Anthony Fantano / TheNeedleDrop - "The Internet's Busiest Music Nerd"™, heelturned since 2017, slowly becoming smug SJW, threw Sam Hyde under the bus

I remember the Fiona Apple thing. What happened what he tried to explain the meaning of Fiona lyrics and some of her hardcore fans (they are truly fanatical) corrected him and he said “YOU SOUND LIKE TERFS. TRANS WOMEN ARE WOMEN!!!” It was bizarre and a weird flex to belittle his female followers and literally nothing was said about trans women. I think they implied that Fiona’s music was targeted to females which triggered Fantano, lmao.
Could you explain the rest of the lore to this? I feel like I'm missing something.
 
I remember 1791l made a video on Fantano. I can’t find the first video 1791l made on Fantano that got Anthony mad (was is deleted or am I just shit at finding stuff). It was something with Noam Chomsky and that Fantano talks about the original video in question on his live stream around 2018. 1791 made this video showing Anthony Fantano’s response to the original video.


Fantano responds without actually watching the video.
 
I remember 1791l made a video on Fantano. I can’t find the first video 1791l made on Fantano that got Anthony mad (was is deleted or am I just shit at finding stuff). It was something with Noam Chomsky and that Fantano talks about the original video in question on his live stream around 2018. 1791 made this video showing Anthony Fantano’s response to the original video.


Fantano responds without actually watching the video.
Unrelated, but I really miss 1791L's content. That's a great channel and I hope they come back to make more stuff (the channel is still up at least).
 
I think he looks a bit like vordrak.
He’s definitely a faggot like sam, maybe that’s where I see the resemblance.
 
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: rotollo
-His MCN is complex media. Home of HotOnes and that celebrity shoe shopping shit. I’m not accusing him of payola, he doesn’t need someone to to pay him for good reviews he has an affiliate link on amazon for his popular album reviews. So it’s technically not Payola. Maybe that’s why Billie Eilish and Ariana Grande gets an 8 for some reason. I think it’s also because Robert Christgau shat on him for not having more women on his best of I think.
lmao, for real? He should have listened to Sonic Youth about that:
"I don't know why
You wanna impress Christgau
Ah let that shit die
And find out the new goal"
Really, just stop listening to critics. Who cares? Make your taste yourself. Tired of Fantanodrones shitting up RYM and /mu/.
 
lmao, for real? He should have listened to Sonic Youth about that:
"I don't know why
You wanna impress Christgau
Ah let that shit die
And find out the new goal"
Really, just stop listening to critics. Who cares? Make your taste yourself. Tired of Fantanodrones shitting up RYM and /mu/.
Christgau sucks. He’s funny sometimes but he tries too hard with his taste. Look at how many albums from Africa he always puts in his Pazz and Jop polls. What a fake. I’m not a huge fan of RYM tbh. I used to use it for catalog reasons. It’s pretty good for that.

I should have mention this first


[Q] It seems like Anthony Fantano's by far the most discussed music reviewer on the internet these days. Have you watched any of his reviews. Do you think he's a good critic? -- David Springer, Fairfax, Virginia

[A] I don't "watch" reviews. I read writing. When I'm at the computer I almost never click on links to podcasts or televised news much less criticism, for two reasons--first, reading is faster than listening, and second, I'm continually using my ears to listen to music. Moreover, no one I know "discusses" Anthony Fantano, a name I barely recognized. Glancing over his Wikipedia entry he seems to have arrived at a plausible brand of 21st-century rockcrit taste that runs toward what I'll call dark prog--the godfathering Swans, this year's number one Daughters, on the rap end his beloved Death Grips. But clearly he's broader than that. Little apparent interest in the pop end or indeed tune or indeed fun, however--always a tragic and psychologically revealing lacuna. Nowhere near as insensible to hip-hop/r&b as dark proggers tend to be, but note that very few female artists crack his top 10s, which in 2018 was really missing the action. Fantano seems to have figured out a way to make some kind of living by disseminating his own criticism in the online age. That's an achievement. But until he starts putting it in written language, I'll live without.
 
I just remembered this video from over a year and a half ago:
8:13-12:50

It’s kind of an interesting retrospective, given how Anthony was showing some of those early signs of tweeting or discussing political topics in an inflammatory manner. Guess things only managed to get a lot worse since then.
 
I just remembered this video from over a year and a half ago:
8:13-12:50

It’s kind of an interesting retrospective, given how Anthony was showing some of those early signs of tweeting or discussing political topics in an inflammatory manner. Guess things only managed to get a lot worse since then.
I remember thinking Tom was being a bit alarmist back then, that Fantano wasn't that bad. I was wrong to doubt him, apparently.
 
Could you explain the rest of the lore to this? I feel like I'm missing something.
found the tweet lmao. Unfortunately I don’t remember what exactly the comment he was responding to said except something along of lines of he just couldn’t relate to a female experience Fiona wrote about in her song “For Her” (I mean, it is in the title) and that he misinterpreted the lyrics. It was admittedly a bit MOTI, but the poster said nothing about trans women. I’m a big Fiona fan so it stuck out to me. Just a retarded response from a person who has no rebuttal.
EBD937A3-A08A-4F9F-A636-2C29307FADD2.jpeg
3CA10004-80DC-45A0-BAC9-B06D8049F1DD.jpeg
 
found the tweet lmao. Unfortunately I don’t remember what exactly the comment he was responding to said except something along of lines of he just couldn’t relate to a female experience Fiona wrote about in her song “For Her” (I mean, it is in the title) and that he misinterpreted the lyrics. It was admittedly a bit MOTI, but the poster said nothing about trans women. I’m a big Fiona fan so it stuck out to me. Just a retarded response from a person who has no rebuttal.
View attachment 1442423
View attachment 1442427
I think it was a YouTube comment was screenshot in that unavailable tweet. 4chan had all of the screenshots from that day.

kinda related, but I can’t find that brave soldier tweet he made awhile back that was posted on/mu/ a lot
 
found the tweet lmao. Unfortunately I don’t remember what exactly the comment he was responding to said except something along of lines of he just couldn’t relate to a female experience Fiona wrote about in her song “For Her” (I mean, it is in the title) and that he misinterpreted the lyrics. It was admittedly a bit MOTI, but the poster said nothing about trans women. I’m a big Fiona fan so it stuck out to me. Just a retarded response from a person who has no rebuttal.
View attachment 1442423
View attachment 1442427
I like how his fans are owning him in all his comments. He must hate that.
 
found the tweet lmao. Unfortunately I don’t remember what exactly the comment he was responding to said except something along of lines of he just couldn’t relate to a female experience Fiona wrote about in her song “For Her” (I mean, it is in the title) and that he misinterpreted the lyrics. It was admittedly a bit MOTI, but the poster said nothing about trans women. I’m a big Fiona fan so it stuck out to me. Just a retarded response from a person who has no rebuttal.
View attachment 1442423
View attachment 1442427
Each time a woman disagrees with me, I'll call them TERF instead of "useless bitch" and "dumb slut". You guys are making fun of him, but I think he cracked the code.
 
He used pander to people on 4chan and Reddit. Now he panders to white liberals on Twitter and Reddit. Either way, it’s cringe.
I think this is the #1 thing I hate about this guy, it seems like he doesn't even totally buy into the stuff he's arguing. He just knows it's good for his career to suck up to the twitter wokescolds and punch down on low-hanging fruit that it's socially encouraged to bully ("terfs," incels, etc). When/if intersectionality goes out of style, he'll jump ship and can all the far-left talking points. Such a weasel
 
As much as I respect Anthony's musical tastes he said Pretty Fly for a White Guy is a bad song which is the worst take I've ever heard.
I'd say Fantano is light on the cow spectrum? At least most of his stupid political takes aren't in his videos. He does deserve a thread for his godawful twitter and hypocritical nature.
Rated optimistic because more than one thread had this kind of messages in the beginning
 
Back