RU Who was Yakov Yurovsky, the man behind the murder of Nicholas II?

L | A
By Oleg Yegorov
8af2aad42939183612b47f833515752014cdf46c.jpg
Yakov Yurovsky surely loved tea - In one of few photos we have he is portrayed with a large glass

This devoted Bolshevik commanded executioners to unleash the fury of their guns on the Romanovs, and even after many years passed Yurovsky never regretted what he did.

As you may know, Russia’s last emperor, Nicholas II, was executed on July 17, 1918, when the Bolshevik guards opened fire on him and his entire family: wife, four daughters and a son, as well as five servants.

This grisly event happened in the cellar of the so-called “House of Special Purpose” in Yekaterinburg (a major city in the Urals, 1,700 km east of Moscow), where the former imperial family was held since April 1918.

7a5efb55b535717bd1fbefc6ff25df17f5e73aeb.jpg
The Ipatiev House, where Nicholas II was executed along with his family

The Bolsheviks, led by Yakov Yurovsky, a rigid black-bearded man who worked in the local Cheka (secret police), acted in cold blood, finishing off those who didn’t die right away with knives and bayonets. That’s what Yurovsky himself wrote in a note, calling himself in third person, “commander,” which indeed was his post in the “House of Special Purpose”:

“The commander told the Romanovs that, as their relatives in Europe keep on attacking Soviet Russia, the Bolshevik government in the Urals gave a verdict to shoot them. Nicholas turned to the family, then turned back to the commander, asking: ‘What? What?’ The commander repeated… then the firing started, which lasted for two or three minutes. It was the commander who killed Nicholas instantly.”

The last sentence, however, might be incorrect, and to this day it is still disputed who exactly among the firing squad shot and killed the ex-emperor. Yurovsky’s testimony, however, shows his ruthlessness and brutality. What turned him into an executioner?


From a watchmaker to a Bolshevik

ba113a6a78fa6bd95168d77452e295c89dfbb2ce.jpg
Actual Yakov Yurovsky vs. portrayed by Duncan Pow

In The Last Czars, a 2019 show by Netflix, Yurovsky, portrayed by Duncan Pow, plays a crucial role as an antagonist to Nicholas II. The emperor was (according to the show) a kind but weak man who didn’t want to reign in the first place. Yurovsky, on the contrary, was shown as a devoted person who would do anything for the cause he believed in – making ordinary people’s lives better.

One of the scenes shows Yurovsky speaking to Nicholas days before his execution. The two men are sharing a cigarette and Yurovsky recalls how they met each other once before. “1891, I was 10. You were completing your Far East tour. You stopped in Tomsk… I had a little flag, waving it. Just one of the little ants you were nodding and waving at.”

0c53a661bf90104b8c22ff8e19f6636453b819b2.jpg

In reality, Yurovsky wouldn’t have bothered to speak with Nicholas II unless it was necessary, let alone share childhood memories. Born into a poor Jewish family in 1878 near Tomsk (3,600 km east of Moscow) – so he certainly wasn’t 10 in 1891 – Yurovsky was eighth among 10 siblings, He often changed his place of residence and occupation early in life, frequently wandering around Russia as a watchmaker’s apprentice.

In 1905, Yurovsky became acquainted with revolutionaries. Knowing quite well the hardships that Russians faced on a daily basis, he turned into an ardent anti-monarchist, spending several years in exile. Then, 12 years later he welcomed the October Revolution of 1917, which gave power to his comrades – the Bolsheviks.


New appointment

b68f90e4374c46cbda862fee8e8b5d7f6f008a18.jpg
Nicholas II after his abdication

While Vladimir Lenin, Leon Trotsky, and other prominent communist leaders were ruling Soviet Russia from Moscow, Yurovsky was among those working in the Russian hinterland, namely in Yekaterinburg, an important citadel and industrial city in the Urals with a powerful workers’ movement. Loyal to the Communist Party, Yurovsky dutifully performed everything his bosses told him to do.

When he was appointed the commander of the “House of Special Purpose” it meant the Bolsheviks wanted to harden conditions for their royal prisoners.

“They put a steel bar on the only window we had,” ex-empress Alexandra wrote in her diary soon after meeting Yurovsky. “Obviously, they are constantly afraid of us escaping.” On the other hand, Yurovsky, a man of principle, stopped the guards from stealing food from the prisoners, which happened often under his predecessor.


Sloppy execution

176ec8d31b95d5f0f208b818574a2a46c6d74007.jpg
Reconstruction of the massacre of Nicholas II. Frontpage of French newspaper Le Petit Journal Illustre, July 25, 1926

Yurovsky had no sympathy towards his prisoners. Later, in his memoirs, he would write: “My general impression was the following: an ordinary, I would say a bourgeois family… Nicholas himself looked like a petty low-ranking officer… No one would say that the man used to be Czar of such an enormous country for many years.”

Throughout his life, he never showed any signs of guilt for executing the royal family, including the children. His report is laconic: “On July 16, 6 p.m. Filipp Goloshchyokin [Yurovsky’s boss] ordered to execute the prisoners.” By 1 a.m. the next day the Romanovs and their servants were dead.

3451e025bc085dd474c47a7dc7135f98ddfed644.jpg
The cellar where the royal family was shot, after the execution

Yurovsky and his men, however, failed completely in terms of disposal of the bodies – their first plan was to throw the bodies in a deep mine outside the city but it turned out not deep enough, so they had to move the bodies to another site. The weather conditions were severe, and cars couldn’t reach the place “Nothing was prepared, no shovels, nothing…” Yurovsky wrote later.

In the end, they partly burned the bodies and buried them in a shallow grave.


Later life


There was a reason why the Bolsheviks executed the Romanovs in July 1918 - at that time the anti-Bolshevik White Army was close to Yekaterinburg, and there were concerns that the imperial family would be freed and taken out of the country. Soon after plotting the infamous execution, Yakov Yurovsky, along with many other Bolsheviks, had to flee the city.

However, he returned later when the Bolsheviks finally defeated the Whites in 1922. Later, in Moscow and in Yekaterinburg, he worked at many posts - none connected with executions. Yurovsky died in 1938 of a peptic ulcer.
 
Born into a poor Jewish family in

Lmao knew it.

Fun fact: This fucker actually disobeyed orders pretty hard. Both Lenin and Trotsky were pissed that the Tsar was killed as they wanted to have a proper "trial" for him and knew that killing him directly could harm their support with a lot of people who still liked him as a person but hated the government and nobles. Their plans included executing him eventually sure but they wanted it done properly and to try and spare some of the relatives as a way to pretend they were civilized.

Basically they wanted to do what China later managed to do with Pu Yi.
 
One of the scenes shows Yurovsky speaking to Nicholas days before his execution. The two men are sharing a cigarette and Yurovsky recalls how they met each other once before. “1891, I was 10. You were completing your Far East tour. You stopped in Tomsk… I had a little flag, waving it. Just one of the little ants you were nodding and waving at.”
In reality, Yurovsky wouldn’t have bothered to speak with Nicholas II unless it was necessary, let alone share childhood memories.
Lol, of course Netflix is trying to humanize a bloodthirsty communist who gleefully ordered the death of not only Nicholas II, but his children too.
 
What would Russia be like today if the Romanov clan were never massacred?
Two ways to go about that

Russia never gets into WWI, maybe WWI never starts or ends early. Russia is way better off now than it was. Russia was on the cusp of prosperity right before the war due to the slow 2 steps forward 1 step back liberalization of the economy.

Second is Lenin did what was suggested above and spared some, which would be no different from today except that there's more claimants to the throne.
 
What would Russia be like today if the Romanov clan were never massacred?
Realistically not that much would actually change, Nikolai II & his family obviously wouldn't be canonized as saints in the Orthodox Church without having been martyred and the Tsar in particular would probably go down in history as a total failure without any great tragedy to make people go 'aww, we probably shouldn't be too hard on this guy'. The White Russians were not all (quite possibly not even a majority) diehard monarchists and the Entente Powers supporting Aleksandr Kolchak (the nominal leader of all the anti-Bolshevik forces as 'Supreme Ruler of Russia', although in practice he was just the warlord-of-warlords in Siberia) straight up made publicly refusing to restore the monarchy into one of the conditions for their aid. So even if the butterfly effect resulting from the Romanovs escaping Ipatiev House alive leads to a White victory, it's very unlikely that the Romanovs and virtually impossible that Nikolai himself specifically would be restored to power anytime soon.

Best-case outcome at that point would be that Kolchak & the other White leaders (Anton Denikin, Pyotr Wrangel, etc.) don't try to kill each other and the White-formed government persists as a conservative military dictatorship which nonetheless manages to maintain more-or-less complete control over the lands within Russia's borders, like a giga-sized version of Franco's Spain or the Eastern & Central European dictatorships common to this era. In time, they could rebuild the country and seek to reconquer the breakaway states that survived the civil war, from Georgia (historically reabsorbed by the Reds in 1921) to the Baltics & Poland. An imperial restoration after Nikolai's death and people get tired of Kolchak/Kolchak himself gets tired of ruling (he didn't like politics, was terrible at it and was also a poor administrator IRL) is possible but not guaranteed.

Worst case, the White Army chieftains do try to kill each other and Russia basically goes through its own version of the Warlord Era in neighboring China. Knock-on effects outside Russia may well include Nazism failing to rise in Germany due to there not being a great Communist boogeyman for Hitler to point to, the KPD will still cause problems and Weimar will still be the ur-example of a weak & degenerate ramshackle democracy but it's likelier that one of the many conservative militarist putsches eventually succeed and turn Germany into more of a normal right-wing dictatorship than the RL Nazi state.

As an aside, the non-monarchist White Russians did have a pretty cool take on the traditional imperial double-headed eagle IMO. Took away most of the imperial symbols (except that globus cruciger held in one of its talons) and replaced it with martial & religious imagery (that sword, radiant cross & banner reading Си́мъ побѣди́ши!/Simŭ pobědiši! - Russian translation of the Greco-Roman Christian motto In hoc signo vinces/'by this sign you will conquer'). Quite fitting imagery for, as I said above, a conservative military dictatorship.

white-russian-eagle.png
 
Her body was found close to her brother's body, if I'm not mistaken.
The sisters all gathered in around their baby brother and were found covering his body.

Whatever you think of royalty, killing children- children raised to be decent enough that their last act was to try to protect the youngest sibling- tells you a lot about a movement.

The successor of the Bolsheviks is the LGBT groomer gangs.
 
The dude died while many of his friends got purged and his own daughter got sent to the gulag.
The old Bolsheviks may have been atheists that did not believe in hell but Stalin made sure their last days were a living one.
The Romanovs could rest easily knowing their killers didn't have a happy future.
 
He should've gone a little bit high in the head. Fellow didn't even killed me.

But now I'm blind in one eye, so fuck him for blowing up one of my fucking eyes.

Being serious for a moment, there is a huge level of satisfaction knowing that this hobo died a very painful death in the gulag, he and the perpetrators of killing the Romanov dynasty got what was coming to them. Divine punishment, if you will.
 
The Romanovs could rest easily knowing their killers didn't have a happy future.
I doubt that would make them rest easily. The Bolsheviks killed off and chased away all of the Russia's best people, the patriotic educated higher class. They effectively murdered the Russian nation only leaving blank slate peasants and traitors in their wake to have Russia be a mindless red golem for a hundred years. That was, shall we say, a huge L.
 
I doubt that would make them rest easily. The Bolsheviks killed off and chased away all of the Russia's best people, the patriotic educated higher class. They effectively murdered the Russian nation only leaving blank slate peasants and traitors in their wake to have Russia be a mindless red golem for a hundred years. That was, shall we say, a huge L.
Except that mindless peasant state is exactly what Lenin and friends wanted. They could rebuild Russia into the society they wanted because those same mindless drones wouldn't push back, either because they were afraid, were controlled, or were dead. The rest would just go along with what the Party wanted, and lest we forget, the Party (as defined by those at the top) ALWAYS knew what was best.

It was just Lenin and Stalin and Trotsky and the rest didn't count on normal Russians (and East Germans and Poles and Slovaks, and the rest) seeing blue jeans and pizza and rock music as something they wanted in on.
 
Back