YouTube Historians/HistoryTube/PopHistory

TIK is fantastic, though can be at times abit of a lolbert, you can tell that he's extremely passionate about WW2 history and his breakdown of the Barbarossa Campaign is great. His video about the difference between National Socialism and Fascism is also rather decent.
I thought it was funny that he got famous for videos bashing the Third Reich for being a shit system, just to have some very vocal former viewers attack him when he revealed he believed Germany's problems stemmed from its socialist doctrine, and that the Soviets were having the exact same issues, and had to be bailed out with lend lease
 
I thought it was funny that he got famous for videos bashing the Third Reich for being a shit system, just to have some very vocal former viewers attack him when he revealed he believed Germany's problems stemmed from its socialist doctrine, and that the Soviets were having the exact same issues, and had to be bailed out with lend lease
Communism has a hell of a PR department
 

Ezekial is a fun History youtuber. Very Jewish and proud of it which is interesting.

Cynical Historian seems genuinely unhinged, he talked about how he conceal carries all the time because he's constantly paranoid a youtube commenter is going to come to his house and shoot him for being a sped.
A reporter who met the original Sandino said that the man was an "odd omelette of ideas". I think the term applies to CH.

Extremely pro-gun
Basically a Breadtuber as far as wealth redistribution goes
Points out woke bullshit like the 1619 Project, and "War for oil" meme.
Points out rightist nonsense like the 1776 Project
Supports government censorship (Death of Stalin video - outright believes in the state censoring films for bad history)
Liberally calls people right of Bernie a Nazi/reactionary for normal opinions
Believes Gamergate caused Trump

Just bizarre.

I thought it was funny that he got famous for videos bashing the Third Reich for being a shit system, just to have some very vocal former viewers attack him when he revealed he believed Germany's problems stemmed from its socialist doctrine, and that the Soviets were having the exact same issues, and had to be bailed out with lend lease
TIK is fantastic, though can be at times abit of a lolbert, you can tell that he's extremely passionate about WW2 history and his breakdown of the Barbarossa Campaign is great. His video about the difference between National Socialism and Fascism is also rather decent.
He built up an audience of Breadtube people and Tankies with his Soviet stuff. Then he basically revealed himself to be an Ayn Rand loving Libertarian. Its just funny.
 
Extremely pro-gun
Basically a Breadtuber as far as wealth redistribution goes
Points out woke bullshit like the 1619 Project, and "War for oil" meme.
Points out rightist nonsense like the 1776 Project
Supports government censorship (Death of Stalin video - outright believes in the state censoring films for bad history)
Liberally calls people right of Bernie a Nazi/reactionary for normal opinions
Believes Gamergate caused Trump
based soy schizo
 

I kind of wanted to talk on this thread but I was business, and all the info basically guys cam faster with.

But, I wanna talk about Dovahhatty's view on Islam, this video doesn't talk about it whatsoever until the end. He always was fearful of expressing his "meme" opinion on Islam. He kind of expresses that the Muslims are going to hate the next video, due to the Caliphate. I am guessing he is going display them as Satanists (Side note: he did it with the Germans, Persians and etc.) or whatever. Even though that Islam hates Satan as well with his tricks. I think the satanic joke is a little over used, but that just might me as well.

I also wanna talk about my opinion on his opinion (and maybe some predictions, etc.). I am guessing that his views on Islam (Coming from a who panders to Jews within his discord server and fear from his yt getting taken or whatever.) are badly vague. I don't hate Islam because most of it seems like Christianity. And views on the Caliphate might be bad (because he likes the romans, Christianity). It could be that he's doing it for the meme or personal hatred, but it's mostly like a meme thing.

My opinion on the Caliphate is they attacked Byzantium and Persia at a Calculated time and then spread Islam quickly through those newly gained land like Syria, Egypt and other parts. I think Dovahhatty is going to make them "evil" and """"""satanic"""""" by displaying Saint Peter's cross on the head, forearms and etc. I know he is biased but it seems will do the same imagery onto the next people attacking Byzantium. Or making them into silly wojaks that are braindead like the Slavs.

I personally don't hate his content but it is becoming somewhat of him making his moves work out, because the only way hes doing this is pandering. I don't hate his content somewhat but besides pushing troon shit on his videos and other weird things.
I wonder of Dovahhatty will take a middle ground (If he actually does do a Muslim series) and simply portray Muhamut (PBUH) as some hideous abomination who's true form can't be deciphered, as well as the later Caliphs.
Such as his recent video on the Confederate Submarine which literally has the same General Sherman, slavery, etc jokes you would see said on R/History or whatever. He even managed to make the topic of the Submarine so boring, like he does with everything he talks about.
PH might be my most hated Historytuber for this point alone. I don't care much for unciting shit etc, that's pretty much the standard for history channels as a whole, but it's his over usage of reddit memes and trying too hard to be like some of those channels that document people like Killdozer who don' actually throw jokes everywhere they possibly can.
Lastly I’ve seen the retards of his community go after people such as Mark Felton who is a actual qualified historian. They accuse him of plagiarism to being a Nazi for literally no reason. I don’t even understand how or why they’d hate him, perhaps not spouting over and over about their Unfunny jokes about Wehraboos, the German army, etc. I don’t even see the reason for accusing him of being Nazi since All his videos clearly denounce what they did. Now yes Felton has his issues as in not citing sources and so on but I’d rather watch his shit than Potential History.
From my understanding most of the hate for Felton is because he doesn't routinely denounce Nazis every 5 seconds or spends half the video on Himmler's shoe size or some autistic WW2 topic explaining how bad the Nazis were.
Was watching ReligionForBreakfast yesterday. You couldn't tell it from its name, but it's basically a religious history channel. Pretty not biased and interesting content.
Used to watch UsefulCharts too. It's run by some jewish convert dude. Lot's of interesting stuff there too.
USefulCharts has let on a little of his past. I like most of his content but the guy has had a weird life starting with being born into British Israelism.
\
A reporter who met the original Sandino said that the man was an "odd omelette of ideas". I think the term applies to CH.

Extremely pro-gun
Basically a Breadtuber as far as wealth redistribution goes
Points out woke bullshit like the 1619 Project, and "War for oil" meme.
Points out rightist nonsense like the 1776 Project
Supports government censorship (Death of Stalin video - outright believes in the state censoring films for bad history)
Liberally calls people right of Bernie a Nazi/reactionary for normal opinions
Believes Gamergate caused Trump

Just bizarre.
Someone get Cynical his meds.
He built up an audience of Breadtube people and Tankies with his Soviet stuff. Then he basically revealed himself to be an Ayn Rand loving Libertarian. Its just funny.
Absolutely based.
 
USefulCharts has let on a little of his past. I like most of his content but the guy has had a weird life starting with being born into British Israelism.
I though he was raised by Christian fundamentalists. I know for a fact he's a convert to Judaism now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: No. 7 cat
I just watched a pretty good video on ww2 German vets turned to Mercs after the war. The video was good even though the author's accent is quite thick.
Also I didn't know Youtube Europe is now forcing people to give there ID and Credit Card to watch 18+ videos.
 
I just watched a pretty good video on ww2 German vets turned to Mercs after the war. The video was good even though the author's accent is quite thick.
Also I didn't know Youtube Europe is now forcing people to give there ID and Credit Card to watch 18+ videos.
The French Foreign Legion got so German after the war that it has influenced it even up to the modern day
I'm honestly baffled there haven't been demands for denazification considering how popular that has been in Europe for the last few decades
 
Potential failure
View attachment 2287209

Conservatives tend to be more business oriented. Armchair Historian and AlternateHistoryHub are very conservative, and also treat their channels more like businesses. History isn't usually something you do for the money.
AHH
Created this video
He says idea came to him from Tigerstar.

Entire thing sounds like Reddit Leftist fantasy/alt history.

In Italy in 1948 socialist coalition lead by Commies wins election.
CIA does a thing and like 60% of Italian territory breaks away peacefuly And creates west alligned south.
South becomes failed Mafia run state while USA doesnt care anymore and rest of Western Europe doesnt exist.

North refuses to bend over to massa Stalin . And creates successful Commie regime. While being isolated.
Because they owned most of Italian industry , because Commies didnt fuck up industrialized country before.... Cough North Korea cough Czechoslovakia.

North in 1980/90 transforms into democratic socialist state unites Italy and legitimizes Communism as viable ideology.
Lol
 
Potential failure

AHH
Created this video
He says idea came to him from Tigerstar.

Entire thing sounds like Reddit Leftist fantasy/alt history.

In Italy in 1948 socialist coalition lead by Commies wins election.
CIA does a thing and like 60% of Italian territory breaks away peacefuly And creates west alligned south.
South becomes failed Mafia run state while USA doesnt care anymore and rest of Western Europe doesnt exist.

North refuses to bend over to massa Stalin . And creates successful Commie regime. While being isolated.
Because they owned most of Italian industry , because Commies didnt fuck up industrialized country before.... Cough North Korea cough Czechoslovakia.

North in 1980/90 transforms into democratic socialist state unites Italy and legitimizes Communism as viable ideology.
Lol
I've honestly lost faith in his recent videos, as they've become boring and questionable at best. This latest video on Italy was just awful and I had trouble finishing it. The comments were a mixed bag of the usual Reddit-tier sycophants making the same tired jokes about gulags, Stalin, and Super Mario for some reason. Only a select few actually dared to challenge the narrative and say, "As an actual Italian, you're full of shit and this video makes no sense."

Cody is also kind of a douche on Twitter and he apparently blocks people who critique his content. I don't follow him personally, so this is all second-hand. I don't think he's a lolcow, though.

And don't get me started on Tigerstar: I don't even understand why has a following in the first place.
 
Last edited:
In Italy in 1948 socialist coalition lead by Commies wins election.
CIA does a thing and like 60% of Italian territory breaks away peacefuly And creates west alligned south.
South becomes failed Mafia run state while USA doesnt care anymore and rest of Western Europe doesnt exist.
Isn't the Northern Part of Italy historically has been the more right leaning region while the former Two Scicilies south has been the more left leaning part of the country? Why would america not care about Italy since the whole point of the marshal plan was to rebuild western europe through american business.
Cody is also kind of a douche on Twitter and he apparently blocks people who critique his content. I don't follow him personally, so this is all second-hand. I don't think he's a lolcow, though.
Maybe his friendship with the Cynical Historian is starting to wear on him.
North refuses to bend over to massa Stalin . And creates successful Commie regime. While being isolated.
Because that worked out so well for Yugoslavia and Albania.
 
I just watched a pretty good video on ww2 German vets turned to Mercs after the war. The video was good even though the author's accent is quite thick.
Also I didn't know Youtube Europe is now forcing people to give there ID and Credit Card to watch 18+ videos.
The French Foreign Legion got so German after the war that it has influenced it even up to the modern day
I'm honestly baffled there haven't been demands for denazification considering how popular that has been in Europe for the last few decades
Post WW2 soldiers of fortune are very interesting. During the Congo Crisis war vets from various nations and conflicts from WW2 to Vietnam formed mercenary crews and were paid in loot and whatever inflated bullshit the Congolese government paid. Mad Mike Hoare even tried couping The Seychelles.
Potential failure

AHH
Created this video
He says idea came to him from Tigerstar.

Entire thing sounds like Reddit Leftist fantasy/alt history.

In Italy in 1948 socialist coalition lead by Commies wins election.
CIA does a thing and like 60% of Italian territory breaks away peacefuly And creates west alligned south.
South becomes failed Mafia run state while USA doesnt care anymore and rest of Western Europe doesnt exist.

North refuses to bend over to massa Stalin . And creates successful Commie regime. While being isolated.
Because they owned most of Italian industry , because Commies didnt fuck up industrialized country before.... Cough North Korea cough Czechoslovakia.

North in 1980/90 transforms into democratic socialist state unites Italy and legitimizes Communism as viable ideology.
Lol
I used to think Tigerstar was a gay autistic lobert but man have I lost respect for his mapping autisms. As for this retarded wet dream of REAL COMMUNISM Italy, my God it's amazing how much lefties will invent shit in order to finally make their utopia. That entire synopsis is a blatant fanfic and makes me wonder if AHH is some sort of leftist faggot as well.
 

JustTheFacts has a fun channel. The art style and subject matter makes them seem far right, but they're pretty much a normal person.

I used to think Tigerstar was a gay autistic lobert but man have I lost respect for his mapping autisms. As for this retarded wet dream of REAL COMMUNISM Italy, my God it's amazing how much lefties will invent shit in order to finally make their utopia. That entire synopsis is a blatant fanfic and makes me wonder if AHH is some sort of leftist faggot as well.
North refuses to bend over to massa Stalin . And creates successful Commie regime. While being isolated.
Because they owned most of Italian industry , because Commies didnt fuck up industrialized country before.... Cough North Korea cough Czechoslovakia.

Here is a fun fact: North Korea was the more industrialized part of Korea before the split. I wonder what happened...?

1627840349548.png


So they stopped being radical Marxist-Leninists after losing? Why assume that would still happen?

His message is very strange. Does he know that France also elected a communist/socialist coalition? We can have healthy conversations about modern democracies electing communists without such fantasys.
 
JustTheFacts has a fun channel. The art style and subject matter makes them seem far right, but they're pretty much a normal person.
JTF is incredibly based and shits on everyone from commies to trad caths and LARPagans.
Here is a fun fact: North Korea was the more industrialized part of Korea before the split. I wonder what happened...?

1627840349548.png


So they stopped being radical Marxist-Leninists after losing? Why assume that would still happen?

His message is very strange. Does he know that France also elected a communist/socialist coalition? We can have healthy conversations about modern democracies electing communists without such fantasys.
You don't understand, Norks aren't reeeeeeeaaal Communism because [Run Leftist Jargon and cite Breadtuber.exe]
 
Potential failure

AHH
Created this video
He says idea came to him from Tigerstar.

Entire thing sounds like Reddit Leftist fantasy/alt history.

In Italy in 1948 socialist coalition lead by Commies wins election.
CIA does a thing and like 60% of Italian territory breaks away peacefuly And creates west alligned south.
South becomes failed Mafia run state while USA doesnt care anymore and rest of Western Europe doesnt exist.

North refuses to bend over to massa Stalin . And creates successful Commie regime. While being isolated.
Because they owned most of Italian industry , because Commies didnt fuck up industrialized country before.... Cough North Korea cough Czechoslovakia.

North in 1980/90 transforms into democratic socialist state unites Italy and legitimizes Communism as viable ideology.
Lol
And as usual they'll just casually throw out the conspiracy of CIA somehow interfering in the election, without of course detailing how. STOP THE COUNT!
Now I'm sure the US was throwing money at the anti communist factions, but you're fucking naïve if you think the Soviets weren't doing the same.
If you want a detail of how a conspiracy can influence a election Time magazine gave us this article
Unless you can prove something similar happened in Italy then all the talk of CIA influencing elections is pure propaganda
 
And as usual they'll just casually throw out the conspiracy of CIA somehow interfering in the election, without of course detailing how. STOP THE COUNT!
Now I'm sure the US was throwing money at the anti communist factions, but you're fucking naïve if you think the Soviets weren't doing the same.
If you want a detail of how a conspiracy can influence a election Time magazine gave us this article
Unless you can prove something similar happened in Italy then all the talk of CIA influencing elections is pure propaganda
I remember back when I was on the TNO Subreddit and people talked about the Years of Lead as if it was only the CIA funding right wing paramilitaries and the communists never received funding from anyone (The CIA through backchannels as well).
 
I remember back when I was on the TNO Subreddit and people talked about the Years of Lead as if it was only the CIA funding right wing paramilitaries and the communists never received funding from anyone (The CIA through backchannels as well).
People also miss out on the Soviet Union extracting scientists from the Nazi regime.


Different though. Soviets put guns to their head, while the Americans paid them off/gave them mercy for crimes.
 
And as usual they'll just casually throw out the conspiracy of CIA somehow interfering in the election, without of course detailing how. STOP THE COUNT!
Now I'm sure the US was throwing money at the anti communist factions, but you're fucking naïve if you think the Soviets weren't doing the same.
I remember back when I was on the TNO Subreddit and people talked about the Years of Lead as if it was only the CIA funding right wing paramilitaries and the communists never received funding from anyone (The CIA through backchannels as well).
As usual, communist love to create this revisionist history where they are the victim in every situation they are in and create this alternate reality version of the cold war where the US was the only one doing anything morally ambiguous.
His message is very strange. Does he know that France also elected a communist/socialist coalition? We can have healthy conversations about modern democracies electing communists without such fantasys.
Most of the time Cody doesn't seem to do much research into the subjects he talks about. I also noticed how Cody Franklin (AHH) doesn't seem to have much of a backbone and let's his friends have influence over his world views. I still like the guy but he needs to pull himself together.
 
Back