Okay, I'll give you a quick rundown of what happened with Clover.
Pokemon Clover has been one of the most requested sets, always being on the top 10, on the site for years.
Over the course of years the comments and thread about Clover have been brigaded with people demanding it not be platformed for being "hate speech". This has been a large sticking point as much of the modern retro community are made of troons, however every time someone ranted about how evil Clover was the game would get another 20ish requests. It had around 500+..
For the past year or so a lot of big speedrun youtubers have been making videos playing RA sets of games they play which get 100k+ views and as a result RA has been trying to maintain more of a public image than it has in the past.
There is another game which had a set since 2022 that is a literal rape porn game, 177 (
https://retroachievements.org/game/6978?v=1), and it had less controversy over being platformed than Clover ever did.
The admin account made an announcement in the thread for Clover clarifying their position on "hateful content" why it was being allowed to have a set. (
https://retroachievements.org/forums/topic/32644?page=1). They make the mistake of stickying this announcement to the front page and coupling it to Clover specifically.
Troons rush our in droves to do what they do best and argue non-stop about how this is literally a fascist genocide against trans poc folx (the thread is 46 pages for fuck's sake), they go on bluesky and bitch constantly. There's probably a lot of funny shit to harvest on that end, I haven't had the time to check myself.
About two hours ago the site's owner Scott himself locks the Clover thread and says there will be an updated announcement shortly.
Both the Clover and 177 pages are blanked out and banned from getting a set in the future, this is signified by a Z icon next to its name and being in the RA graveyard hub.
A new announcement is made apologizing and capitulating to the troons that can be summarized as "hate speech... le bad!" (
https://retroachievements.org/forums/topic/32648), this one is locked immediately.
The entire discord is put into slow mode, you can only reply every five minutes. But of course while the initial thread had tons of people coming out of the woodwork to support their first standpoint on a Clover set, the same handful of troons are throwing a victory lap now.
One of the hash maintainers and a prominent developer tele quits directly because of this decision leaving a message in their discord which was deleted, quote here:
"I'm getting this out of the way since I'm already getting DMs about my disappearance:
I left the admin/moderation teams and have temporarily left the Discord servers. I cannot support caving into an idiotic vocal minority over doxing, harassment, threats, etc. instead of outright banning them or fighting back. I've said it countless times: it is absolutely no one's business what other people play and people who want to make it their business can just fuck off.
I personally don't give a shit about any of the games in question, but I defend their existence on the site because RA is a supplementary service. The implication and accusations that we are supportive of RApe, RAcism, etc. over allowing games that include such things is fucking absurd and I think is impossible to take seriously. If it's not those things, it'll be something else. The likelihood of a domino effect in asskissing is something that I'll have no part of, so good luck with that mess. I imagine the ridiculous UWC reports will also end up working since all it takes is threatening our "staff" for people to get their way and it's incredibly easy to do. Thanks, internet.
I'll continue doing hash management and maintaining RAPatches, if allowed, but I believe that will be the extent of what I do. Who knows how long that will last, though. I think continuing as a developer is up in the air at the moment, but that could fizzle out and leave no point to me contributing altogether. In the meantime, I'll need others to take over DevJam, DevQuest 004, and a few other things. I'll be in touch soon(tm).
For now, I'm taking a break from dealing with anyone.
- tele"