Magic the Gathering: Arena - Pay to ... buy cards you can't trade (or don't).

Capsaicin Addict

Now see here you little shit.
True & Honest Fan
kiwifarms.net
Joined
Jun 4, 2018
Alright, the TLDR: it's not bad.

First off, MtGA is free to play, with all the cheerful crap that entails. It doesn't look like you can outright buy your way to victory, though; paying money still gets you those random packs. I don't know if they'll have a system to trade cards at any point, either (right now I don't think they do). In fact, player interaction is EXTREMELY limited; there's no ingame chat that I've seen, and matchmaking is semi-random (more on this soon). So it's hard to virtually teabag an opponent except through the game.

That being said, the game does have an excellent tutorial, although the little fairy-mote that walks you through things reminded me disturbingly of Navi. You get five monocolor decks as you work through the tutorial, and can earn more bicolor decks as you play. While these premade decks are fairly decent, they can also be modified, swapping out cards (note that you do not need more than four of any nonland card; you can have a red/blue deck with four Lightning Bolts and a black/red deck with the same, so long as you HAVE four Lightning Bolts).

The interface itself is fairly good, and it's smart enough to speed things along during a match if players don't have the ability to take actions (you can bluff by setting 'stops' during your turn, to make an opponent think you have some instant or counter in your hand. Clever.). Of course, if everything goes tits-up for you, the Concede button is behind the options gear. Sometimes, you just gotta fold.

Winning matches, casting spells or playing cards of certain colors nets you gold, which can be used to buy more packs. Packs can come with, and count towards, getting 'wildcards' -- which can be converted into ANY card of the same rarity. Very neat mechanic, and I suspect one reason why trading won't be along anytime soon. There's almost no need for it.

So yeah, I'd say it's worth the download, but I wouldn't spend cash on it (then again I am a miserly bastard).
 
Is Hambly banned yet?
LOL, I had to look this loon up.

No way to tell. The accounts all use handles, so unless he's actually playing as his real name, I really couldn't say.

I doubt he does play, as the system really does not lend itself to autistic screeching. There's only like five messages you can send in a match -- Nice, Oops, Good Game, and a couple other pretty nonoffensive ones (I think one is 'Bring It' or something similar).

Edit: Oh, this is the guy who also (supposedly) got attacked at GenCon. While nobody deserves physical assault, Hambly strikes me as such a jackass I wouldn't put a 'provocation' defense away.
 
A nice attempt at cashing in on Hearthstone, which is sad since M:tG should have used their 20+ year head start to make a PC game worth half a shit. I kind of liked the recent Steam version of Magic that had mini campaigns for Lilliana and some other notable planeswalkers, but goddamn is this game late to the party. Can't be arsed anymore.
 
I love mtg but can't stand playing on the PC. No idea why, but something totally gets lost when you're not holding and drawing real cards.

That said as a veteran player, it's a fantastic program for old and new players, and it's not too hard to go infinite with drafts whilst also being pretty fun. I just wish they would go all out on it and start adding eternal formats like Modern, even though I'm sure it would be quite an undertaking. Overall, very worth the download, but definitely don't drop any money, especially for virtual cards with no intrinsic value.

I'm not sure if this would be counted off topic, but the impact it's having on the in-paper market is pretty interesting. FNM attendance is definitely dwindling, as more and more older players are finding it's much easier to play on their own time than be at a store by 6:30. It'll be interesting to see whether WOTC decides to keep moving in their current trajectory, which would make a lot of brick and mortar stores obsolete.
 
I'm not sure if this would be counted off topic, but the impact it's having on the in-paper market is pretty interesting. FNM attendance is definitely dwindling, as more and more older players are finding it's much easier to play on their own time than be at a store by 6:30. It'll be interesting to see whether WOTC decides to keep moving in their current trajectory, which would make a lot of brick and mortar stores obsolete.

That and the smell. My FLGS did a full renovation recently and made a big playing area full of tables... in the basement. And not nearly enough HVAC to vent it. You couldn't pay me to play there anymore.
 
I just wish they would go all out on it and start adding eternal formats like Modern, even though I'm sure it would be quite an undertaking.
As much as I'd love eternal format support on mtga I'm trying to imagine how it would feel to play some of my favorite legacy decks or modern decks on the platform and I just don't think it would be nearly as fun of an experience unless the timer system was closer to paper or mtgo. I used to play a lot of legacy and vintage dredge in paper and online, and trying to translate what that would look like in Arena vs. the other two is kind of like trying to learn another language.
 
  • Feels
Reactions: Keep Yourself Safe
A nice attempt at cashing in on Hearthstone, which is sad since M:tG should have used their 20+ year head start to make a PC game worth half a shit. I kind of liked the recent Steam version of Magic that had mini campaigns for Lilliana and some other notable planeswalkers, but goddamn is this game late to the party. Can't be arsed anymore.
They already made a PC game worth half a shit 22 years ago but now Hasbro is licencing them out to chase that pay to win whale money.

Actually, full disclosure, the Magic 20XX games were kind of alright and not pay to win. Except for Magic 2015, which would let you pay extra to skip pack grinding but IIRC was also the only one that let you deck build.
 
As much as I'd love eternal format support on mtga I'm trying to imagine how it would feel to play some of my favorite legacy decks or modern decks on the platform and I just don't think it would be nearly as fun of an experience unless the timer system was closer to paper or mtgo. I used to play a lot of legacy and vintage dredge in paper and online, and trying to translate what that would look like in Arena vs. the other two is kind of like trying to learn another language.
Haha yea I can't imagine vintage feeling the same.

Casting Flusterstorm would probably take down all the NA servers.
 
They unquestionably hate the shit out of that guy.
Kind of reminds me of League of Legends where one employee a-logged the shit out this kid Tyler1 for a year deleting every new account he made to stream on just because he was a 'toxic' player, but couldn't control his autism on Discord and publicly shat on the streamer so Riot had to fire him. Later that year Tyler1 got invited to a live event where devs had to play nice with him and sort of suck up as he represented a big chunk of the community and playerbase.
 
Kind of reminds me of League of Legends where one employee a-logged the shit out this kid Tyler1 for a year deleting every new account he made to stream on just because he was a 'toxic' player, but couldn't control his autism on Discord and publicly shat on the streamer so Riot had to fire him. Later that year Tyler1 got invited to a live event where devs had to play nice with him and sort of suck up as he represented a big chunk of the community and playerbase.
On a side note, it's always easier to let people like that take that step over the line and then banhammer them. As tempting as preventative maintenance can be with a playerbase, it's too easy to abuse.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Uncanny Valley
Game is fine. the problem is the meta. Its super toxic and sucks out all the fun.
 
I decided to give this a whirl and am having fun destroying people with the default white deck. Though I am dreading the day when I'm matched against whales and spergs with customs decks.

How bad is constructed bronze tier? Is it possible to push to silver with the default deck?
 
I started playing this, it runs mostly fine on Linux (minus the auto-updater insisting on redownloading the whole game every update). I hear spending my gold on draft mode is the best way to build a collection, any tips for drafting?

Spending actual money on F2P games is for cucks.
 
I started playing this, it runs mostly fine on Linux (minus the auto-updater insisting on redownloading the whole game every update). I hear spending my gold on draft mode is the best way to build a collection, any tips for drafting?

Spending actual money on F2P games is for cucks.
The most basic pick order in limited is BREAD (Bombs > Removal > Evasion > Aggro > Duds). It's not a hard rule but it's something to keep in mind. You can also google specific tier lists for the set you're drafting, like this one. This guy does Arena draft videos and is pretty good at explaining the choices he does and doesn't make.
 
I heard they're nerfing the 3 packs/week to some weird level up XP system. GAMERS RISE UP.

Also PLAYM20 (3 M20 packs) and LevelUp (2 levels) are new promo codes.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: Thiletonomics
They retired the 15 wins = 3 packs a week thing and instead introduced the Mastery system. It takes 1000 xp to level up and you can get a max of 1k xp a day (800 from quest, 200 from first 3 wins a day). Every 2 levels you get a free pack, up to 36 packs. Unfortunately, this means unless you log in a lot you won’t get the same amount of packs. Plus you can buy the Mastery pass to get more junk including a cosmetic pet. People are upset and it’s hilarious.
 
Back