- Joined
- Nov 4, 2017
Speaking of the prequels, I have a question. Everyone is always saying they would've been much better if someone had had the guts to tell George what he was doing wrong...But, could they?
I mean, Are we sure George wouldn't have just fired anyone that questioned in the spot?
Sure, before Lucas became famous, the OT trilogy cast did tell him his dialogue sucked when they thought the Star Wars would be a forgettable sci-fi movie, and once they became irreplaceable, and his famous friends like Spielberg also didn't have trouble telling him. They were his equals after all.
But during the prequels, who could've told him? Was he even open to criticism or did he fire anyone that questioned him?
Honest question. I don't know.
I think when they say that (or at least when I say it) they/I am envisioning someone Lucas is somewhat accountable to and can't just summarily fire or dismiss off hand. He just needs a handler, a Lucas-to-Actual-Person translator.
The OT cast got away with stepping to Lucas the first movie because Lucas had no budget and was in a little over his head, scrambling. He couldn't go around firing people, and even if he did, he didn't carry too much water in hollywood at the time; your career wasn't going to be seriously and lastingly harmed. After the movie was a huge hit, Harrison Ford could freely tell Lucas his script fucking sucked for the next two movies - what was Lucas going to do, recast his most popular character*?
For the PT, Lucas had unlimited time and budget. He answered only to himself, and he had considerable pull and connections via Spielberg. Stepping to Lucas would have come with potentially serious repercussions.
His most seasoned actors were mostly side characters; Samuel L. Jackson didn't have any cringe lines. Ian had some....bizarre.... lines but worked them. So its entirely possible they had dialogue just as attrocious, but talked to Lucas and got it changed (or just adlibed)
Add to that Lucas kept changing actors for Anakin. For Phantom Menace it was a young boy. As fucking epic as it would have been for pre-voice change Jake Lloyd to have told Lucas his script blows ass, no one is going to expect a kid to do anything other than read what they're given.
*Sorry Luke/Mark, you know its true.