Careercow Tim Rogers

acrylicpaint

High fuckin' functionally autistic
kiwifarms.net
Joined
Feb 25, 2013
tim_look2.jpg


Tim Rogers is a "video game journalist" who writes for Kotaku and his own website, ActionButton.net. No, he isn't really a lolcow. But he is an incredibly pretentious hipster douchebag, not to mention one of the Internet's lulziest characters.

Tim has been on the games journalism scene for the past decade or so and has actually led a fairly interesting life. After graduating from Indiana University with a BS in journalism, he actually put his degree to use writing for online publications and working in the games industry, all while spending extended amounts of time in Japan and Hawaii (and living in complete poverty, mind you).

He rose to prominence thanks mostly to his incredibly wordy (read: never even glanced at by a copy editor) writing style, the best example of which is his infamous whopping 8-page expose on the experience of playing Animal Crossing (remind you of anyone you know?). Like most of Tim's work, the Animal Crossing review exhibits an oddly condescending tone and ridiculous John Hersey in-the-trenches type of storytelling that just doesn't jibe well with games journalism. Half of the review is Tim describing the experience of heating up his vegan burrito while the game loads.

As I mentioned before, Tim isn't technically a lolcow because there's never been an organized trolling movement against him, but I highly doubt such a movement would be unsuccessful if it ever popped up. Tim is very sensitive to criticism and will write a 6,000 word article putting you down if you don't like his pink shirt. And it's a shame, too: Tim's writing actually isn't bad and he sometimes has legitimately interesting things to say about game design. It's just hard to sift through the paragraphs and paragraphs of rants on thrifting, veganism, and childish weeaboo shit to find it.

If you want the Tim Rogers experience condensed into a mere 5,190 words, read this article. Please, read that article. You will rage.
 
It's kind of funny, I got inspired to try out Animal Crossing when I read his article. And his stuff (and other interesting articles at Insert Credit) actually made me interested of starting a game blog. You may, however, find it a big relief that I'm not copying Rogers' writing style. At. Fucking. All. :)

If you want a perfect illustration of why Rogers' style is ludicruous, try Something Awful's take on it. This is beautiful.
 
Thanks for bumping the thread. You know I'm certain I likely wouldn't like Tim Roger's as a person but I got nothing but praise for his recent hilarious Action Button reviews, namely his review of Pac-Man and the 90s Dating Sim Tokimeki Memorial.

One could critique his recent videos as pretentious and navelgazing but I see it as just comical reviews since it's literally a giant nerd treating video games with the same reverence as an art critic could discuss a Van Gogh painting. Probably not a cup of tea for everyone but they were fun for me to listen while doing my daily commutes.

I would currently consider Tim a redeemed lolcow although I'm sure others will disagree.
 
Tim Rogers has been co-hosting a podcast called Insert Credit for some years with Brandon Sheffield (an annoying, outdated tumblr-circa-2013 style sjw) and Frank Cifaldi (a video game preservationist who does not like nor play video games). Last week, episode 360 of the podcast was released and featured Tim and only Tim, talking about the Xbox 360 for 2 hours. Naturally, this is the most viewed episode of the podcast.
Screenshot 2024-10-29 132230.png

The video ends with Tim asking viewers to donate to his personal Patreon rather than the show Patreon. After releasing this episode, Tim quit the podcast.
Clipped here is Frank and Brandon's opening statements from episode 361 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=90n16f5Q3m4):

And this is Tim's response/damage control/whatever:
tim1.jpgtim2.jpgtim3.jpg
Entertaining reactions from the community:
Here is the show's official forums discussion thread for ep 361 https://archive.is/PmHGO
Here is Tim's own subreddit talking about how annoying he is https://archive.is/uKFA6
And here's a /v/ thread about it just as a little bonus https://archive.is/CVIpV
EDIT: Here are some clips from Tim's stream on 10/25 (https://www.twitch.tv/videos/2285355342)
 
Last edited:
Dude leaves, stays quiet when asked for a statement, then complains they didn't read his mind and announce it the wait he wanted. Peak feminine narcissistic behaviour.
The wait his subreddit scrubbed everything is very telling too. Very good post.

Edit: His fanbase is full of fags, still, lol
Screenshot_20241030-052627.png
 
Last edited:
I first became aware of Tim more than 20 years ago after reading his essay "Dreaming in an Empty Room" about Metal Gear Solid 2. He has definite lolcow vibes, but also clearly the highest IQ in games journalism. Interesting guy.
 
Did his action button reviews channel just get abandoned, or is he working on some really strange esoteric review that takes him 50 years to finish? This guy is the most pretentious person to ever be
most of his review on Boku no Natsuyasumi is him methodically sperging about his childhood house and his epic scary photographic (but it's not like, photographic guys) memory power he is cursed with. i don't know why i sat down and watched it all.
anyways, i'll thank him for lolcalizing Moon RPG, great game, but it is still a lolcalization.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChiribiscoToo
Tim's midlife crisis is ongoing. Baited his fanbase with a goty stream, then admitted that everything he wrote before the current incarnation of his internet presence was a lie (though he won't admit to the lies he still relies on for his current persona eg eidetic memory.) He has confessed to these things because people are supposedly trying to cancel him for all the rape and pedophilia in his old autobiography. (He said everything he wrote before 2016 is heavily fictionalized, but he also specifically says that his teen muteness was made up, which is a major part of the ff6 review he wrote in 2019? kinda sus.) He claimed everything he says about himself in his video essays is true.
Screenshot 2025-02-15 213600.png

Here's the vod https://www.twitch.tv/videos/2381314394
Here's a different reddit thread that is more in depth about the stream https://archive.is/Qo4Wo
 
Tim's midlife crisis is ongoing. Baited his fanbase with a goty stream, then admitted that everything he wrote before the current incarnation of his internet presence was a lie (though he won't admit to the lies he still relies on for his current persona eg eidetic memory.) He has confessed to these things because people are supposedly trying to cancel him for all the rape and pedophilia in his old autobiography. (He said everything he wrote before 2016 is heavily fictionalized, but he also specifically says that his teen muteness was made up, which is a major part of the ff6 review he wrote in 2019? kinda sus.) He claimed everything he says about himself in his video essays is true.
View attachment 6987545
Here's the vod https://www.twitch.tv/videos/2381314394
Here's a different reddit thread that is more in depth about the stream https://archive.is/Qo4Wo
I'm surprised that people even have access to his autobiography in this day and age. the overwhelming majority of Tim's fanbase are from the kotaku video essay era of his work. the autobiography was distributed via email around the time the first Mario Maker game came out iirc. doods in the reddit are either concern trolling, or are actual insufferable fags that pearl clutch if someone so far as looks at them wrong.

Tim never SA'd anyone, lol. The pedophilia is more warranted, altho the girl was 15-17 years of age. The more interesting aspect was that she was severely mentally ill, and was driven to suicide potentially due to the fact that Tim rejected her advances. He does admit to fucking a few underage (once again 15-17) broads afterwards tho.

kind of a nothingburger imo, but I do agree with you that he has been very immature with this newfound regret/denial of concealing his 'genuine' self from the wider populace. the truth is, you read autobiography, and read some choice blogs LPM, and you get as much of an encapsulation as you would need. he's either deluding himself into this lie, or is just growing more sensitive to the larger criticisms levied to him the more he puts himself out there. the earliest I can remember him doing this schtick was when they had that Irish faggot on Insert Credit that was besmirching Mario Odyssey, which set off Tim's 'tism.
 
Tim has released his first video in two and a half years. It is a ten hour description of the plot of L.A. Noire...
Not a review, a recap. Done in character as a detective describing it as if it really happened. Just the plot of the game in a funny voice. Nothing else. No context, nothing about the development, influences, release, cultural impact. Nothing about how it feels to play. Nothing about how it relates to him personally. Even Tim's subreddit is more peeved than pleased:
Highly upvoted posts and comments refer to it as "an extended nostalgia critic episode," "incredibly disappointing," & "hard to watch." Tim refers to it as his "Favorite Thing I Have Ever Made."
Due to the creative restrictions he placed on himself, the more tim-rogersy observations are only present implicitly (e.g. the bulk of the joke of the video is highlighting examples of ludonarrative dissonance but describing them as real actions taken by real people and not acknowledging them as video game jank.) The non-game b-roll featured is exclusively of the "tim shows you his expensive clothes" variety.
 
Tim has released his first video in two and a half years. It is a ten hour description of the plot of L.A. Noire...
Not a review, a recap. Done in character as a detective describing it as if it really happened. Just the plot of the game in a funny voice. Nothing else. No context, nothing about the development, influences, release, cultural impact. Nothing about how it feels to play. Nothing about how it relates to him personally. Even Tim's subreddit is more peeved than pleased:
Highly upvoted posts and comments refer to it as "an extended nostalgia critic episode," "incredibly disappointing," & "hard to watch." Tim refers to it as his "Favorite Thing I Have Ever Made."
Due to the creative restrictions he placed on himself, the more tim-rogersy observations are only present implicitly (e.g. the bulk of the joke of the video is highlighting examples of ludonarrative dissonance but describing them as real actions taken by real people and not acknowledging them as video game jank.) The non-game b-roll featured is exclusively of the "tim shows you his expensive clothes" variety.
it's very tiresome whenever it stops for a moment to go "whoooa isn't it weeeeird that he proceeded to stare at a bottle unrelated to anything for a whole minute?!?!?" and just keeps doing it, and keeps doing it, and keeps doing it, all throughout almost 10 HOURS. is this what millennials find hilarious? tim needs to get his priorities straight when a video of his from 4 years ago with less than half as much runtime has more to say.
 
Back