Creepy Unsolved Mysteries - From unsolved murders to unidentified people to unexplained supernatural events, what are some of the creepiest unsolved mysteries you've ever heard of?

  • Agree
  • Like
  • DRINK!
Reactions: Fallow Tallow, UnsufficentBoobage, lurkin and 11 others
Timothy Troon said:
Has Jennifer kesse been mentioned ?

Vanished into thin air one morning, only one poi who is seen on cctv, but manages to be basically hidden by the fence he walks past after dropping her car off at a neighbouring housing complex.

Click to expand...
Seems clear to me that a beaner who was working at her complex raped and killed her. Since Jennifer’s death we’ve seen countless other spic-on-white girl killings similar to this.
 
  • Like
  • Informative
  • Agree
Reactions: Fanatical Pragmatist, Fallow Tallow, UnsufficentBoobage and 8 others
On September 22nd, 2000, Canadian truck driver Trevor Angell was transporting a shipment from Los Angeles to Calgary when he stopped at a bar and casino called Whiskey Pete's in Primm, Nevada. He last spoke to his dispatcher around 10:00 AM. He also called his wife and told her that it had been four days since he'd slept. That was the last time Trevor was heard from. What happened to him next remains a mystery over two decades later.

After Trevor failed to make contact with his employers, the company reported him missing on September 26th. His truck was found abandoned in Whiskey Pete's parking lot. Investigators uncovered Trevor's wallet inside the truck; it contained his driver's license and credit cards, but no cash was found. Someone using Trevor's bank card withdrew money nine times between September 22nd and 4:00 AM the following morning until his entire paycheck had been taken out, but it's unknown if it was Trevor himself or another person who made the withdrawals. A waitress at Whiskey Pete's told police that she served Trevor a bowl of oatmeal at 10:00 AM on September 23rd, six hours after the last withdrawal was made from his bank account. He paid for his breakfast with pocket change. Trevor was later seen in the parking lot, disoriented and clutching his stomach. Witnesses said he appeared to be ill and was asking for help.

Trevor's parents searched desperately for their son, but no sign of Trevor has ever been found. They claim that the trucking company Trevor worked for was unhelpful and told them that they believed Trevor had a gambling problem. Trevor supposedly enjoyed drinking and gambling and often stopped at casinos during his trips. Supposedly Trevor no longer wanted to work as a trucker and had planned to quit in order to spend more time with his wife and son.

There are numerous theories regarding Trevor's fate. The detective in charge of his case believes that Trevor chose to go missing, while others suspect that Trevor killed himself after gambling away all of his paycheck or that somebody at the casino harmed him. Violent crimes have taken place in Primm, including the murder of a seven-year-old girl at a casino near Whiskey Pete's.

Trevor's disappearance took yet another strange turn in 2010, when someone posted in Trevor's missing persons thread on the website MyDeathSpace. They claimed to be a man in a gay relationship with Trevor, and that Trevor had willfully abandoned his old life after committing a hit and run accident. He also posted a photo that he claimed was of himself and Trevor. MDS users determined the poster's real name and contacted law enforcement, and immediately afterwards the poster claimed to have made a mistake and that his boyfriend wasn't really Trevor after all.

Trevor's whereabouts remain unknown. His wife remarried and her husband adopted the son she shared with Trevor, but as of 2014 she still kept the same cellphone number she had when Trevor disappeared in case he should ever decide to call her.
 
  • Informative
  • Like
  • Feels
Reactions: madethistocomment, Fanatical Pragmatist, Fallow Tallow and 25 others
The Hardest R said:
Being up four days in a row, known as a gambler, and withdrew from the ATM multiple times makes me think he was a tweaker (many semi drivers are) who got into some shit with a meth dealer or just someone who was bad news in general and his body is buried at an unknown location in the desert.
Click to expand...
Degen gamblers will often go this pattern. They'll withdraw some fraction of what they have, deciding they'll just gamble a little, then lose all that. Then they'll start chasing their losses and keep withdrawing until it's all gone. Also maybe he got a bad batch, was borrowing money from the wrong people, or any possible number of ways people into sketchy shit end up dead.

The fact they didn't find a body seems to indicate someone got rid of it, though. Maybe a dealer who had sold him the bad batch noticed he was drawing attention, and offered to give him a ride. . .to a hole in the desert.
 
  • Thunk-Provoking
  • Like
  • Informative
Reactions: Neetness, Fanatical Pragmatist, rusty shackleford 1 and 16 others
Him being seen clutching his stomach reminded me of Blair Adams, a highly weird case featured on Unsolved Mysteries. Blair behaved very erratically and died after suffering a violent beating that resulted in an abdominal perforation. I wonder if Trevor was also dealt a catastrophic blow to the stomach like Blair and that's why he appeared ill and was asking for help. I couldn't find an answer regarding whether anyone actually helped him or not. If no one did, it could have been because he was behaving in an alarming way that caused others to keep their distance or because they saw something they didn't want to get involved in.
 
  • Thunk-Provoking
  • Informative
  • Like
Reactions: Fanatical Pragmatist, Fallow Tallow, Trombonista and 7 others
That area of the country is pretty interesting. You’ll see some random trailers in the middle of nowhere with a half mile path leading up to it, with a sign that says they’ll shoot any trespassers and you’re not going to want to test that theory. Everyone just minds their own business there, making it easy to bury a body out there, especially since there’s little or no traffic off the interstate because there’s no reason to go out in the middle of the desert. Would not be surprised if Angell’s body is out there, his definitely isn’t the only one.
 
  • Like
  • Informative
  • Agree
Reactions: Trombonista, AssistantWeasel, Botchy Galoop and 4 others
Per Trevor Angell: I remember when that seven-year-old girl was murdered in Primm. There was a national outcry about both the killing, and the (in)actions of the murder's friend David Cash Jr., who witnessed him attack the little girl and haul her into the restroom, but did nothing about it. Cash, who showed all the signs of being a sociopath, became a hated pariah at his university and elsewhere. I wonder where he is today.

The Hardest R said:
That area of the country is pretty interesting. You’ll see some random trailers in the middle of nowhere with a half mile path leading up to it, with a sign that says they’ll shoot any trespassers and you’re not going to want to test that theory. Everyone just minds their own business there, making it easy to bury a body out there, especially since there’s little or no traffic off the interstate because there’s no reason to go out in the middle of the desert. Would not be surprised if Angell’s body is out there, his definitely isn’t the only one.
Click to expand...
The Mob disposed of countless corpses out there back when they ran Vegas.
 
  • Horrifying
  • Informative
  • Agree
Reactions: lurkin, Pina Colada, Lowlife Adventures and 11 others
DavidFerrie said:
Per Trevor Angell: I remember when that seven-year-old girl was murdered in Primm. There was a national outcry about both the killing, and the (in)actions of the murder's friend David Cash Jr., who witnessed him attack the little girl and haul her into the restroom, but did nothing about it. Cash, who showed all the signs of being a sociopath, became a hated pariah at his university and elsewhere. I wonder where he is today.
Click to expand...
Christ, I had forgotten all about this case.
Two sociopaths.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: DavidFerrie
AnOminous said:
Based on irl Anthony "the Ant" Spilotro, who had personal knowledge, and also ended up in a hole, although his was in an Indiana cornfield.
Click to expand...

Joe Pesci looked nothing like Tommy DeSimone, the basis for his character in Goodfellas, but he was such a dead ringer for Spilotro that several longtime dealers and pitbosses had full-on panic attacks when they saw him in the casino, after assuming he'd been safely dead for years.
 
  • Informative
  • Like
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: Loris Yeltsin, Fallow Tallow, Truman the Jewman and 19 others
Mola Ram said:
Joe Pesci looked nothing like Tommy DeSimone, the basis for his character in Goodfellas, but he was such a dead ringer for Spilotro that several longtime dealers and pitbosses had full-on panic attacks when they saw him in the casino, after assuming he'd been safely dead for years.
Click to expand...
DeSimone was a physically large, chaotic thug with clear anti-social tendencies, which is why people were afraid of him and why he ended up wacked before he was 30. 5-foot-nothing middle-aged Joe Pesci was a complete miscast, especially since anyone could act the part.

It helps that Spilotro was already middle-aged by the time Casino takes place, where the casting of Pesci works better.
 
  • Thunk-Provoking
  • Informative
  • Like
Reactions: ShadowAngel785, John.Doe, LateNightMuffin and 3 others
McMitch said:
5-foot-nothing middle-aged Joe Pesci was a complete miscast, especially since anyone could act the part.
Click to expand...

I think it's unfair to say he was miscast when he managed to turn in one of the most iconic mafioso performances of all time. Goodfellas took a lot of liberties with both casting and facts. Just check out what Paul Vario really looked like some time and compare him to the avuncular Paul Sorvino: the real guy looked like the monster he was. And Billy Batts got whacked for way more reasons than badmouthing Tommy when he got out of prison.

EDIT: Just to keep things on topic, Tommy DeSimone's disappearance is officially unsolved. No one has ever been charged with his murder and his body has never been found. There are theories that he was dumped in one of the so-called "mafia cemeteries" that have been uncovered in the woollier parts of the outer boroughs, but there's no real evidence for it, and he theoretically could be anywhere. Personally, I've always wondered how many mob hits wound up in the Fresh Kills Landfill. That place was so enormous nothing could be found there after just a few weeks of regular garbage dropoffs.
 
Last edited:
  • Informative
  • Agree
  • Like
Reactions: Nurse Ratchet, John.Doe, Trombonista and 7 others
Mola Ram said:
Just check out what Paul Vario really looked like some time and compare him to the avuncular Paul Sorvino: the real guy looked like the monster he was.
Click to expand...
I mean Henry Hill was no Ray Liotta either.

But even with the liberties taken, I find Pesci playing DeVito to be too far fetched after having learned about DeSimone, and his portrayal isn’t anything beyond what any other actor can do.
 
  • Dumb
Reactions: ShadowAngel785
McMitch said:
5-foot-nothing middle-aged Joe Pesci was a complete miscast, especially since anyone could act the part.
Click to expand...
Bull, his ability to play the character was because of his ability to play an absolute psycho. I will refer back to his character in Scorsese's Raging Bull when he went utterly insane and slammed Salvy in a car door over and over again. There is no way you could have ever miscast Pesci in a role calling for insane violence. His midgetry even improves it.

And really, do we even need to go to Goodfellas?
 
  • Like
  • Agree
Reactions: Truman the Jewman, John.Doe, Trombonista and 10 others
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back