- Joined
- Dec 6, 2020
True, but the problem was that:Ehhhhh. Britain had their hands full with Germany. The US Navy was a more pressing problem; that's where the whole "bomb Pearl Harbor to get enough breathing room to capture forward bases, and make taking them back so expensive as to negotiate decent peace terms" plan came from.
Really, if FDR hadn't been so anxious to provoke a war with Japan, I think they'd still be just fighting the Chinese by the time the UK and USSR, with US supplies if not troops, ground Hitler into dust.
Then maybe you end up with a China divided between Communist and "Democratic" spheres, with Imperial Japan "protecting" "Free China," and the Soviets treating a much-diminished Communist China as a satellite along the lines of Romania or Mongolia?
I need to plug these values into HOI3 and see what the scientific answer would be.
• the Co-Prosperity Sphere required territories that were French (Vietnam), British (Malaya, Hong Kong and maybe some bits of India) and American (Hawaii and the Phillipines) to work
• Britain and America wouldn't just give their colonies up
• the American and British navies could, combined, defeat the IJN.
Japan was never going to be able to defeat America and Britain, and should have either tried to pick Britain off first before doing anything along the lines of Pearl Harbour and bringing America into the war.
I honestly doubt that America would have joined in the war without a casus belli on the scale of Pearl Harbour anyways, but this isn't a history sperging thread and so I'll end the conversation here.