A Fraser Valley naturopath has filed a legal action against his professional regulator, alleging it doesn't have the power to stop him from producing fecal transplants in his B.C. lab to administer to autistic children in Mexico.
Last month, the College of Naturopathic Physicians of B.C. ordered Jason Klop to stop producing pills or enemas made from human feces, saying it was necessary to take "extraordinary action" to protect the public while an investigation is underway.
In response, Klop has filed a petition in B.C. Supreme Court asking for a judge to step in and quash the college's action. That document includes allegations that the college has overstepped its powers by setting guidelines outside its jurisdiction to regulate the practice of naturopathy.
The college, it says, "has no mandate to purport to protect patients who are receiving treatment in Mexico or any other place outside British Columbia or otherwise restrict the treatment choices of patients outside British Columbia."
As for the regulation of fecal transplant products, Klop argues that's the domain of Health Canada.
None of the allegations in the petition have been proven in court and the college has yet to file a response. Asked for comment, college registrar Carina Herman said the college has received the petition and will file its response "in due course."
As first reported in January 2020, Klop has been charging parents about $15,000 US for autistic children as young as two years old to have fecal microbiota transplants (FMT) at a clinic in the oceanside Mexican city of Rosarito.
FMT treatments involve taking bacteria and other microbes from the poop of a healthy person and transferring them to a patient either anally or orally, with the goal of restoring a normal environment inside the gut.
An illustration shows how fecal microbiota transplants are produced. (Vancouver Island Health Authority)
The process isn't legal in either Canada or the United States for anything other than treatment of recurrent C. difficile infection that hasn't responded to other therapies.
Doctors and scientists have warned that any other use of this emerging therapy is experimental and carries serious risk of infection, while autistic advocates have denounced Klop's procedure as an unproven treatment that puts vulnerable children in danger.
Klop claims he is 'compliant with federal laws'
The college said it stepped in to prohibit Klop from making, advertising or selling FMT products in response to a complaint from a former employee, who alleged he manufactured these products in a "household lab" in B.C. without standard procedures or quality control.According to an Aug. 19 decision from the college's inquiry committee, the unidentified whistleblower provided shipping labels and invoices showing that Klop had exported his pills and enemas to Denmark, Edmonton and across the U.S.
Though Klop has defended the health and safety measures in his lab, the college said the more pressing concern is that he is clearly producing and selling FMT for purposes that are not allowed in Canada, which puts the public at risk.
- Autistic advocates say 'it's a start' after Canada takes action on naturopath's fecal transplant biz
He argues that he "has always been compliant with federal laws" and that he consults with Health Canada to make sure he is following the rules.
"Donors are regularly tested in accordance with standard operating procedures in line with best industry practice and Health Canada guidance documents," the petition reads.
The power of poop: What fecal transplants can and cannot treat
2 years ago2:39
Fecal transplants have shown a lot of promise for illnesses like C. difficile. As the treatment’s claimed list of uses grows, we debunk the myths 2:39
Health Canada has initiated at least two investigations into Klop's operation.
Last year, the federal body banned him from accepting Canadian patients at his Mexican retreats, and according to the college, it also opened an investigation into the former employee's complaint.
Klop's petition maintains that federal agents have inspected his new lab and spoken to him about best practices, and says Health Canada informed him on July 27 that it will not be taking further action against him.
CBC News has reached out to Health Canada for comment on that assertion.
- B.C. naturopath's pricey fecal transplants for autism are experimental and risky, scientists say
- Taking children with autism to Mexico for fecal transplants 'out of scope' for naturopaths, regulator says
The latest iteration of his business, Novel Biome, was incorporated in B.C. last year, using an address in an office complex in Chilliwack. In a promotional video posted on the website in January, Klop says he believes that "precision manipulation of the gut microbiome will solve every single chronic disease."
In response to CBC's reporting on Klop's business last year, the B.C. Naturopathic Association, a volunteer professional organization, voted to suspend Klop's membership.
