- Joined
- Feb 19, 2017
Internet ‘traditionalists’ are largely Catholics (or pretending to be), and while Catholics have certainly been part of the Religious Right, such as on abortion, the movement was largely Evangelical Protestants. Tradcaths are also more likely to be vaguely economically left wing.
Actual religious conservative beliefs are not popular, outside of abortion. Americans want legal booze, legal weed, legal porn, and casual sex. The working class is only socially conservative relative to wokies. When 70% of Americans without a college degree* have at least one child out of wedlock, they cannot be meaningfully described as socially conservative.
*I realize this doesn’t perfectly align with ‘working class’, but it’s what everyone else uses.
True, I have noted many times that the traditionalist faggots are mostly Catholic Zoomers while the OG Religious Right from the 80's and 90's were Evangelical Protestants, and I honestly think that part of why so many Zoomers went to Catholicism as opposed to Protestantism is because of the old Religious Right and its failures.
Even traditionalist Catholicism is less austere than the traditionalist Evangelical Protestants (who tend to lean in a Calvinist, Pentecostal, or conservative Baptist direction) and Catholicism has a stronger historical tradition in Western Civilization, with the Anglosphere being the one major exception where Protestantism was the norm. Plus, the Catholic Church tends to accept the theory of evolution as opposed to Young Earth Creationism and isn't as outwardly anti-science or redneck-adjacent as the Evangelical Protestants were. So that is a plus in the eyes of the Gen Z Right.
I wouldn't be surprised if some of the "fundies are bad like SJW's" rhetoric of the early 2014-2016 counterculture rubbed off on the Core Zoomers and that's why they gravitate towards Catholic instead of Protestant Christianity, since even the traditionalist and conservative Roman Catholics stayed out of the last culture war (Liberals and Libertarians vs. Religious Right and Neocons) for the most part and only stepped in to back the Religious Right on a few issues like abortion. The anti-Catholic lunacy of Jack Chick and WBC may also have played a small role in this as well.