It's wrong, though, he was born in 1983. March 13 if he's telling the truth. I'm not sure what those Social Security results are, but often sites like that just base their results on the first 5 digits, and whether those blocks of 4 have actually been used, not whether the specific SSN in question has been.
There are a number of reasons your results might have incorrect results for where it was issued or when it was issued.
And it's possible his SSN was issued some time after he was born. It's more common for older people but certainly happens to this day.
It does raise some questions considering Ron Toye has a history of threatening people involved in litigation with him with extreme acts of physical violence to try to influence those court proceedings.