The ICANN Transition - The future of the Cyber

On Sept. 30, the US Department of Commerce will allow its contract with the nonprofit Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) to lapse.

ICANN's main job is to manage identifiers and addresses on the Internet, such as administering the root zone file (the backbone of the DNS system), assigning IP address blocks, and approving new top level domains (like .ms or .exposed). It does not have any control over the specifics of the content hosted online or exercise any control over governmental restriction within their borders.

If all goes as planned, ICANN is set to transfer over fully to an independent 'multi-stakeholder' governance model, that would include representatives from various world governments, as well as private companies and civil society groups.

The organisation has been criticised for its lack of transparency and accountability to these stakeholders, however, despite spending two years trying to push through community-led reforms.

ICANN's Board and staff do not like the changes that the internet community, over the course of a year, have devised in order to keep them in check.

  • They – ICANN Corporate – don't like the fact that the community working group (CWG) has proposed that the "member organization" be given real members so that a group other than the Board and staff has a legal right to demand changes.
  • ICANN Corporate also doesn't like the fact that the group has recommended the internet community be given an emergency veto power over the organization's budget.
  • And ICANN Corporate doesn't like the proposal that the internet community would be able to remove individual Board members if they fail to act in the internet's broader interests, rather than only the organization's.

There has also been some controversy over continuing delays in the granting of new domain names, like .gay (lol), which Saudi Arabia did in fact object to the inclusion of in the list of new TLDs.

US politicians took the opportunity to demonstrate their remarkable ability to turn complex policy issues into soundbyte slapfights. Ted Cruz and Donald Trump, along with a bunch of other Republicans, claim that the ICANN transition would empower countries like Russia and China to censor the Internet at the highest level. That's dumb tbh fam.

Cruz tried to include a provision that mandated continued US administration of ICANN into the new Senate spending bill, but it seems to have been dropped from the most recent version, so it looks like it's going ahead.
 
ICANN is absolute shit. If you somehow turned over the shit they've done to the government of fucking Sudan, it couldn't be worse. Fuck ICANN and fuck everything it is even in charge of.

I hope it's a complete and utter disaster and the whole Internet collapses unless we come up with a decentralized solution to everything they have ever done.
 
ICANN is absolute shit. If you somehow turned over the shit they've done to the government of fucking Sudan, it couldn't be worse. Fuck ICANN and fuck everything it is even in charge of.

I hope it's a complete and utter disaster and the whole Internet collapses unless we come up with a decentralized solution to everything they have ever done.

The only other serious alternative that I've heard of is to turn internet governance over to a dedicated UN Committee, which would be guaranteed to be somehow even worse.
 
The only other serious alternative that I've heard of is to turn internet governance over to a dedicated UN Committee, which would be guaranteed to be somehow even worse.

The only thing these bozos have ever done is provide a very trivial service, which is just converting names into numbers. There are all kinds of alternatives to their incompetence. This is not that hard to do.
 
The only thing these bozos have ever done is provide a very trivial service, which is just converting names into numbers. There are all kinds of alternatives to their incompetence. This is not that hard to do.

Right, but I would have a hard time naming a bigger network effect than the one you enjoy when you're on the same Internet as everyone else. From my understanding, decentralising DNS roots in a big way would open the door for a nationally fragmented Internet(s).
 
  • Informative
Reactions: Male Idiot
Right, but I would have a hard time naming a bigger network effect than the one you enjoy when you're on the same Internet as everyone else. From my understanding, decentralising DNS roots in a big way would open the door for a nationally fragmented Internet(s).

Best Korea Internet is coming! Now with 50% more propaganda! Available only in North Korea on all fifty computers in the greatest country!
 
In the worst case scenario we'll have to start using IP addresses instead of domain names.
 
Net neutrality is a concept that existed as long as the fucking Internet has existed. It existed well before Obama was even a person on the political scene. Grow the fuck up.

Yeah and the concept of personal responsibility and the idea of the government protecting your rights instead of granting them to you existed long before the Constitution was ratified.

Doesn't change the fact that "a concept" and "a reality" are two different things.
 
The Republican voter has been trained for the past eight plus years to reflexively oppose anything Obama supports and this is no different. Do they ever stop to wonder "Wait a minute. His last several hundred evil plots to destroy America and force us to convert to Islam ended up doing neither. Maybe he really isn't out to get me...."? I know I'm giving them to much credit and they'll scream that THIS TIME will be the fulfillment of his plan to destroy the white race and trick their women into craving big black Muslim cock while forcing them to gay marry.
 
The Republican voter has been trained for the past eight plus years to reflexively oppose anything Obama supports and this is no different. Do they ever stop to wonder "Wait a minute. His last several hundred evil plots to destroy America and force us to convert to Islam ended up doing neither. Maybe he really isn't out to get me...."? I know I'm giving them to much credit and they'll scream that THIS TIME will be the fulfillment of his plan to destroy the white race and trick their women into craving big black Muslim cock while forcing them to gay marry.
Nigga, I see your point, but most of the people in this thread aren't even Republicans.
 
So did this thing happen yet or not? I heard it was scheduled for october 1st and I've heard absolutely fuck all since the initial madness.
If it has, I can't wait till the real world fun police bash down my door for owning pepe memes and I'm erased from every photo I've taken with important people soviet-era style after the ensuing shadow-excecution.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Uncanny Valley
Back