Phil doesn't want to share paypigs, the reason he's even entertaining the wrasslin' show idea is because he thinks he'll hook a few new kino whales.
Based on my rather limited observations of watching some Phil streams between July and December, both on the gaming and reacts, is that his paypigs are significantly less disruptive. Casino paypigs not only derail the show with shoutouts and Nerds On The Go/Destination Stone/whatever, but the whole negotiation about a) whether the paypig request is on the table at all, b) how many subs will be needed to make it happen. Not to mention pausing the show to offer paypigs the ability to skip or include content. Their live negotiations are worse than shoutouts. Phil has many issues, this isn't one of them. Of course, when you zoom out to extra wide lens and get Ashton in the frame, Ashton and his paypigs might import this nonsense with them, so even if the Phil paypigs don't do that whole back and forth bullshit, the Casino pigs that Ashton has in his copious back pocket will. Obviously Phil doesn't want to share his pigs, but I think that the sum donos they'd get together divided by two would be greater than what either could get individual. There is a symbiosis at play when Lard has a Tard, where the whole becomes larger than the individual sums. A + B = A + B + C, where C is some factor not only greater than zero, but greater than A+B. That said, if there is a hard and definitive split, neither is stealing the other's paypigs. Ashton's paypigs are Ashton loyalists, Phil's paypigs are Phil loyalists. I know which poison I'd pick if I were in PPP's shoes, but it really can be argued either way.
I agree that Phil is very poor at tech, but even his absolute minimal output beats Ashton's zero. Even if Phil is slow to accomplish the goal and takes an unnecessarily long way to get there, he's at least in motion, while Ashton is his usual sedentary self. Tardski is clearly better than both.
Added in edit: It occurred to me after I posted that Phil derails by begging to a far greater degree than Ashton or Andy. If I am going to factor in negotiation derails, I also have to factor in "Draw attention to the goal" derails. This weakens my previous thesis.
I'll admit I'm not just new to this forum but to the Kino Casino as well...but I've seen some of the classics on YouTube PPP's camera was a potato and he was in 144p like when YouTube is playing on the lowest quality.
I was a huge Casino fan until a few weeks after VegasGate. There are definitely aspects of the show I enjoyed and made me laugh. Learning about not only Metokur Masochist, but learning that there were several extreme perverts in their paypig cabal, I can no longer enjoy them, because they feel like a gift you later found out was purchased with blood money. Their Kick Chat will certainly go back and forth with you about what you find enjoyable about the show, but those of us here, whether former fan or never fan, really aren't going to share fondness for the show. At most, you'll see us say something that they could do better. I'll give you some time to ruminate on that.