Evaluating the evidence -- What is proven, and what could be edgy LARPing?
Keep in mind I'm trying to play devils advocate here and disregard what Bella says. I'm going by whether things can be corroborated by other parties or have material evidence. Don't yell at me because I'm "defending her". After all the leaks I believe a lot of the depraved shit she talked about she actually did. But this is about whether it's been conclusively proven.
Note: Evidence towards these is either provided as links, or can be read in the Summary thread under the specified numbers (#), or can be read in the OP of this thread. This post will be updated as I have the time, not all evidence might be sourced at the current moment. I aim to be accurate but do your own damn research too, don't trust people on the internet.
Stealing money from Chris: Not proven
While
she gloats about it in the posted log, she also denies it later saying it was
payment for a camera and services. If what she says is true I'm not sure whether her not being able to render services (due to Chris' arrest) makes it illegal not to return the money though.
Summary thread #12
Stealing a jury summons from her ex lover Avery: Not proven
The only evidence for this is her
talking about it in the Discord leaks. Given that it's not as horrible as boiling hamsters I have no trouble believing she did it, but there has been no confirmation of it in any form.
Summary thread #62
Withholding information about elder abuse: Proven
Repeated Discord leaks have shown she was aware of the abuse and withheld the audio. She claimed this was so that she could edit it to hide her identity. Relevant proof is in the Summary thread.
Summary thread #2, #5
Animal abuse: Proven
There was
a photo. A student of her school confirmed their authenticity. Allen also
confirmed this to Kiwifarms and admitted to it in DMs with other people.
Summary thread #25
Rape: Inconclusive
We have no info about this except the discussions in the Discord. It might just Bella being edgy and retarded.
EDIT: Zorgoth talked about Bella
"feeling friends up". This could be construed as sexual assault.
EDIT: This comes up in
Romans testimonial, but we can't confirm this since the Title IX is obviously not public.
Summary thread #23, #96
Feeding Luis estrogen drugs without his knowledge with the help of her friend Allen / Omongidale Asemota Owobu: Inconclusive
I want to say it's proven because Allen talked to her about it and the
messages in the leak don't seem like a joke at all. However the idea here is to be impartial. Allen engaging about it with her is enough proof for me to believe it, but not enough to conclusively confirm it.
Summary thread #88
Getting her friend Allen / Omongidale Asemota Owobu to buy her alcohol because she's too young to do it herself: Proven
But seriously who fucking
cares. There are no photos or similar but it's absurd to believe they were RPing this for some weird reason on a private Discord server. Thus it's proven beyond reasonable doubt in my opinion.
Summary thread #97
Making/buying fake IDs: Proven
She posted images of these, and they aren't issued by the state. That's forgery.
Summary thread #58
Making fake covid cards: Proven
There are pictures of these cards, and she professed her intent to do so.
Summary thread #57
Spying on people: Inconclusive
The most compelling evidence is
Romans testimonial. He has shown himself forthcoming on KF and his posts so far had no attempts to mislead us, or exaggerate Bellas actions. That said, unless there is a leak of the relevant Title IX documents or TTU confirms it we can't be completely sure.
Summary thread #62, #98
Loli/shota: Proven
Yea, it's in the leaks. No, I won't link these images.
Summary thread #38
Selling drugs: Not proven
There's no proof except her boasting about it. She could easily just been trying to look cool.
Summary thread #55, #92
Pedophilia/CP: Inconclusive
Zorgoth said Bella was collecting CP for "personal use and selling" and mentioned it was "common knowledge". However, no material evidence of that has been found (thank God). Other people
said she posted pictures of children on Discord and made sexual remarks about them. In the recent imgur leaks it was discovered she had at least links to CP in her possession.
Summary thread #40, #39
Vandalism: Proven
While not proven with any material evidence,
screenshots show the whole group of greaseballs planning it out and gloating over it afterwards. It's absurd to believe they were RPing this for some weird reason on a private Discord server. Thus it's proven beyond reasonable doubt in my opinion.
Summary thread #73