No, because not only was Half-Life 2 available as a reasonable port for the original Xbox, Orange Box with Ep1&2 was also on 360 (ported by Valve & running fine, unlike the PS3 port they refused to do so EA handled it themselves - apparently Ep1 has moments of poor framerate & Ep2 is even worse on PS3) - they're also supported via backwards compatibility. Xbox version on 360 if you're that eccentric, 360 version on Xbox One.
EDIT: Also can't forget DSP's seeming addiction to achievements & trophies. I imagine a good chunk of his desire to do that Patrons' Choice 2nd playthrough of Fallout: New Vegas as hardcore with only melee weapons was so he could squeeze out those 2 big achievements on the 360 version.
This is the one I'd like to see win, mostly to hear his excuses when he realises it requires 3+ playthroughs to get the real ending. There was one chat regular who kept cheering pushing for Eternal Darkness before the nominations thread even came up, his cheering money won't get him his wish.