Inactive Nick Bate / Nickalaus B. Stoutzenberger (Thread 2: THE RECKONING)

Status
Not open for further replies.
The "mudplay" video transcript (aproximate)

you are the most brave person i have ever encountered. i say this because i assume to transcript, you had to rewind/watch it a few times. you are very brave.

he took the job knowing he'd have to represent some guilty as hell people who'd done disgusting shit, but Nick probably makes him want to take a decontamination shower.
i don't think anyone signs up to become a lawyer thinking, "i can defend a pedophile who willingly smears his own bodily fluids on his wall".
 
you are the most brave person i have ever encountered. i say this because i assume to transcript, you had to rewind/watch it a few times. you are very brave.


i don't think anyone signs up to become a lawyer thinking, "i can defend a pedophile who willingly smears his own bodily fluids on his wall".
the concept is beyond most people's understanding. I mean there are some things so sick that you think, surely no can be that stupid/disgusting/etc. And then when you come across you just start thinking, "WHY?" Then when you think you hit rock bottom and we come across...this. Well, I leave it to the Nostalgia critic to take things from here

This is when we get out the brandy and proceed to drink ourselves into oblivion.
 
and hearing all the..splashing

Gah!

Two questions for the Kiwi legal department:

The docket sheet says "Public Defender Requested by the Defendant? -- No"

Does this mean he's got his own lawyer, or that he's just flat refusing representation?

The docket sheet says"Has the Defendant Been Fingerprinted? -- No"

Is it normal to not take his prints? Seems like you'd want his prints for investigations and stuff.
 
Two questions for the Kiwi legal department:

The docket sheet says "Public Defender Requested by the Defendant? -- No"

Does this mean he's got his own lawyer, or that he's just flat refusing representation?

The docket sheet says"Has the Defendant Been Fingerprinted? -- No"

Is it normal to not take his prints? Seems like you'd want his prints for investigations and stuff.

I think you can request one but if you don't, one gets assigned. If you go further down on the docket, you see that one has been assigned.
 
Two questions for the Kiwi legal department:

The docket sheet says "Public Defender Requested by the Defendant? -- No"

Does this mean he's got his own lawyer, or that he's just flat refusing representation?

Counsel is listed on the docket sheet by name, so I'd assume he actually has a representative. Whether he's actually conferred with counsel about anything yet, I don't know.

I'm not sure whether it's actually meaningful that it says "no" to the requested thing. For all I know, it's in error about that. Or it's only there for some situation where whether he gets counsel is actually questionable, like a minor infraction.
 
The "mudplay" video transcript (aproximate)

"Hey. This is Nick Stoutzenberger, better known as Nick Bate. Erm, I'm filming this video because I've been accused of sexually assaulting my sister, and this is me trying to prove that I didn't. Erm, part of the reason that I think err they think I did it, is because of this chat-log err that surfaced where I told my friend that I did, erm molest my sister, erm and I even though I came out multiple times to say this is a lie and that I actually didn't, err they nobody believed me, but erm one thing erm that I can prove was definitely a lie in the chat log is that erm I mentioned in it that I didn't do anal with her because err she had faeces on her butt, and erm everybody knows that I'm a coprophiliac so this wouldn't have stopped me, if I were to molest somebody I definitely would have done anal, no matter what. And I can prove that I'm a coprophiliac because... <camera spins> here is my toilet in which I have just defecated <view of Nick's toilet with faeces in the water> As you can see, erm and I'm going to touch the faeces and masturbate with it. So, erm, I don't know to how set up <Nick places the camera on the floor, in full view of the toilet> As you can see <Nick shows his unsoiled hand to the camera> my hand is clean. Okay, there's nothing on it <Nick's left-hand dives into the toilet> And now, I'm holding the faeces. Can you see it? <Nick shows his soiled hand to the camera, with faeces dripping onto the floor> Okay so, <Nick unbuckles his trousers > I'm undoing my pants <Trousers are pulled down and Nick sits on the toilet, his legs are open and showing his very small penis. A close-up as he shows the soiled hand to the camera, and smothers faeces on his foreskin and rest of his penis.> So now it's all over my penis, I hope you can see it. <Nick picks up the camera from the floor to show that he has smothered his privates in faeces. A close-up of his soiled genitals, and then places the camera back on the floor.> Erm, it was requested that I film myself actually masturbating, I'm not really err, I'm not really aroused right now too much, erm ever since I've started on my medication erm I haven't been able to masturbate on demand, so yeah, so erm anyway hopefully this will prove that I'm a coprophiliac and that this is proof enough that I couldn't have molested my sister because of err you know, faeces wouldn't have stopped me from doing anal. Err okay! That about wraps up my video. Thanks."
Dipper scream.gif


What the FUCK did I just read?
 
That's another reason. There are really a nearly unlimited number of arguments for admissibility. Another is that even making the video at all demonstrated consciousness of guilt.

Why it wouldn't be admissible, that is, be prejudicial, is the improper inference that Nick is a bad person with the propensity to do disgusting things, so he therefore probably committed this crime.

So if this actually gets in front of the trier of fact, it will probably be with a jury instruction to use it for only the proper purpose, i.e. that it shows he specifically remembers details of the offense that only the perpetrator would know, and not the improper purpose, i.e., that Nick is a disgusting sick fuck who should be locked up just on general principle whether or not he's even guilty of this particular crime.

The jury will duly note this, conscientiously try their best not to let it affect their decision, and then conclude that Nick is a disgusting sick fuck who should be locked up etc.

Which is why the prosecutor would want it in, whatever claims are actually made to get it in.


It would be somewhat ironic that something he made to prove his innocence (in his own, twisted mind) would end up contributing to having him found guilty. I was wondering if his own lawyer might use it if he went for the Not Guilty by reason of mental defect. "See, this guy obviously isn't right in the head and this is part of the reason."
 
Maybe they're just having a hard time finding somebody willing to print Mr. Shitty Digits. Understandable.
It might just be that this investigation will require basically zero forensics. Having his fingerprints on file wouldn't necessarily help convict him. They may just not bother until he is convicted.
 
Maybe we should pitch in and get Nick this poster he can hang in his cell.
186.jpg

In best Schwarzenegger Conan voice when he falls in tomb after being set free: "Crrrruuuuuuuummmmmbbbbbbbbbbb!!!!!!!"

It has problems loading for connections outside of the U.S. It just times out after a minute or so.

Working for me currently in Canada.
 
I preface my comments that I am Canadian.
The docket sheet says "Public Defender Requested by the Defendant? -- No"

Does this mean he's got his own lawyer, or that he's just flat refusing representation?

I think that means he didn't ask for a PD, so one was appointed. He is named in the docket sheet.

The docket sheet says"Has the Defendant Been Fingerprinted? -- No"

Is it normal to not take his prints? Seems like you'd want his prints for investigations and stuff.

It is strange no prints taken. My guess is that Nick's hands are bagged so he can't smear shit.

But yeah, odd that one. In Canada you are usually fingerprinted as soon as you are booked in to the copshop.

Still won't load for me.

Give me a sec, I will cap and post for you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back