Definitely felt a lot like Red Thread. My favorite episodes of that were the cryptid ones which I think could work for Creep Cast if they put a bit of effort into turning the first hand accounts into a more story-like format. To use a story that's been covered on both CC and RT already as an example, they could open with the Goatman creepypasta, go over the urban legend and folklore, and then cover some eyewitness encounters. I think that would make for a pretty compelling episode with enough effort put into the script