack the experience in most cases. This redeemed Zoomer sounds like most cases.
 
1716579793973.png

New WIAH video, I kinda have my hands full with the Rekieta stuff, I might do a summary later
 
View attachment 6018233
New WIAH video, I kinda have my hands full with the Rekieta stuff, I might do a summary later
Its incredibly retarded, im about 15 minutes in and hes using a comparison with Britain as the jumping off point for the entire discussion. Rudy seems autistically obsessed with comparisons to the point he loses the plot entirely, studying a culture takes actually reading and studying their story as told from themselves. No mention of Confucianism, or religion/philosophy, the actual origin of the culture, just sweeping summaries of Japanese historical periods and comparisons to other countries half-way across the world. He doesn't even cite any books on Japan written by Japanese people.
 
Last edited:
Its incredibly retarded, im about 15 minutes in and hes using a comparison with Britain as the jumping off point for the entire discussion.
Fuck no, that was a meme talking point within right-wing anime Twitter like a year ago. Now we know why Rudie is the way he is, he's no incel, he's a Twitter DR zoomer without (most of) the weebshit that bought everything they said at face value
 
Its incredibly retarded, im about 15 minutes in and hes using a comparison with Britain as the jumping off point for the entire discussion. Rudy seems autistically obsessed with comparisons to the point he loses the plot entirely, studying a culture takes actually reading and studying their story as told from themselves. No mention of Confucianism, or religion/philosophy, the actual origin of the culture, just sweeping summaries of Japanese historical periods and comparisons to other countries half-way across the world. He doesn't even cite any books on Japan written by Japanese people.
That would require him to read any source that isn't from a Western author.
 
Back