Will Patrick ever learn to write a proper sentence? Or does he actually want to name them as Stalker and just forgetting to capitalize the Noun he gave them?
Like Patrick, it's there only win in 50 years so they have something in common
The consensus on the other forum is that it means that Pat is still fat. As for what the legal ramifications are, there are a few theories around but nobody is sure yet.
Surprised we didn't have this clown as a lolcow until early this year.
He's desperately requesting a delay in his own case until the fuckery in California is over, and begging for a chance to try to amend his train wreck of a complaint into something functional. Good chance he'll get both.
This motherfucker is so short on authorities he's citing a New Jersey state court case?
I
The judge did say he was going to recommend the subpoena to be quashed and did not seem impressed with Patrick's lawyers even saying himself he didn't consider fake book reviews to be considered "defamation".
If he's already said that, I doubt he'll consider this supplemental brief very convincing. It's feeble.
He essentially doubled down on saying the book reviews were super defamatory, but didn't make any effort to connect any of them to Quasi, which is what the judge specifically said he needed to do in order for the motion to quash to not be upheld. There was also some random shit saying things like Quasi isn't allowed to present exculpatory evidence in a motion to quash since that's what the courtroom is for and a subpoena is only about a prima facie display of wrongdoing.
If nothing else, the original subpoena would seem to have merit as to the post described on lines 6-11 of page 2 of the most recent filing. OnA as a platform isn't responsible for the content that's posted there, but they'd seemingly have a responsibility to at least provide IP logs of the post to which Fatrick refers.
Well, that's my general impression, but if the reports of what the judge was actually saying during the hearing are accurate, he doesn't agree and would need his mind changed. I don't see anything particularly earth-shattering in this supplemental.
Just to be clear, it's my hope that the subpoena is still quashed - at least to the identity of Quasi, which, contrary to the most recent pleading, doesn't need to be revealed in order for IP logs pertaining to other allegedly defamatory comments to be turned over.
Quasi already provided them with the user info including IP addresses for the posters mentioned in the complaint, but they complained that the information wasn't enough. it had something to do with the IP addresses not giving them data on the end user.
Boo-fucking-hoo. OnA has no responsibility to require, and keep records of, someone's diver's license when they sign up to the forum, Fatrick should go be one of those retards who campaigns to remove anonymity on the internet then.
I don't think it would show actual malice to say that about, say, Bryan Singer, even if he hasn't been charged. There have been quite credible accusations of having sex with minors leveled at him, even if law enforcement hasn't acted. It would definitely be "defamatory" in the strict sense of causing someone to fall into disrepute and ignominy if such things were believed, and would be defamatory per se, but it would not pass the actual malice test, in that a reasonable person could believe that.
He has his trail of breadcrumbs, it is up to him to follow it. If it's just IP addresses, tough shit.
Knowing who Quasi is would not magic up any more information on the end users. It's a pure fishing expedition.
I did not know that. If that's the case, then he's fulfilled his obligation.
That's not his problem. That may be the reason that the judge isn't thrilled with him pushing it further... a fishing expedition, as AnOminous said.
Accurate
That's exactly what this is. A comparison to Vordrak was made in the previous page of the thread, Pat is just as deranged as Vordrak but has yet to get the location of any of his detractors. Pat also owns many guns so I doubt he would bother with anonymous bomb threats, he'd instead try and do to Quasi what those Tranny-hotline idiots did to Null.
