Exulansic / TT Exulansic / Sierra Weir / Sierra Dullea Weir - TERF detransitioner/desister who has a crusade against the "I Am Jazz" phenomenon and also a massive collection of Party City wigs.

[Miss Misery]

For those breathlessly waiting to find out if Exulansic is Mohawk, I have results!

And those results are: maybe?

Her family has been in the St. Lawrence area for generations, but I have found nothing in the way of tribal connections. All census and other relevant records claim they are white. This is almost certainly a case of family lore, and I'm disappointed that she's using unproven (and more importantly, unpracticed) tribal affiliation for SJW influence. This is the sort of thing that gets people removed from tenure positions and subjects otherwise intelligent and well-spoken people to ridicule.

During my research I found that she could join DAR several times over. Her maternal grandmother was born to parents who immigrated from Italy around 1900. Her paternal grandmother was descended from Danish immigrant LDS handcart pioneers! And several branches of her tree have been in Quebec since the 1600s. There's so much family history to be proud of, but she's pretending to be native for what?

Chasing fake ancestry for clout is bullshit. Even if you have legit native ancestry it doesn't mean shit if you weren't raised with tribal traditions and culture. Be proud of who you REALLY are.

 

[Plague Dog]

Once you find out you are male you should use male facilities and resources from that point onward. XY is male, no exceptions.

Nope not quite. She bases it on the activation of the sry gene (found on the y chromosome). Basically if you have xy but the sry gene is broken, they still count as women. And if somehow you get sry on an x gene, she'd say you can be xx and male.

Sry isn't a terrible basis for determining male vs female in theory, but the problem is that sex isn't perfectly binary when you have deleterious mutations (or chimerism). She argues that cais people with internal testes, vaginas and without penises who are infertile present a risk of insemination in female prisons so they should be in men's prisons instead. It's really spergy.

 

[remiem]

For those breathlessly waiting to find out if Exulansic is Mohawk, I have results!

And those results are: maybe?

Her family has been in the St. Lawrence area for generations, but I have found nothing in the way of tribal connections. All census and other relevant records claim they are white. This is almost certainly a case of family lore, and I'm disappointed that she's using unproven (and more importantly, unpracticed) tribal affiliation for SJW influence. This is the sort of thing that gets people removed from tenure positions and subjects otherwise intelligent and well-spoken people to ridicule.

During my research I found that she could join DAR several times over. Her maternal grandmother was born to parents who immigrated from Italy around 1900. Her paternal grandmother was descended from Danish immigrant LDS handcart pioneers! And several branches of her tree have been in Quebec since the 1600s. There's so much family history to be proud of, but she's pretending to be native for what?

Chasing fake ancestry for clout is bullshit. Even if you have legit native ancestry it doesn't mean shit if you weren't raised with tribal traditions and culture. Be proud of who you REALLY are.

Does she have Métis / mi'kmaq / inuit in her background then? I live in Canada and know quite a few mixed for several generations people. Her face really strongly reminds me of a lot of the them. Everyone I know whose mixed inuit have only two forms- relatively normal and basically white or I'm so sorry your face looks that way (and white).

 

[Miss Misery]

Does she have Métis / mi'kmaq / inuit in her background then? I live in Canada and know quite a few mixed for several generations people. Her face really strongly reminds me of a lot of the them. Everyone I know whose mixed inuit have only two forms- relatively normal and basically white or I'm so sorry your face looks that way (and white).

No, she looks like that because she's a quarter southern Italian.

 

[RamblinRosie]

She's saying; if you are biologically male which people with CAIS are, you should not be in women's spaces or using women's resources. Once you find out you are male you should use male facilities and resources from that point onward. XY is male, no exceptions.

In her newest video "Testosterone, CAIS, and the Voice," she seems to be arguing that male hormones affected intersex individuals such as Eden Atwood (DNA says male, physical appearance is female) more. Which. You could also make that argument for women with PCOS.

If the only way one can tell that someone has male coding is by scans and DNA testes, then yeah it makes no sense to tell these individuals who look physically female, and have been raised female to suddenly inhabit men's spaces. It only becomes an issue when wanting children in a marriage.

 

[Plague Dog]

Here's the current sperg about cais. As you know, all women only sing high notes like sopranos, there are no altos, ever. You sing like snow white or you're secretly a dude.

Notice how little research she put into this. No discussion of singing ranges, no labeling the pitches, no discussion of how a woman's voice might change with age, just look at the trannies look at the cais people. You heard a difference in those 10 seconds right? Don't you dare listen to adele, Tina Turner, Amy Winehouse or lady gaga! No stop listening to the difference between teenage Judy Garland and adult Judy Garland!

Edit- the sperg has described female alto singers as having excess testosterone. Classy.

Don't you know that women have 0 testosterone in their bodies so there is 0 change to their voices ever? That's why you never hear any difference between a teenager's voice and an adult woman's voice ever and her comparison is 100% legitimate. Doubly so when you compare professionally recorded footage to one dude with a camera.

 

[Contra Pozz]

So she definitively exposed herself as a rigid ideologist in the CAIS matter. RIP mainstream appeal

 

[Marvin]

Here's the current sperg about cais. As you know, all women only sing high notes like sopranos, there are no altos, ever. You sing like snow white or you're secretly a dude.

Notice how little research she put into this. No discussion of singing ranges, no labeling the pitches, no discussion of how a woman's voice might change with age, just look at the trannies look at the cais people. You heard a difference in those 10 seconds right? Don't you dare listen to adele, Tina Turner, Amy Winehouse or lady gaga! No stop listening to the difference between teenage Judy Garland and adult Judy Garland!

Edit- the sperg has described female alto singers as having excess testosterone. Classy.

Don't you know that women have 0 testosterone in their bodies so there is 0 change to their voices ever? That's why you never hear any difference between a teenager's voice and an adult woman's voice ever and her comparison is 100% legitimate. Doubly so when you compare professionally recorded footage to one dude with a camera.

Thing is, Exulansic's only claim to being a "scientist" is that she's a speech pathologist (read: a speech therapist).

Purely for her sake, as far as her legitimacy goes, it's a terrible idea for her to come out swinging (so poorly), in the field that is her only claim to authority.

Her argument here is that while testosterone might not have all the primary effects it's usually associated with (because the primary receptors are numb to it) there might be some minority, alternative receptors that still work. Hell, maybe even it's just chemical effects of testosterone.

Certainly this could be true, but she's selling it as a foregone conclusion. "like aha, here are four samples, you can clearly hear it! I've proven it!" (personally I can't hear what she's talking about, but whichever)

I mean, I'd be willing to entertain this, but c'mon, you're a speech pathologist. An expert one, allegedly. Let's hear about these alternative receptors. How do they work? What do they do? What data is there on this?

What does she do for a living? Help kids with their lisps? (not to shit on speech therapists, and while I'm sure she knows a lot about vocal cords and hearing, I don't think she's an any more an expert on hormones than a GP is, which is to say, fairly uninformed)

---

Now, the other day, I was poking around her youtube community page and I noticed she's trying to start a church. It seems to be some kind of satirical church, largely for the purpose of maybe initiating lawsuits against troon practices in schools and government and such. The joke seems to be a reference to plants (monocots sprout one leaf from their seed, dicots sprout two, etc).

I'd totally be on board with lawsuits, and I can appreciate the satirical aspects (church of the subgenius is funny up until a point). But... I don't know, she's really sperging out hardcore about it.

I don't know, what do you guys think?

1. Wall of text announcement (archive)
2. Applying to the IRS to be a church (archive)
3. Name of the church, plus plants (archive)
4. More wall of text sperging (archive)
5. Sperging, sperging (archive)
6. Ok, finally something I chuckled at (archive)
7. Jesus was a monochot (archive)
8. Monochot dietary needs, also satire about troon surgeries (archive)

I don't think she actually believes this. It's obviously satirical. But damn, she's autistic as fuck.

 

[Miss Misery]

Edit- the sperg has described female alto singers as having excess testosterone. Classy.

I sing lower than contralto and my testosterone levels are normal, thx. WTAF Sierra, just because you work with speech doesn't mean you're an expert on the non-physiological biological reasons* for vocal differences.

@Marvin: But what happened to her whole dander gender nonsense?

* I have rewritten this phrase a million times and what I mean by it is she is certainly an expert on biological reasons caused by the physical parts of the body that affect speech as well as the issues in the brain that can also cause speech problems. She is not an expert on anything hormonal that affects speech. Hell, I should have just said that last part...

 

[The Emperor Skeksis]

Back to making the good stuff.

I really liked this video, hilarious. Next time some creepy MTF tries to tell you he's 'valid' because humans are like sex-changing fish somehow, just tell him that humans are actually like ruff birds! And it's fucking creepy when birds go AGP too.

 

[Unkraut]

So she definitively exposed herself as a rigid ideologist in the CAIS matter. RIP mainstream appeal

She went the way of the tranny sideshow thread: starts out as having a laugh about trains and at some point derails into pointless intersex chromosome sperging. Let's see if she also does it in cycles like the thread does.
(Imo endulging the intersex spergery in the tranny context makes zero sense, as it implies that the rhetorical trans<->intersex connection exists in the first place and is more than just TRAs leeching sympathy off of people with a genuine developmental disorder)

 

[Miss Misery]

Does she have Métis / mi'kmaq / inuit in her background then? I live in Canada and know quite a few mixed for several generations people. Her face really strongly reminds me of a lot of the them. Everyone I know whose mixed inuit have only two forms- relatively normal and basically white or I'm so sorry your face looks that way (and white).

I just realized how much she reminds me of Carrie Bourassa and then thought of your comment. Bourassa is a common Anishinaabe name... unfortunately, that's her married name. Her maiden name is Weibel.

https://www.thecut.com/2021/12/carrie-bourassa-allegedly-faked-her-indigenous-identity.html
https://nypost.com/2021/12/01/how-carrie-bourassa-passed-herself-off-as-indigenous-for-years/
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/can...nches-process-to-verify-claims-to-indigenous/

“Universities are terrified of doing that kind of stuff, because they’re scared of breaching human rights and scared of being sued. But that’s the way it’s got to be done. There’s got to be criteria in place,” Prof. Wheeler said. “Most important is that you are accepted and belong to a community, and that you can trace your lineage to this community.”

And this is what happens when you claim Indigenous ancestry and cannot prove tribal affiliation and cultural traditions. Exulansic is in private practice and she's a random YouTuber, sure, but saying she's Native and using it for clout (she's talked about it in several videos now, not just as an aside, but to make a point) makes her an easy target so she needs to either prove it or shut up about it ASAP.

 

[topsikrets]

imo she's the same type of malevolent queer as the ones who helped pave the way for this shit. Broken clock.

 

[Plague Dog]

Has anyone noticed her tendency to banshee shriek in her recent videos for no particular reason? It's terrible.

 

[RamblinRosie]

Has anyone noticed her tendency to banshee shriek in her recent videos for no particular reason? It's terrible.

No. if anyone banshee shrieks it's Peppermint.

ETA:

Nah, I'm serious. It's just as bad. Umm... be wary if you're listening on headphone or around people. If you need context of the volume of the rest of the video I guess go back about 5-10 second, but it's your funeral if you really want proof of her banshee shrieking.

Weak

 

[Plague Dog]

No. if anyone banshee shrieks it's Peopermint.

Nah, I'm serious. It's just as bad. Umm... be wary if you're listening on headphone or around people. If you need context of the volume of the rest of the video I guess go back about 5-10 second, but it's your funeral if you really want proof of her banshee shrieking.

https://youtu.be/KnjBbC6kZeg?t=95

https://youtu.be/hSfDqD201Mo?t=85

https://youtu.be/ZrC1wMf9Ehw?t=225

 

[The Emperor Skeksis]

New relevant Exulansic video starring the notoriously dense Jamie who did bought her PhD in only two years and was shocked to hear that her supervisor was trained by one of the OGs who did research on troons.

She had an arterial bleed after her metoidioplasty, and two hematomas, and she is pretty dang traumatised, but she had NO! REGRETS! AT! ALL! She also still got more surgery because she needed 'balls'.

I loathe this girl and I am sad that NHS care is apparently still so good that they managed to save her life. She is not worth the money they are putting in to keep her alive, despite her best efforts.

 

[Miss Misery]

About three and a half minutes in does Exulansic say she's been watching "the show since she was a teenager"? Is she referring to the Jazz phenomenon in general?

Jazz was born October 6, 2000, and wasn't a "public figure" until she was six when she was profiled by Barbara Walters in 2007.

Exulansic was born April 3, 1987. That's pushing the boundaries of "since I was a teenager" pretty fucking hard.

She drives me fucking nuts. Exulansic has plenty of coherent and cromulent points that easily debunk a lot of trans insanity, but when she bends the truth or lies outright she completely destroys her credibility. Why??

Edit: 25ish minutes in she a spergs about blind children not having issues learning to speak. Well of COURSE not, they're blind, not D/deaf you fucking retard.

I'm kind of starting to loathe her...

 

[and I must scream]

She recently made a video on Jammidodger, and it made me realize I can't stand her. Jammie, I mean. Can't stand this person spewing up so much of that trans shit and influencing so many young people.

Anyway, had to get it out. Back to Exulansic. I still like her. She has some wild theories, she exaggerates sometime, she sometimes finds fault in everything (in the Jazz videos especially), I don't agree with some of her views and doubtful about others, but I sure would rather watch I Am Jazz with her commentary than watch it without, and she has some good videos with good points. That's enough for me.

 

[The Emperor Skeksis]

Drama incoming. I didn't follow Exulansic's fued with the CAIS intersex person who was on Benjamin Boyce, but she's going to war because this person made a response video. I haven't watched the response video because I do not care a bit about the inane discussion. The discussion in this bloody thread was a thousand times less stupid and more clear anyway.



This is the video and the thumbnail she is upset about.

I mean, it's not a nice image, but...you're not gonna win this, Sierra. You must know what the Streisand Effect is.


I have to agree. I really wish Exulansic would let this CAIS obsession go already. She made her opinion very clear, we all get it. People are going to disagree about a super super super rare disorder, while a ton of normal kids are still being mutilated by surgeons. Priorities, woman!