- Joined
- Sep 20, 2018
That Hallmark article has me Mad at the Internet, so I thought KF would appriciate me sperging about why the author doesn't know shit about fascism.
First things first: You need to know that canonically, fascism doesn't give a shit about "normality". This is important becausue the author mistakenly believes this to be a part of the "platonic ideal" of fascism, and draws a lot of bad conclusions from this point. As a social structure, the ideology places a lot of value on duty, embracing conflict, dying well, believing in some sort of higher power, educating people for their chosen role in life, and most of all: complete and utter subservience to the nation and its governing body over yourself.
* Only about 15 percent of Nazi films were propaganda, but they were the big budget blockbusters, by and large
* Hitler and Goebbels were film fans, and Goebbels reviewed most films that made it to release
* Neither article talks about normalcy at all as a narrative the movies were pushing
* The movies were a place that the common man often went to get the correct answers to political questions, so that he didn't accidentally speak out of turn of the third reich
Jesus Christ this nonsense is poorly thought out. Fascism isn't just "the stuff that the people I don't like believe". It's also not "stuff that promotes white people". These article writers need to pick up a book.
First things first: You need to know that canonically, fascism doesn't give a shit about "normality". This is important becausue the author mistakenly believes this to be a part of the "platonic ideal" of fascism, and draws a lot of bad conclusions from this point. As a social structure, the ideology places a lot of value on duty, embracing conflict, dying well, believing in some sort of higher power, educating people for their chosen role in life, and most of all: complete and utter subservience to the nation and its governing body over yourself.
Has nothing to do with the doctrine. A multicultural state can be fascist.Running down this year's schedule of Christmas movie offerings is like a trip into an uncanny valley of shiny-teethed, blow-dried heteronormative whiteness, with only a few token movies with characters of color.
The author ignores pretty much the two articles she cites here from Nazi Film and Propaganda experts, in order to take literally one sentence out of the whole article for this hot take on "Normalcy". The article is really interesting though, and here are some valuable takeaways for those interested in the subject:That is probably a startling statement to some. When most of us think about fascistically propagandistic movies, we think of the grotesque grandeur of Leni Riefenstahl's films celebrating the Third Reich — grand, but cold sweeping shots of soldiers goose-stepping and flags waving, all meant to inspire awe and terror. But the reality is, even in Nazi Germany, the majority of movies approved by the Nazi minister of propaganda, Joseph Goebbels, were escapist and feather-light, with a Hallmark movie-style emphasis on the importance of "normality."
* Only about 15 percent of Nazi films were propaganda, but they were the big budget blockbusters, by and large
* Hitler and Goebbels were film fans, and Goebbels reviewed most films that made it to release
* Neither article talks about normalcy at all as a narrative the movies were pushing
* The movies were a place that the common man often went to get the correct answers to political questions, so that he didn't accidentally speak out of turn of the third reich
Focus on God's chosen aside, this is actually a fair point, if the author's depiction is accurate. That said the author goes on to scold the minority ideas of white nationalism and anti-cosmopolitanism a couple of sentences later, so this is really a case of "ideological freedom is important (but only if I don't like the ideology)""In the Hallmark-Lifetime Cinematic Universe, Hanukkah and the characters who celebrate it exist only in relation to Christmas," Nancy Coleman of th New York Times complained, adding that the Hallmark movie "Holiday Date" could, with "remarkably little editing" turn into "a Jewish 'Get Out.'"
Britni de la Cretaz, writing for the Washington Post, not only complained that the Jewish Hallmark movies were "Christmas movies with Jewish characters," but also that the movies "rely on some of the oldest anti-Semitic tropes in the book," such as painting one Jewish character as the "perpetual outsider" who is "sneaky, untrustworthy."
"The drama hinges on Jewish characters being compelled to observe Christmas, and the tension resolves only when these outsiders learn how to participate in or appreciate the dominant religious tradition," she adds.
Sadly, it's hard to imagine it being any other way. The qualities that people cite when they defend Hallmark movies — comforting, formulaic, soothing — are all a result of the aggressively conformist impulse that drives them. And that impulse and fealty to the dominant culture stands in direct contrast to the values of diversity Hallmark facetiously claims to hold."
I've reread this section a half a dozen times, and I can't squeeze a cogent message out of it? It honestly feels like Amanda Marcotte just wanted to take a break to let you know that Hans Fiene is a bad man because when he says christians he means white people, and when he says sexual deviants he really means the gays."If you don't believe me, listen to authoritarians themselves. At the Federalist, which is ground zero website for generating frankly fascist "culture war" arguments, Hans Fiene argues that, "culturally speaking, Hallmark Christmas movies are noticeably Christian."
By this, Fiene isn't talking about characters who actually go to church or pray — even self-identified conservative Christians don't want to see that — but a set of patriarchal and authoritarian values that are more about white evangelicals defining themselves as an ethnic group, and not about a genuine feeling of spirituality.
The movies always depict a "heroine who begins the story loving her self-involved life in the city chooses family and a life of self-sacrifice in her hometown," he writes, arguing that it's the "last remaining hideout" for those who want a fantasy of a world where "the cynicism and immorality of modern life aren’t allowed." By "cynicism and immmorality," Fiene explains he's talking about "fornication" and acceptance of "sexual deviants," by which he means LGBTQ people."
*How to date your article in one easy step*"I've got my own flavors of trashy entertainment I fully enjoy without mistaking it for high art. (Baby Yoda, what's up?)"
'Susan told me not to be a grinch after I turned Hallmark off while mom what watching it. What a fascist.'"Still, it's critical to be mindful of the role that Hallmark movies are actually playing in our society. The very fact that they're presented as harmless fluff makes it all the more insidious, the way they work to enforce very narrow, white, heteronormative, sexist, provincial ideas of what constitutes "normal."
It's easy to spot fascist propaganda when it's goose-stepping Pepe-the-frog memes. It's a lot harder to notice how it's working when it's tied up in Christmas cheer and suggesting grinchhood of anyone who questions the rigidity of its worldview."
And we end on the sentiment that not liking gays is fascism. It isn't, and fascist Italy & Germany didn't even harbor an abnormal amount of disgust for homosexuals versus similar nations, fascists are just more proactive and punitive when it comes to punishing crimes, including sex crimes."So many people feel betrayed because this is one of the very last channels that families could go to and not be bombarded with politically correct commercials and the LGBTQ agenda," the American Family Association griped in a press release.
Note that the language is solely that of exclusion. This isn't about Christian conservatives wanting more Hallmark movies that show characters who actually go to church or anything like that. What makes something "family friendly" and "Christian" is who is not allowed inside the fantasy land of impossibly expensive rural houses and women who are realizing that they wanted to just get married to the boy next door all along."
Jesus Christ this nonsense is poorly thought out. Fascism isn't just "the stuff that the people I don't like believe". It's also not "stuff that promotes white people". These article writers need to pick up a book.