#Comicsgate - The Culture Wars Hit The Funny Books!

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Dunno, but I'm wondering if this is why Englentine called it one of the worst comics he's ever read?

lol Englentine said that about Mike's book? Hilarious. To answer your question as to why:
Englentine was one of the first Comicsgate channels.
e2.PNG

But sadly, his channel sucks and he got left behind.
e1.PNG


Now he sad. :'(
 
lol Englentine said that about Mike's book? Hilarious. To answer your question as to why:
Englentine was one of the first Comicsgate channels.
View attachment 673853
But sadly, his channel sucks and he got left behind.
View attachment 673852

Now he sad. :'(

It was at the beginning of his review for the Female Furies issue 1. He said Mike Miller's comic was one of the worst comics he's read, but it didn't compare to the dumpster fire that was Female Furies . So that gotta count for something.
 
lol Englentine said that about Mike's book? Hilarious. To answer your question as to why:
Englentine was one of the first Comicsgate channels.
View attachment 673853
But sadly, his channel sucks and he got left behind.
View attachment 673852

Now he sad. :'(
Doesn't help how grating his voice can get after hearing it for longer than 5mins. His brother also got into many slapfights with other CG YTbers, namely CapnCummings during his CG days.

He also alienated most of his fanbase when he and (forgot his name) debated EVS back when EVS quit Comicsgate (only to rejoin shortly after).
 
Doesn't help how grating his voice can get after hearing it for longer than 5mins. His brother also got into many slapfights with other CG YTbers, namely CapnCummings during his CG days.

He also alienated most of his fanbase when he and (forgot his name) debated EVS back when EVS quit Comicsgate (only to rejoin shortly after).
IIRC there was a Yellowflash, Cecil and TUG? drinking stream on one of their channels and apparently YF went off his rocker about why he hates Engeltine in a massive rant. I was watching another stream (probably rackets) and people were talking about it in the chat and as far as i know that stream was either privated or removed after it ended. I would have liked to have caught that.
 
IIRC there was a Yellowflash, Cecil and TUG? drinking stream on one of their channels and apparently YF went off his rocker about why he hates Engeltine in a massive rant. I was watching another stream (probably rackets) and people were talking about it in the chat and as far as i know that stream was either privated or removed after it ended. I would have liked to have caught that.
YF deletes all his streams, I think it's mostly because he shit talks a lot in them.
 
They explicitly separated Hydra from the Nazis purely for marketing, as Europe has very strict anti-Nazi laws that keep you from selling anything with Nazi logos on it. And marvel took a TON of shit, back in 1990 when they did a Red Skull trading card with the Nazi flag in the background.

I rated this informative, but that's because I couldn't rate it both informative for the overview but autistic for the confusing mess of comics narrative you were documenting. It really does exemplify some of the worst excesses of comics continuity when a simple question like 'Are HYDRA Nazis?' requires numerous paragraphs of history that comes down to 'yes, sometimes, maybe and no, occasionally simultaneously'.

Honestly, it was a good effort on your part, but I'm more confused than before.
 
Quick update but my “Cover A” copy if Lonestar arrived bagged and boarded with the Christmas card, trading card and dog tags, and that’s just at the 25$ buy-in price (for a signed copy). Real shit, Mike knows what he’s doing.

Haven’t read it yet but I’m definitely excited to do so.
 
IIRC there was a Yellowflash, Cecil and TUG? drinking stream on one of their channels and apparently YF went off his rocker about why he hates Engeltine in a massive rant. I was watching another stream (probably rackets) and people were talking about it in the chat and as far as i know that stream was either privated or removed after it ended. I would have liked to have caught that.

Yeah.. the infamous debate with Unranked Chevron and Engeltine on Nicky Racket's stream was some painful shit to watch. I made it only about half way through because there is only so much spergery you can listen to and neither of them seemed to have anything approaching a fully formed point to make. You can catch that shit-show here but it's only fair slap a warning on it: 'Please be aware, watching this content may result in self-harm'.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0vOz9K1HXCY&t=7038s

I'd love to see an impartial review of Comicsgate books by a third party with no skin in the game.
I didn't back Lonestar because cape shit isn't really my thing and it just looked like a sub-par Captain America rip-off akin to those cheap, Chinese market-stall knock offs of Marvel product...

Huh? It Ron Man and is Capstan Merica!
maxresdefault.jpg


It's the same reason that I never backed Zack. I was sorely tempted to, just to give the industry a middle finger, but at the end of the day his campaign didn't need my 25 bucks to do that and I felt that it would just take the piss out the whole idea of Comicsgate to back something for ideological reasons over quality.
It does beg the question though. Has Comicsgate got a writer problem?
You only have to skim through Mike S. Miller's weekly 'Drawn and Quartered' show to see that comicsgate is brimming an with amazing pool of artistic talent. But as Gail Simone pointed out in a tweet (and who want's to find themselves in agreement with that smug land-wale), where are the writers? All over at Ben Henderson's Cautionary Comics or Alterna perhaps like Chuck Dixon?

It's just kind of a shame that the first wave of comicsgate books look underwhelming from a writing perspective and I wonder if the delay in EVS finishing Cyberfrog isn't in part a result of his starting out by drawing his story without a finished script. Just like shooting a movie without a finished script, there will be inevitable re-shoots to craft it into something coherent after the fact. That's going to cause delays, because you're never going to be able to put a date on when your done if you don't know in advance what done is going to look like, just that you'll know what it looks like when you finally get there.
You kind of get hints of this from the occasional comments EVS makes about the ever expanding origin story consuming the book and whether or not he needs to drop pages from the mid section to just get the book out. Personally I hope he takes the time to make Cyberfrog something the anti's choke on rather then rushing it out to meet the criticism of people that didn't buy the book in the first place.

I feel like every comicsgater waving an indigogo around at the moment really needs to sit down and watch Doug Tennapel's series of breakdowns of how to write a script and structure a story. They're very good because he's spent years producing scripts for animation houses using his writing formula which he teaches a writing course on, here's his first one:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XUGxTu-2y4M&list=PL9lUh2RfeyPGbRsK6TCdzSkgxD3fEeFLn
 
Last edited:
Yeah.. the infamous debate with Unranked Chevron and Engeltine on Nicky Racket's stream was some painful shit to watch. I made it only about half way through because there is only so much spergery you can listen to and neither of them seemed to have anything approaching a fully formed point to make. You can catch that shit-show here but it's only fair slap a warning on it: 'Please be aware, watching this content may result in self-harm'.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0vOz9K1HXCY&t=7038s
What you said is true, however I'm talking about a drunken stream that occurred on Cecil's? channel that occurred months? before that 4 person 'debate' on rackets channel. I'm going off shoddy memory, but it occurred around June - August 2018 and was the same stream that YF reportedly drank Cecil under the table.

From what i remember of that awful debate was that unranked chevron and engeltine wanted to follow this model (not that Malin or EVS handled themselves any better).
upload_2019-2-23_23-2-29.png
 
What you said is true, however I'm talking about a drunken stream that occurred on Cecil's? channel that occurred months? before that 4 person 'debate' on rackets channel. I'm going off shoddy memory, but it occurred around June - August 2018 and was the same stream that YF reportedly drank Cecil under the table.

From what i remember of that awful debate was that unranked chevron and engeltine wanted to follow this model (not that Malin or EVS handled themselves any better).
View attachment 674462
I couldn't actually tell where unranked chevron and engeltine wanted to take CG besides yelling at comic pros via twitter and youtube vids. Are Malin, EVS and the rest capitalizing via indiegogos? Yeah, but trying to put something out to please the crowd beats yelling into a void all day hoping for change. The mainstream has loudly decided that CG ain't worth listening to. So fuck 'em and put out your own stuff. If they're not listening to dying shops they're not gonna listen nerds yelling at them on the internet.
 
Edwin has a bad habit of jumping to the wrong conclusions about things, but it goes without saying he doesn’t deserve a gun in his face.

Conclusions? He's actually reached some? All I've ever heard him do on streams is ramble on in "a six year old telling a shaggy dog story" way. Having said that he's the least offensive, least confrontational person associated with CG I can think of. I don't think I've ever heard him even raise his voice. If he weren't so religious I'd suppose a massive daily intake of Maui Wowie he's so mellow.

@Bleeding Fool thinks Whale Simone might be partially responsible for it. Mind giving us a more detailed take?
https://twitter.com/BleedingFool/status/1099340027119747072
View attachment 674614

Has she done anything of note in comics besides that stupid "Fridging" trope? Hell, and IIRC the male characters in that Green Lantern (or was it the Flash?) issue actually got worse treatment. But nobody talks about them.
 
Conclusions? He's actually reached some? All I've ever heard him do on streams is ramble on in "a six year old telling a shaggy dog story" way. Having said that he's the least offensive, least confrontational person associated with CG I can think of. I don't think I've ever heard him even raise his voice. If he weren't so religious I'd suppose a massive daily intake of Maui Wowie he's so mellow.

I finished listening to EVS's livestream just now and Edwin made and appearance on the stream. He seemed calm about the event and assured everybody he and his wife were fine, she also made a brief appearance and she seemed pissed.....but coping well.
Edwin can be a bit exceptional in his own way though. Lord knows he probably exponentially expanded the suspect list by sticking his nose into the twitter weeb wars, (and already they're shaping up to make comicsgate look like tea at the palace with the Queen by comparison) he actually attended Amazing Con yesterday wearing a #comicsgate #standwithVic T-shirt. Which is both cringy and deliberately provocative to two groups of exceptional assholes, talk about painting a target on your back.
Being such a boomer I doubt it was hard for some loon to find his address. He's stated that he intends to go to the con again tomorrow and was encouraging folks to tweet at the con not to ban him (I think the usual suspects are attempting to @ the con). For comicgate's 'voice of reason and wisdom' Edwin can be a right sped sometimes but nobody should ever have to face 6 armed cops at two in the morning just for being a crushing bore.
 
What asshole is going around swatting Edwin, he's so chill, nice and...
he actually attended Amazing Con yesterday wearing a #comicsgate #standwithVic T-shirt
...goddamn retarded. For fucks sake, you boomer, you can't trigger that many spergs at once. That's asking for trouble. We're dealing with nutjobs who want to take twitter banter into the real world. I still remember that one pro who toyed with baiting Meyer into throwing a punch his way
 
YF deletes all his streams, I think it's mostly because he shit talks a lot in them.
Those are the only times YellowFlash is ever interesting to listen to. When he's shit talking others like MundaneMatt he actually comes off as having energy and wit. Everything else of him is just boring, repetitive, droning anti-sjw "look at what Polygon/The Mary Sue/etc. is saying" shit.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top Bottom