- Joined
- Apr 2, 2019
-The Three Fingers are right. The Frenzied Flame and the Greater Will are both mindless dipshits, the Dark Side of the Force (Three Fingers) and the rest of the Force (Two Fingers), with the Greater Will being the equivalent of a poorly-optimized Game of Life program spinning off and clumping up in some corner of the map. You could say "we should have known this was the case due to a hand normally having five fingers", but shut the fuck up about that. This feels like the reveal in Runescape that life only exists because one of the original Gods was retarded and refused to put away her toys. The Greater Will makes things, sticks two fingers and a bug into the world's pussy, and immediately fucks off afterwards.
For the subject of the Three and Two Fingers, the Three Fingers are still wrong. Their argument is literally, about how since pain and suffering exist that all existence should end.
Their quest is pretty clear about that and even their demons like Shabriri and Haeta are clear, they want to end all life forever and destroy the Erdtree which is the embodiment of all life, everywhere.
Also spoilers for the Finger quest but, the Two Fingers aren't creations of the Greater Will, they and the Fingercreepers are the children of Metyr who is in turn a child of the greater will and the first star to fall upon the lands between. The dialogue from the Finger quest implies the golden order and Marika were rotten from conception, for Marika the only suspicous Neuman/Shaman couple we have are Midra and his wife Nanaya so they might be her parents. From the Fleeting Microcosm and Staff of the Great Beyond we learn that the universe of Elden ring is called the Microcosm, literally a "small cosmos" and that the greater will exists beyond that, and that Metyr their mother doesn't represent the Greater Will anymore, and it's either left altogether or just given up on Metyr.
Additionally, from the Two Fingers gesture near the Shaman Village and Marila living close to the Finger Ruins, it's likely that she made contact with Metyr and was probably working with her, which tracks as the the last Fire Giant is guarded by Metyr's children and so is Ranni, who was being raised to replace Marika, by the "Greater Will," but if the Greater Will gave up on Metyr it's likely Marika was just blowing smoke up peoples asses about the Two Fingers working for it when in reality they were answering to Metyr and her.
Ymir the Finger quest giver even says the Fingers guided her.
But as is implied by Metyr not being the mother of the Three Fingers, it's likely the Three Fingers aren't even her children or are just Two Fingers warped by frenzy, so it doesn't seem to be dualistic situation, the Greater Will just left his computer on and the Frenzied Flame wants to blow it up and end all life.
Last edited: